FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved

Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family

Contents 31
PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Staying Beside
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Staying Beside
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Grief in Scripture and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Grief in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Death, Funeral and Remembrance
  3. Lecture 1-3: Grief Is Love in Another Form
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Death and Loss
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Around the Funeral
  1. Lecture 2-1: The First Days
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Funeral Season Beside the Family
  3. Lecture 2-3: Words That Hurt, Words That Help
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practical Help That Is Specific
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A First Visit
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Different Losses
  1. Lecture 3-1: Sudden Death
  2. Lecture 3-2: Long Illness, and the Death of an Older Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth
  4. Lecture 3-4: Suicide Loss: Standing Beside Without Stigma
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Standing Differently for Different Losses
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Children, Teenagers and the Family
  1. Lecture 4-1: Grieving Children
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grieving Teenagers
  3. Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family
  4. Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Talking With a Child, Standing Between Relatives
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Long Accompaniment and Referral
  1. Lecture 5-1: Anniversaries and the Long Months
  2. Lecture 5-2: Long Accompaniment
  3. Lecture 5-3: When Grief Needs More Help: Noticing and Connecting
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases and an Anniversary Card
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Carer and the Congregation
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Carer's Own Losses
  2. Lecture 6-2: Limits, Rest and Not Being the Fixer
  3. Lecture 6-3: A Church That Cares for the Bereaved Over Years
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Kinds of Community
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Bereavement Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

A death brings a family together, and it can also bring out old differences. People who love each other grieve in different ways and at different speeds, and they are tired, frightened and often short of sleep. In the weeks after a death there are decisions to make quickly: about the funeral, the home, the belongings, the money, who will care for whom. A sentence said at the wrong moment can open a quarrel that lasts for years. Brothers and sisters stop speaking. A widow and her husband's grown children disagree about the house. A son thinks his sister is hiding in work; she thinks he does not care. It is one of the most common, and most quietly painful, parts of grief, and it is rarely mentioned at the funeral.

This lecture asks what a church carer can and cannot do when a bereaved family is divided. The carer is not a judge, a mediator trained for family disputes, a lawyer or a therapist. The carer can listen to each person, keep each one's confidence, refuse to carry tales, make a little room for calm, and help the family find the right professional for the law, the money or the hard conversation. The central claim of the course returns: grief is not an illness; it is love in another form. A church carer is not a fixer but someone who stays beside. The carer does not hurry, does not prescribe stages, helps more by presence than by words, and connects to professionals when more help is needed. The carer has losses and limits too. A family quarrel is often grief in an angry form, and a carer who sees it that way is slower to take sides.

This course is not grief therapy, not legal advice and not family counselling, and it gives no medical or psychological advice. It does not describe any method of mediation. It prepares a carer to be present and to know when to help a family find a professional.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Explain why differing styles of grieving, and differing needs, can look like conflict in a bereaved family.
  • Name the common points of conflict after a death: the funeral, belongings, money and inheritance, roles, and care of those who remain.
  • Describe what a carer does and does not do when a family is divided, including taking no side and keeping confidences.
  • Say why the law and money are matters for a lawyer, checking locally, and not for the carer or the church.
  • Explain why safety is not a matter for balance, and what a carer does if there is fear, violence, abuse or a vulnerable person at risk.
  • Name general ways of opening a little room for calm, and say when to refer a family to a professional.

When Joseph’s brothers saw that their father was dead, they said, “It may be that Joseph will hate us, and will fully pay us back for all of the evil which we did to him.”" — Genesis 50:15

World English Bible

Joseph said to them, “Don’t be afraid, for am I in the place of God?" — Genesis 50:19

WEB

Now therefore don’t be afraid. I will nourish you and your little ones.” He comforted them, and spoke kindly to them." — Genesis 50:21

WEB

One of the multitude said to him, “Teacher, tell my brother to divide the inheritance with me.”" — Luke 12:13

WEB

But he said to him, “Man, who made me a judge or an arbitrator over you?”" — Luke 12:14

WEB

If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18

WEB

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1

WEB

See how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to live together in unity!" — Psalm 133:1

WEB

Genesis 50:15 shows a family quarrel after a death. When their father Jacob died, Joseph's brothers feared that Joseph would now pay them back for the wrong they had done him. Grief and old fear arrived together. Genesis 50:19 gives Joseph's first answer: he asks whether he stands in the place of God. Genesis 50:21 records that he comforted them and spoke kindly to them. The story is not a pattern for every family, because the people and the wrongs are different, but it shows that a death can wake what was buried, and that kindness in speech is part of the way forward. Luke 12:13 and 12:14 show a man asking Jesus to settle an inheritance. Jesus declines to act as judge or arbitrator over the brothers. Whatever else the passage teaches, it is a reminder that disputes about property are real, that a wise person may refuse to decide them, and that a carer need not decide them either. Romans 12:18 asks us to be at peace with everyone as far as it depends on us, and Proverbs 15:1 says that a gentle answer turns away wrath. Psalm 133:1 describes the goodness of brothers living in unity. It is a hope and not a rule, and not every family reaches it. A carer does not use these verses to press anyone to be reconciled.

1. Why bereaved families quarrel

A family in grief is not at its best. Several things push people into conflict at once.

People grieve differently. One wants to talk about the dead person all day, and another cannot bear to hear the name. One cries openly, another works. One wants the house kept as it was, another wants to clear it. One goes to the grave every week, another never goes. Each may think the other is wrong, or does not care. Differences in style are not differences in love. Lecture 1-3 spoke of the many shapes of grief, and the family is where those shapes meet most closely.

Tiredness and shock. Decisions are being made when people have slept little, eaten poorly and are in no state to think. A remark that would be forgiven in an ordinary week is not forgiven now.

Old patterns return. Every family has its habits: who leads, who gives way, who was the favourite, who was the one who left, who stayed to do the caring. A death can bring these back with new force. A sibling who looked after a parent through a long illness may feel that others who arrived at the end now want a say. A person who lived far away may feel shut out. An old injury may surface, and the person who could have settled it has died.

Unfinished business. Some people carry things they wish they had said or settled with the one who died. The wish may turn into blame of someone else.

The living relationships change. The death alters who is head of the family, who holds the memory, who is looked to for decisions. These changes are rarely agreed, and they can seem like grabs for power when they are really loss.

A carer who understands these pressures can look at a quarrel with some patience, and not as proof that a family is wicked. This is not an excuse for harm, as the section on safety will say. But it helps the carer to avoid a quick judgment.

2. Where the conflict tends to gather

The funeral. Who decides? Burial or cremation, the place, the form, the music, the people who speak, who is invited, how much is spent. Families differ in their traditions, in their faith, in what the one who died wished, and in how much money there is. Where there are different religions in the family, or a mix of customs, or a custom that some relatives hold strongly and others reject (lecture 1-2 spoke of the dispute over rites for ancestors in some churches), the funeral can become the place where everything is fought out. The local rules about who may decide, and about what is permitted, differ by country and region: check locally. The carer does not decide. The minister and the family do.

Belongings. Who takes what, who keeps the photographs, who gets the ring or the tools or the Bible. Objects hold memory, and the argument is rarely about the object. A carer who hears "she took Mother's necklace" is hearing grief.

Money and inheritance. Wills, debts, a house, a business, a share of land, the cost of the funeral, the support of a surviving parent or a younger sibling. The law differs widely by country, region and family circumstance, and customs differ as much as laws. The carer gives no advice about it, takes no view about who is owed what, and does not suggest what is fair in a particular case. A lawyer or a person with proper training in local law is the right person to ask. The carer can say, "That is a matter for someone who knows the law here. Shall I help you think about who to ask?"

Roles and care. Who looks after the surviving parent, the children left behind, a sibling with special needs. Who gives up work, who pays, who moves house. These questions can be heavy, and the answers cost real things.

Who is told, and how. Who calls whom, who is told first, who is left out. A relative who hears by chance, or after others, may take it as a slight.

Faith. Disagreement about how to speak of the death, whether a priest should come, what the family believes about the dead. The carer follows the family's own traditions and does not correct them. Lecture 5-4 sets out the differences fairly.

3. What the carer does not do

The carer does not take a side. A person who has been wronged, or thinks so, will naturally want the carer to agree. A carer who says "You are right, she was unfair" has made an enemy of the other person, and has made it harder for the family to come together later. The carer can say, "I can hear how much this hurts," without saying who is right.

The carer does not judge from one person's account. Every person in a quarrel tells the story in a way that makes sense to them. A carer who has heard only one side does not know the other. The carer can say, "I only know this part of it. I would not want to say more than I know."

The carer does not carry tales. What one person says in confidence to the carer is not repeated to another, except where someone is in danger, and local rules differ: check locally. A carer who passes messages between relatives, however kindly meant, is likely to distort them and to become part of the quarrel. If one person asks, "Please tell my brother what I said", the carer can reply, "I think it would be better coming from you. Can I help you think about how?"

The carer does not decide the money or the law. As above.

The carer does not use Scripture as a weapon. A carer who quotes "honour your father and mother" or "forgive as the Lord forgave you" to a person in the middle of a quarrel is using it to press them. Scripture is not a way of winning. Joseph's brothers, in the passage at the head of this lecture, are not told what to do by a bystander. The carer does not quote verses on forgiveness or peace to push anyone toward a reconciliation they are not ready for.

The carer does not try to be a mediator in a serious dispute. Mediation is a skill, and it also depends on safety (see below). A carer is not trained for a family dispute over inheritance or care. A carer who tries to settle one risks making it worse.

4. What the carer can do

Listen to each person, separately, and stay calm. A person who can say all of it to someone who does not argue back often feels a little lighter. The carer says back what has been heard: "You feel that you were left to do the caring and nobody thanked you." The carer does not add to it.

Name the grief under the anger. Gently, and when the person is ready, the carer can say, "It sounds as if you miss her very much." Many quarrels soften a little when the loss is spoken. The carer does this lightly, and does not say "You're only angry because you're grieving", which sounds like dismissal.

Slow things down. Decisions made in the first days are often regretted. Where a decision does not need to be made at once, the carer can say, "Does this have to be decided this week?" Some things have a limit in time (a funeral date, a legal deadline), and the carer does not delay those. But many things can wait, and a family often fights less once people have slept. The belongings of someone who died do not need to be cleared in the first month, unless the family needs to.

Keep what is shared apart from what is divided. A family may find that they agree on the form of the funeral and disagree on the house. The carer can help each matter to be spoken of separately: "Could we deal with the service first, and leave the house for another day?"

Offer simple ground rules, if people are willing. For example: one matter at a time; each person speaks for themselves and not for the others; no raised voices; a pause is allowed; no decisions in the first hour. These are modest principles of respect, and they do not amount to mediation. If a family wants to meet to talk, a carer might offer a quiet room and a cup of tea, and might sit in for a short while if asked. The carer does not chair, does not decide, and does not pretend the meeting has more weight than it does.

Find the right person. A lawyer or a person trained in local law for the will and the money. A trained family mediator or counsellor for a dispute that has become stuck. The minister, for the form of the funeral and the church's own practice. A doctor or other professional for a person whose grief is heavy. The carer helps a family to find these people, and, if the family wishes, helps them to prepare their questions. Lecture 5-3 returns to connecting. The course on marriage and family care covers the family in more depth, and the counselling ethics course covers referral.

Care for the person who stands between. In many families there is one who is the go-between, the peacemaker, the one who rings everybody. This person is often exhausted, and they are rarely asked how they are. The carer can ask.

Keep coming. A dispute does not end at the funeral. The weeks and months afterwards are often when the real division shows. The carer who continues to call, to each person in turn, helps keep the way open.

5. Safety is not neutral

The carer's refusal to take sides has a limit, and the limit is safety. A carer takes no side in a quarrel. A carer takes the side of safety.

If any person in the family is afraid of another; if there is violence, threat or intimidation; if one person is being controlled, shut out or forced to sign or agree to something; if an older person, a person with a disability or a child is being pressed, neglected or put at risk; if there is a worry that someone may harm themselves or another, then the carer is no longer in the position of "listening to both sides". Balance between a person who is afraid and a person who is frightening them is not fairness.

In that case the carer:

  • believes the person who says they are afraid, and does not minimise it;
  • does not bring the two people together to "talk it through";
  • does not tell the other person what has been said;
  • helps the person who is afraid to find safe help: a trusted pastor or priest, a doctor, and the proper services. The carer helps the person to research in advance, and keep at hand, the names of local services, without this course naming any, and the local emergency services if the danger is now;
  • passes a concern about a child or a vulnerable adult to the person that the church's safe-church policy names, because reporting duties differ by country, region and role: check locally.

The course on marriage and family care treats domestic abuse in more depth, and the safe church course covers a community's duties toward children and vulnerable people. If any person speaks of wishing to die, or of wanting to join the one who has died, the crisis course applies.

A carer who is unsure whether what they have heard is a dispute or a danger asks someone with experience: the minister, an or a safe-church lead. The point is to ask before acting, and to act at once if someone is in danger now.

6. When a carer is pulled in

A carer may find themselves pulled in despite their care. A relative may ask the carer to speak at the funeral about reconciliation. A faction may try to have the carer on its side. A person may ask the carer to hold money, documents or keys. The carer may be a member of the family, with feelings of their own.

Some guidelines. Keep clear of money and documents: the carer does not hold, sign or witness anything, and does not act as an executor or a guardian, unless a proper arrangement exists and the church's policy allows it. Tell the minister or a senior person when the situation is beyond a carer's role. Refuse, kindly, to be the messenger. Step back if the carer's own feelings or relationships make fairness impossible, and ask another to take the visits. A carer who is a relative of the family says so, and may be better to be a relative than a carer.

7. Small and large communities

(an invented example) In a village church, an old man, Mr Fernandes, died. His sons, Paolo and Daniel, argued the day after the funeral about who should take the small family plot of land. Paolo had stayed and worked it; Daniel had gone to the city. The elder who visited, Mr Hossain, listened to each on his own. Paolo said, "I gave my life to that land." Daniel said, "I sent money every month." Mr Hossain did not say who was right. He said to each, "Your father is gone, and you both miss him." Then he said, "This is a matter for the law and for the two of you, not for me. I will help you find someone who knows the local rules, and I would ask you both to wait until after the first month." He did not repeat to either what the other had said. In a small place everyone knows everyone, and the risk is that a carer who is friend to both becomes a messenger. His restraint kept him a friend to both.

(an invented example) In a large church, a woman named Mrs Zielinski died, leaving a husband and three adult children from an earlier marriage. The children and the husband quarrelled about the funeral. The church's bereavement coordinator, Ms Tanaka, noticed that two of the children said they were afraid to speak at the meeting because of the way the husband shouted. She did not arrange a joint meeting. She spoke to the minister, who spoke to the husband alone, and who helped the children to speak at the funeral in a way that did not require a confrontation. Later she gave one of the children the name of a person at a family services office, and offered to find more if wanted. In a large community the strength is a person whose role it is to notice, and the risk is that a quarrel is passed from person to person until no one has seen the whole.

8. Summary of what to remember

A bereaved family's quarrel is often grief in an angry form. The carer listens to each person, takes no side, carries no tales, and does not decide the money or the law. The carer can slow things down, separate what is shared from what is divided, and offer a quiet place. The carer finds the right professional, and keeps coming. But safety is not neutral: where there is fear, violence, abuse or a vulnerable person at risk, the carer takes the side of safety, does not bring the parties together, and seeks help from the proper services.


Diagram 1. What the carer does when a family is divided

A divided family: the carer's part No side. No tales. No decisions about law or money. What the carer does not do Takes a side or judges from one account Carries messages between relatives Decides the money, the will, the house Quotes Scripture to press for peace Chairs a serious dispute Holds money, documents or keys What the carer can do Listens to each person on their own Names the grief under the anger Slows down what can wait Separates one matter from another Finds the right professional; check locally Keeps coming, to each person Safety is not neutral Fear, violence, control or a vulnerable person at risk: no joint meeting; safe help first.

Diagram 2. Where the quarrels gather

Six places a family disagrees Under each one there is usually a loss. The funeral Form, place, cost, who decides Minister and family; check locally Belongings Photographs, rings, tools, a Bible Objects hold memory Money and inheritance Wills, debts, land, a home A lawyer; check locally Roles and care Who looks after whom, who pays Who gives up work or moves Who is told, and how Who was left out, who heard late Slights that feel like verdicts Faith and custom What to say, what rites, which priest Follow the family; do not correct

In short

  • Bereaved families quarrel because people grieve differently, are tired and frightened, face urgent decisions, and meet old patterns again.
  • Conflicts gather around the funeral, belongings, money and inheritance, roles and care, who is told, and faith or custom.
  • The carer takes no side, judges from no single account, carries no tales and does not decide the law or the money.
  • The carer listens to each person, names the grief under the anger, slows what can wait, and helps the family find the right professional.
  • Safety is not neutral: where there is fear, violence, control or a vulnerable person at risk, the carer takes the side of safety and holds no joint meeting.
  • The law, wills and property are for a lawyer, checking locally; the carer holds no money or documents.
Front Back
Why families quarrel Different styles of grieving, tiredness, urgent decisions, old patterns, unfinished business and changed roles.
What the carer does not do Take a side, judge from one account, carry tales, decide law or money, press with Scripture, chair a serious dispute.
What the carer can do Listen to each, name the grief, slow down, separate matters, find the right professional, keep coming.
Safety Not neutral: fear, violence, control or someone vulnerable at risk means no joint meeting and safe help first.

One sentence to remember In a divided bereaved family the carer takes no side, carries no tales and leaves the law to the lawyer, but always takes the side of safety.

This week's action Write down what you would say to someone who asks you to carry a message to a relative, and list two kinds of local professional you could help a family find.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why might two people in the same family grieve in ways that look like conflict? What would you say to each if both told you the other did not care?
  • A relative asks you to tell her brother something she is too angry to say. What do you do, and what do you say?
  • Why does the carer leave the law and the money to others? What kinds of professional might you help a family find where you live?
  • Where does the line fall between "taking no side" and "taking the side of safety"? What would make you ask a senior person for help?
  • Who is the go-between in a family you know of, in general terms, and how could a carer care for that person?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.