Lecture 3-1: Choosing Songs
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Planning Worship Is, and Is Not
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Gathering
- Lecture 1-3: Shapes of a Service
- Lecture 1-4: Welcome, Transitions and Silence
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read One Service
- Lecture 2-1: Who Serves
- Lecture 2-2: Calling, Trying Out and Saying No
- Lecture 2-3: Training, Rotas and Rest
- Lecture 2-4: Rehearsal and the Week Before Sunday
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Team
- Lecture 3-1: Choosing Songs
- Lecture 3-2: The Congregation's Voice
- Lecture 3-3: Leading Without Performing
- Lecture 3-4: Permission to Use Music
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Month of Songs
- Lecture 4-1: Where Traditions Differ on Art
- Lecture 4-2: Seeing, Moving, Reading Aloud
- Lecture 4-3: The Room
- Lecture 4-4: Worship Everyone Can Join
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Walk the Room
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Words and Sound
- Lecture 5-2: Recording and Streaming
- Lecture 5-3: Those Who Join Online
- Lecture 5-4: Testing a Tool
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Slide, One Broadcast
A song list looks like a small decision. Four or five titles, written on a sheet. But the people will sing these words with their own mouths, in front of God and in front of each other. For some of them it will be the longest speech they make all week. A song says what the people believe, what they ask for and what they promise, and they say it in the first person.
So choosing a song is not choosing a mood. It is choosing words for other people to say, in a tune they can manage. This lecture gives you a way to test a song before it goes on the sheet. We start with the words, then the tune, then the fit with the day. We end with a checklist you can use alone, with a book, with a phone, or with a committee.
The principle of this week is the filter for everything below: a song is chosen for the people who must sing it, in the voices they have.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Test the words of a song against Scripture, against the persons of the Trinity, and against the range of what people need to say to God.
- Judge whether a tune can be sung by the people who will be there, looking at range, rhythm, length and language.
- Describe the strength and the danger of hymns, chant, modern songs, and local or migrant music, without ranking them.
- Fit a song to a season, a reading and a place in the service.
- Use a written checklist to accept, change or refuse a song.
Sing to Yahweh a new song, for he has done marvelous things! His right hand, and his holy arm, have worked salvation for him." — Psalm 98:1
World English Bible
Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly; in all wisdom teaching and admonishing one another with psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your heart to the Lord." — Colossians 3:16
WEB
speaking to one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs; singing, and making melody in your heart to the Lord;" — Ephesians 5:19
WEB
The psalm gives the reason to sing: God has acted. The two letters add something easy to miss. Singing is also "teaching and admonishing one another" and "speaking to one another." A song is addressed to God, and it is also heard by the neighbour in the next seat. The words you choose will teach that neighbour, for good or for harm.
1. Start with the people, not the song
Most song lists begin the wrong way round. Someone remembers a song they love, or a song they heard last week, and then looks for a place to put it. A better order is the reverse. First ask who will be in the room and what the day is. Then ask what the people need to say to God. Then look for a song.
You will have done some of this already in the first week of this course, when you read the gathering. If you have thirty people, three of them children, two learning the language, one who cannot read well and one old man who knows only the songs of his youth, that is your singing congregation. It is not the congregation you wish you had.
2. The words
Words come first, because the tune only carries them. Four questions test them.
1. Is it faithful to Scripture? Not "does it quote a verse," but "does what it says agree with what the Bible says?" A song can contain no Bible quotation and still be faithful. A song can be made of Bible phrases and still twist them, for example by taking a promise made to one person in one story and singing it as a general guarantee. When a line is doubtful, ask the person responsible for teaching in your community. Traditions differ on how much a song may go beyond the words of Scripture; some sing only the psalms, some sing hymns of the church's history, some sing newly written songs. This course requires only that the words do not contradict what your community teaches from Scripture.
2. Does it name the God we worship? Many Christians hold that the heart of worship is the Father, through the Son, in the Spirit. You do not need every song to say all three. But look across a month of songs. If the Son is never mentioned, or the Spirit never, or God is only "you" and "the Lord" with no story attached, the people are learning a thin faith through their singing. The test is not mathematical. It is a question: over the weeks, does the God we sing to sound like the God of the Bible?
3. Does it leave room for more than one feeling? The Psalms contain praise, thanks and joy, and they also contain lament, confession, complaint, fear, anger turned toward God, and silence. A congregation that only ever sings glad songs is quietly told that sad people do not belong in the room. A congregation that only sings sad songs is told the opposite. Look across the month. Is there a song for the person who has just buried someone? Is there a song for the one who has just been given a child?
4. Who is speaking, and to whom? Look at the pronouns. "I" songs are personal and can be precise, but they put the singer's private experience on every mouth: if the song says "I always feel your joy," the person who does not feel it sings a false line. "We" songs say what the whole church holds. Songs to God ("you") and songs about God ("he") do different work, and both are in the psalms. None of these is wrong. A list made only of one kind is thin.
Here is how a short test works on an invented song line.
(An invented example.) The line: "Nothing can ever trouble me now, for I am carried high on joy." The first question: is it faithful? It is not a quotation from Scripture, and Scripture itself speaks of troubles that remain. The third question: what does the grieving person do with this line? Either they sing something that is not true for them today, or they stop singing. The line is not wicked. But the leader may decide it belongs in a thanksgiving service with a verse of lament beside it, and not on a day when half the room has come from a funeral.
3. The tune and the singers
Even good words fail if the people cannot sing them. Test the tune with five questions.
Range. Many adult voices without training are comfortable across about an octave, and many are uncomfortable on notes far above or below their speaking voice. A tune that starts low and climbs to a high note on the key word will be sung by a few and heard by the rest. If you can choose the key, choose it for the people and not for the leader. Lecture 3-2 returns to this.
Rhythm. Songs with complicated off-beat patterns are easy to sing for people who have heard them often and hard for people who have not. A hymn that follows the natural rhythm of its words is learned quickly. A song with a syncopated line that only the band understands is a song for the band.
Length and repetition. Repetition can help a person pray: the same line sung again makes room for the heart to catch up with the mouth. It can also become a way to fill time. Judge by what the repeated words are doing. If they are a short prayer, repetition may deepen it. If a line of little content is repeated many times to build the sound, ask what the people are being led to.
Language. If the room has more than one language, ask how each group will sing. Can the song be sung in two languages by turns? Is there a simple refrain everyone can learn? A song in a language that half the room does not understand can still be sung if the meaning is first explained, but people cannot say "amen" to words they have not understood.
Age. A song written for teenagers may be too fast for the old; a hymn with long words may exclude the child. You do not need one song for all. You need to look over the month and ask who has sung and who has watched.
4. Many kinds of song
Each kind has a strength and a danger. None is better.
- Hymns carry doctrine and the memory of the church. A hymn learned in childhood is often remembered when other memory fades. The danger is old vocabulary that no one now understands, or verses sung while the mind is elsewhere.
- Chant and sung psalms carry the words of Scripture itself and are, in many traditions, the church's oldest singing. A simple chant can be learned by ear without a book. The danger is that a chant sung only by a trained few becomes a performance, and that a plain tone sung without attention becomes a habit.
- Modern songs speak in the language people use now and often fit the life of younger members. The danger is that they are written for a particular band, a particular recording and a particular sound, and a small congregation cannot reproduce that. They may also rise and fall in fashion faster than the faith they carry can be tested.
- Local and migrant music gives the people their own voices. A song from a mother tongue, a work song reworked as a prayer, a tune brought from another country: these tell the people that God hears them as they are. The danger is the opposite of the first: a song can be chosen only to show variety, or can be taken from another culture without asking what it means there. Where possible, ask someone from that culture how the song is used.
A congregation may use one of these, or all. Many mix them. The question is the same for each: can these people sing it, and are the words true?
5. Fitting the day
A good song may be wrong for a day. Three things help the fit.
The season. Where your community keeps a church year, the seasons already suggest what to sing. Where it does not, the local calendar of harvest, school terms and hard times still matters. (The church year belongs to PT731E.)
The passage. If the sermon or reading of the day is on one theme, a song that sings the same theme helps the people carry it home. A song unconnected with the day is not forbidden; but a month of songs that echo nothing in the readings turns worship into a collection.
The place in the service. A song that gathers people at the start is not the song for the moment after confession. A quiet song may be right before prayer and wrong for a procession. When the order of service has parts (lecture 1-3), ask what each song is doing in that part.
6. A checklist
Write it small enough to keep in a Bible or on a phone.
- Words: true to Scripture and to our community's teaching?
- God: does the month show the Father, the Son and the Spirit?
- Feeling: is there room for thanks, sorrow, confession and praise across the month?
- Voices: can our people sing the range, the rhythm and the length?
- Language: can everyone understand, or is there a plan to help?
- Fit: does it suit the season, the reading, the place in the service?
- Permission: may we use it in the way we plan? (Lecture 3-4.)
- Instrument: can we lead it with what we have?
A song does not have to pass every point on its first reading. But a song that fails the first, the fourth or the seventh should be changed or left out.
Diagram 1. The song filter
Diagram 2. Four kinds of song
| Kind | Strength | Danger to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Hymn | Carries teaching and the church's memory | Old words nobody understands; singing without attention |
| Chant and sung psalm | Carries Scripture itself; learned by ear | Becomes a show for a few, or a bare habit |
| Modern song | Speaks in today's language; close to younger people | Built for a band and a recording; quick to date |
| Local or migrant song | Lets people sing in their own voice | Chosen for variety only, or taken without asking what it means |
In short
- Choose a song for the people who must sing it, in the voices they have; the words come first and the tune carries them.
- Test words four ways: true to Scripture, naming the God we worship, room for more than one feeling, and clear about who speaks to whom.
- Test the tune by range, rhythm, length, language and age; the leader's comfortable key is not the people's.
- Hymns, chant, modern songs and local songs each have a strength and a danger; none is better than another.
- Fit a song to the season, the reading and its place in the service, and check permission to use it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four tests for words | True to Scripture; names the God we worship; room for more than one feeling; clear who speaks to whom. |
| Five tests for a tune | Range, rhythm, length and repetition, language, age. |
| Why vary the kinds of song | Each kind has a strength and a danger; a month drawn from several protects the people from the danger of one. |
| Where the song fits | The season, the reading of the day, and the part of the service it serves. |
One sentence to remember A song is chosen for the people who must sing it, in the voices they have.
This week's action Take the last four songs your gathering sang and run each through the checklist in this lecture. Write one change you would make.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of the last month of songs in a gathering you know. Over that month, which feelings did the songs make room for, and which did they leave out?
- When you read a song's words, do you more often ask "do I like it?" or "is it true?" What would change if you asked the second first?
- Which kind of song in this lecture is easiest for your people to sing, and which is hardest? What is the reason in each case?
- Why might repetition help one person pray and trap another in noise? How would you tell the difference from the front?
- Colossians 3:16 says singing teaches and admonishes. What might a neighbour learn about God from your last month of songs?