Lecture 4-2: Seeing, Moving, Reading Aloud
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Planning Worship Is, and Is Not
- Lecture 1-2: Reading the Gathering
- Lecture 1-3: Shapes of a Service
- Lecture 1-4: Welcome, Transitions and Silence
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Read One Service
- Lecture 2-1: Who Serves
- Lecture 2-2: Calling, Trying Out and Saying No
- Lecture 2-3: Training, Rotas and Rest
- Lecture 2-4: Rehearsal and the Week Before Sunday
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Map Your Team
- Lecture 3-1: Choosing Songs
- Lecture 3-2: The Congregation's Voice
- Lecture 3-3: Leading Without Performing
- Lecture 3-4: Permission to Use Music
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, A Month of Songs
- Lecture 4-1: Where Traditions Differ on Art
- Lecture 4-2: Seeing, Moving, Reading Aloud
- Lecture 4-3: The Room
- Lecture 4-4: Worship Everyone Can Join
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Walk the Room
- Lecture 5-1: Screens, Words and Sound
- Lecture 5-2: Recording and Streaming
- Lecture 5-3: Those Who Join Online
- Lecture 5-4: Testing a Tool
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Slide, One Broadcast
Lecture 4-1 asked what a room says. This lecture asks what happens in the room: what people look at, what their bodies do, and whose voices are heard. Candles, coloured cloth, a procession, a dance, a reading shared between several people, a short drama, a pause with no sound at all. These are the "actions" of worship. Each is a kind of art, and each can bring people into the service or turn them into an audience.
That last danger is the main subject. A congregation can sit and watch a skilled dancer, a beautiful reading, or a clever drama and go home having been entertained and having answered nothing. The same dancer, the same reading, the same drama can also be a way for the whole room to join in. The difference is not in the art. It is in what the plan asks the people to do.
We look at six kinds of action, one test for all of them, and the practical questions that follow: who prepares, who may take part, what to do with an outside artist, and where the children stand.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Use one test to tell whether an action brings the people in or makes them watchers.
- Describe the use, the strength and the danger of candles, movement, shared reading, short drama and silence.
- Prepare a reading for several voices, including a part for the whole room.
- Plan the visit of an outside artist so that the community's rules and the safety of children are kept.
- Include children as takers-part, not as decoration or as a show.
Let them praise his name in the dance! Let them sing praises to him with tambourine and harp!" — Psalm 149:3
World English Bible
Miriam the prophetess, the sister of Aaron, took a tambourine in her hand; and all the women went out after her with tambourines and with dances." — Exodus 15:20
WEB
Both verses describe praise that used the body, and in both the people did it together. Miriam did not dance while Israel watched. "All the women went out after her."
1. One test: where do the people's eyes, voice and body go?
Every action in worship can be put to a simple test. Ask three things.
Where are the people's eyes? On the Word, on the table, on the person who leads, on a performer, on a screen, on one another?
Where is the people's voice? Do they speak, sing, answer, or only listen?
What are the people's bodies doing? Sitting still, standing, kneeling, walking, holding something, raising hands?
A service in which the eyes are always on one person, the voice is always one person's, and the body is always still is a service that has turned the room into an audience. That may be the right pattern for a short time: a sermon is mostly listening, and nobody is wronged by that. The question is not whether people ever listen. It is whether the plan gives them, somewhere, something to do.
Notice that this test does not rank traditions. A liturgical service often has the people's voices and bodies moving in set patterns: they stand, kneel, respond, and process. A quiet meeting may give the people's voices to each person in turn. A Spirit-led gathering may let anyone speak or sing. Each of these answers the test in its own way.
(An invented example.) A planner draws a line under every item in next Sunday's order and writes E, V or B beside it, for eyes, voice, body. The result is a column full of E's and a few V's. There are no B's. She does not conclude that the service is wrong. She notices that a child in the third row will sit still for fifty minutes, and she looks for one place where the whole room can stand or move together. The question, "What do the bodies do?", would not have occurred to her without the test.
2. Candles and light
A candle is one of the oldest signs in worship, and it is one of the simplest to understand. A small flame in a dark room draws the eye, asks for quiet, and speaks of light. Many communities light candles at the start of a service, at a reading, or before an icon. Others do not use them at all, because they see no need for them or because they wish the room to be plain.
Use. To mark a beginning, to mark a place, to give the eye something to rest on during a prayer.
Strength. It is cheap, it is silent, and it can be understood without words by a child.
Danger. Fire. Smoke. A lit candle near cloth, paper or a child is a risk, and the smoke may trouble people with breathing difficulties. Candles also tempt a leader to use the dim room to produce a mood, and as lecture 4-1 said, this course does not teach that. The care of fire belongs to lecture 6-4. Until then, a simple rule is enough: follow the building owner's rules and your local safety rules, and keep the flame away from anything that burns.
Where a real flame cannot be used, some communities use a small electric lamp. Whether this is acceptable is a matter for the community, but the sign it gives is the same.
3. Movement and dance
Scripture records people moving in praise. Miriam and the women with tambourines, David before the ark, and the psalm that says "Let them praise his name in the dance!" are all there. Today, movement in worship takes many forms:
- walking in a procession with a book, a cross or a lamp;
- standing for the reading of the Gospel, kneeling for prayer, bowing, making the sign of the cross;
- raising hands, clapping, swaying, stepping to a rhythm;
- a set dance by trained dancers;
- a children's action song with simple gestures;
- a slow walk to the table or to the front in response to an invitation.
Traditions disagree about how much of this belongs. Some communities have movement built into the service and would feel lost without it. Some regard dance as entirely proper. Some are uneasy about dance, especially when it is done by someone other than the whole community, because they fear it will become a display. Some cultures move freely in worship, and others hold the body still as a sign of reverence. None of these is the more spiritual way. Each is the community's way of using the body to say something it believes.
The planner's questions are practical.
- Who is moving, and who is watching? A procession in which everyone walks is one thing. A solo dance while everyone sits is another.
- Can a person who cannot move take part? A person who uses a wheelchair, a person with weak knees, an older person who cannot stand for long: if the only way to join is to stand, they are shut out. Offer a way to take part from a seat, such as lifting a hand, turning the face, or singing the refrain.
- Is it modest? Clothing, the room and the community's custom matter. A movement that is fine at a celebration may not fit a funeral.
- Does anyone feel pressure? No one should be made to move, and no one should be shamed for not moving.
A trained dancer or a movement group can be a real gift to a community, especially one where worship has long been words alone. If your community welcomes it, the best forms are those that bring the dancer into the people's own action: leading a procession, or teaching a simple gesture to the whole room.
4. Readings for several voices
A reading is not only for one person at a lectern. A passage shared among several voices can make the room hear it afresh, and a part for the whole room puts the people's voices to work.
Here is how one might lay out Psalm 150 for four readers and the room. The verses are copied from the World English Bible.
Reader 1: Praise Yah! Praise God in his sanctuary! Praise him in his heavens for his acts of power! Reader 2: Praise him for his mighty acts! Praise him according to his excellent greatness! Reader 3: Praise him with the sounding of the trumpet! Praise him with harp and lyre! Reader 4: Praise him with tambourine and dancing! Praise him with stringed instruments and flute! Reader 1: Praise him with loud cymbals! Praise him with resounding cymbals! All: Let everything that has breath praise Yah! Praise Yah! — Psalm 150:1-6 (WEB)
This costs no money and needs no instrument. Notice what it does: the last verse is for the whole room, and the room is the "everything that has breath".
Some practical rules for shared reading:
- Give each reader the exact text in large print, with their lines marked.
- Practise once, aloud, in the room, so that everyone knows when to begin.
- Choose readers of different ages and voices, but never put someone on the spot who cannot read comfortably. A shy reader can be given a short line, or the part for the whole room.
- Where the room includes people who use a second language, keep the text short and the pace slow.
- Where the translation is a modern one, check its terms (see lecture 3-4).
- If you have no printed text, the leader can speak the line and the room can repeat it.
5. Short dramas
A short drama is a scene acted for the gathering. It may retell a Bible story, show a parable, or act a modern parallel. In some communities it is old and loved. In others it is unusual or unwelcome. It can do three useful things: make a story concrete, welcome children, and give a way in for people who do not read well. It can also do harm.
The dangers are these.
- Performance. If the drama is the high point of the service, the people have become an audience.
- Mockery. A drama that laughs at a person, a group, a profession or a way of worship is cruel, whoever the target is. Humour has its place, but it must not wound.
- Frightening children. Scenes of violence, or of a person being punished, can disturb a child more than the actors intended.
- Putting words in the mouth of God or of Christ. Some communities forbid an actor to play God or Christ. Follow your community's rule.
- Replacing Scripture. A drama retells a passage; it does not take its place. The reading should be heard as well.
Some practical rules. Keep it short: three to five minutes is enough for most gatherings. Write the script, however plain. Show it beforehand to those responsible for the service. State at the start what Scripture it is based on. Rehearse so that nobody is fumbling.
6. Silence
Silence is the plainest art. A pause after a reading, a minute of quiet after a sermon, an empty moment before a prayer: these cost nothing and are available to every community. Lecture 1-4 spoke of silence as part of a service. Here we note only that silence needs preparation too. A silence that comes by accident feels like a mistake. A silence that has been announced ("We will be quiet for one minute; I will say Amen when the time is over") feels like a gift.
A silence is also a place where nobody performs. It is, in a sense, the opposite of a show. It is one of the few moments when the leader, the choir and the people are all doing the same thing.
Not everyone finds silence easy. Some people are anxious in quiet, and some are grieving. Keep it short at first, and tell people what will happen.
7. Outside artists
A community may invite a visiting artist: a painter, a musician, a dancer, a speaker. This can enrich the service. It also brings a risk, because the artist does not know the community's rules.
Before a guest takes part:
- Agree the content. Ask for the text, the song or the plan beforehand. Those responsible for the service should read or hear it.
- Agree the form. How long? Where will they stand? Will they speak? Does the community allow what they plan to do?
- Tell them the rules. Dress, language, filming, how to speak of God, what the community does at this point in the service.
- Protect the children. A guest who will be near children should be treated as any other adult in the community's written safeguarding policy. A young person should never be alone with a guest. Follow local law and the community's written rules.
- Say how they will be thanked. If money changes hands, or a gift, agree it plainly beforehand. Whether a guest is paid is a matter for local law and the community's policy.
- Bring them into the people's action. The guest teaches a gesture, leads a song, helps with the cloth. They do not simply perform.
Be as kind to a guest as you would be to anyone. The aim is not to be suspicious, but to avoid surprises that hurt the guest or the people.
8. Keeping the people from becoming an audience
Several signs show that a gathering is drifting toward an audience:
- The applause is for people, not for God. (Some communities clap in thanksgiving; the question is who the clap is for.)
- The eyes of the people follow one person for most of the service.
- The people's songs become songs the people cannot sing: too high, too fast, too new, too clever.
- The leader speaks of "the show" or "the set".
- The people's voices are not needed. If the sound team could turn the room off and nobody would notice, something has gone wrong.
None of these is a crime. Each is a signal to ask the test question again. The remedy is nearly always the same: add something for the people to do, or remove something that does it for them.
9. Children in the action
Children are the most honest judges of whether an action is real. A child will not sit still for something that does not involve them.
- Give them a part. Carrying a cloth or a lamp, holding a book, saying a line of a shared reading, making a gesture to a song. A part that is simple and genuine tells the child they are a member of the gathering.
- Do not use them as decoration. A child dressed up and placed at the front to be looked at is not taking part. Do not put a child on show for the pleasure of the adults.
- Check what a child may see or do. A candle held by a small child needs two adults nearby. A drama with frightening elements needs a warning for parents. A child who does not wish to take part should be free to say no.
- Include children with disabilities in the same way. Lecture 4-4 returns to this.
- Do not photograph or film the children's action without the community's written policy. Lecture 5-2 covers this in full.
Diagram 1. The test: eyes, voice, body
Diagram 2. Planning a guest
| Step | Question |
|---|---|
| Content | Have those responsible read or heard it? |
| Form | How long, where, and does the community allow it? |
| Rules | Do they know dress, language, filming and our way of speaking of God? |
| Children | Is the guest under the written policy, never alone with a child? |
| Thanks | Is any payment or gift agreed beforehand, under local law? |
| People | Does the guest bring the room into the action? |
In short
- One test applies to every action: where do the people's eyes, voice and body go? A service of only E's is an audience.
- Candles, movement, shared reading, short drama and silence each have a use, a strength and a danger.
- Movement must offer a way in to those who cannot move in the set way, and must not pressure anyone.
- A reading for several voices can give the last line to the whole room.
- An outside artist is agreed in advance on content, form, rules, children, thanks and the people's part.
- Children take part in the action. They are not put on show.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The test | Where do the people's eyes, voice and body go? |
| Sign of an audience | The eyes follow one person, and the people's voices are not needed. |
| Before a guest takes part | Agree content and form; tell the rules; protect children; settle thanks; bring in the room. |
| A child's place | A real part in the action, not a place at the front to be looked at. |
One sentence to remember Art in worship serves the people when it asks them to do something, and fails them when it asks them only to watch.
This week's action Mark one real order of service with E, V and B, and find one place to add something for the people to do.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Take the order of one service you know. Mark each item E, V or B. Where is the longest stretch with no V and no B? Is that the right place for it?
- Why does the lecture say that movement is not more spiritual in one culture than another? What would be lost if a community insisted that its way was the only reverent one?
- A shared reading puts the last line in the mouth of the whole room. What does that line do that a single reader could not do?
- What is the difference between a drama that retells a passage and one that replaces it? Give an example of each from the stories of the Bible.
- A visiting singer offers to perform at your gathering. What are the first three questions you would ask?
- How could a person who cannot stand or walk take part fully in a procession?