Lecture 8-4: Suffering, and Science — The Two Questions That Come Back
Contents 66
- Lecture 1-1: Kerygma — The Shape of the Apostolic Announcement
- Lecture 1-2: The Triune Ground of Evangelism
- Lecture 1-3: The Theology of Conversion — Regeneration, Repentance, Faith
- Lecture 1-4: The Uniqueness of Christ and the Urgency of the Message
- Lecture 1-5: Why We Do This — The Motives of Evangelism
- Lecture 2-1: The Earliest Church — Scattered, and Therefore Everywhere
- Lecture 2-2: The Reformation and the Recovery of Conversion
- Lecture 2-3: The Awakenings — Revival and Its Machinery
- Lecture 2-4: Modern Mass Evangelism — What It Gained and What It Cost
- Lecture 2-5: What the History Teaches — Chapter 2 Synthesis
- Lecture 3-1: Election and the Motive to Speak
- Lecture 3-2: Conversion: A Moment or a Journey
- Lecture 3-3: Judgement and Hell, Told Truthfully
- Lecture 3-4: The Word and the Loaf
- Lecture 3-5: Part I in One Piece
- Lecture 4-1: The Frame Every Outline Is Built On
- Lecture 4-2: The Four Spiritual Laws and the Romans Road
- Lecture 4-3: The Bridge and the Whole Story
- Lecture 4-4: Choosing an Outline, and Paying for It
- Lecture 4-5: Preparing Your Own, and Naming What It Drops
- Lecture 5-1: Relational Evangelism — Building a Bridge of Trust
- Lecture 5-2: Mass Evangelism and Street Evangelism
- Lecture 5-3: Lifestyle Evangelism — The Gospel Carried by a Life
- Lecture 5-4: Asking and Listening
- Lecture 5-5: Chapter 5 Synthesis — Becoming an Integrated Evangelist
- Lecture 6-1: The Evangelist's Life of Prayer
- Lecture 6-2: The Character the Work Asks For
- Lecture 6-3: Rejection and Fear
- Lecture 6-4: Growing Over a Lifetime
- Lecture 6-5: Part II in One View, and the Midterm
- Lecture 7-1: Children — What Jesus Made Room For, and What Care It Requires
- Lecture 7-2: Adolescents and Young Adults — The Years When Everything Is Being Decided
- Lecture 7-3: Later Life — Urgency, Respect, and the Witness of the Old
- Lecture 7-4: Life Transitions — Open Doors and the Danger of Treating Them as Such
- Lecture 7-5: Chapter 7 Synthesis — One Christ, Every Stage
- Lecture 8-1: Apologetics and Evangelism — What Reason Can and Cannot Do
- Lecture 8-2: Talking with Atheists and Agnostics
- Lecture 8-3: Speaking with People of Other Faiths
- Lecture 8-4: Suffering, and Science — The Two Questions That Come Back
- Lecture 8-5: Chapter 8 in One View — Knowledge and Love
- Lecture 9-1: Presence Before Explanation
- Lecture 9-2: The Ward and the Bedside
- Lecture 9-3: The Funeral and the Long Months After
- Lecture 9-4: Disaster and the Wounding of a Whole Community
- Lecture 9-5: Chapter 9 Synthesis — Witness Inside the Suffering
- Lecture 10-1: The Unchanging Message and the New Medium
- Lecture 10-2: What an Online Relationship Can Carry, and What It Cannot
- Lecture 10-3: Social Media and Made Content
- Lecture 10-4: Anonymity, Argument and Shallowness
- Lecture 10-5: Part III Synthesis — The Whole Evangelist
- Lecture 11-1: What Follow-Up Is
- Lecture 11-2: The First Weeks
- Lecture 11-3: From Attendance to Belonging
- Lecture 11-4: Drift, Relapse and Return
- Lecture 11-5: Chapter 11 Synthesis — Fruit That Remains
- Lecture 12-1: What an Evangelistic Culture Is
- Lecture 12-2: Leaders and What They Do in Public
- Lecture 12-3: Training and Mobilising a Congregation
- Lecture 12-4: Worship, Small Groups and Existing Ministries
- Lecture 12-5: Chapter 12 Synthesis — The Church That Evangelises
Two rooms, on the same day.
In the first, a woman sits beside a bed on a children's ward. Her daughter died four hours ago of something that a hospital in another country would have treated in an afternoon. She looks up at the chaplain and asks why.
In the second, a secondary-school science teacher marking papers says to a colleague, quite mildly, "I don't see how you can teach this subject and believe that." He is not being aggressive. He has never heard the two things held together and assumes there is a trick.
Both questions come up more than any others, and they are not the same kind of question. The second is asking for information. The first is not asking for information at all, and the largest mistake in this lecture's territory is answering it as if it were. This lecture sets out the serious replies to both, and then says when a reply is the wrong thing to offer.
What these 15 minutes give you
- Set out the main theological responses to suffering fairly, including the response that declines to explain.
- Give a balanced account of how science and Christian faith are related, and say why the story of permanent conflict is too simple.
- Judge when an argument is the right response to the question of suffering and when it is not.
For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part, but then I will know fully, even as I was also fully known." — 1 Corinthians 13:12
World English Bible
Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? Declare, if you have understanding." — Job 38:4
WEB
1. The question at full strength
Stated properly, the problem of evil is this. If God is entirely good he would want to prevent suffering. If he is entirely powerful he could. Suffering exists in enormous quantity. So one of the three claims appears to fail. The form is old — it is reported of Epicurus and pressed hard by David Hume — and it has a modern version that is harder still: never mind whether some suffering could be justified, what about this amount, distributed like this, falling on a child.
Do not soften it. A Christian who cannot state the objection in a form that would satisfy the person raising it is not yet in the conversation.
2. Four replies, and what each one costs
The free-will defence. God made creatures capable of genuine love, and genuine love requires the real possibility of refusal; the misuse of that freedom is where moral evil comes from. Alvin Plantinga's version is the best known. What it costs: it addresses evil that people do, and it does much less about a virus or an earthquake.
Soul-making. Suffering can be the material of maturity: "suffering works perseverance; and perseverance, proven character; and proven character, hope" (Romans 5:3–4, WEB). Irenaeus is the ancient source and John Hick the modern one. What it costs: it fits growth that actually happened and cannot be said over suffering that destroyed someone. Said too early it is monstrous.
A disordered creation. The Christian account has the world itself out of joint, not merely human behaviour: creation was "subjected to vanity" and "groans and travails in pain together until now" (Romans 8:20, 22, WEB), waiting for release. What it costs: it explains the category, not the instance, and it raises further questions about how and when.
Mystery, and the refusal to explain. Job asks and is not answered — he is questioned instead, out of a whirlwind, for four chapters. The book contains a long theological explanation of his suffering, offered by his friends, and God's verdict on it is not favourable. What it costs: used lazily this is a way of avoiding thought, and someone can hide behind it rather than admit they have no reply.
None of the four is the course's official answer. Each is holding something real. A student who can state all four, with the cost of each, is better equipped than a student who has one and defends it everywhere.
3. When an argument is the wrong thing to say
Job's friends did one thing right, at the start: they sat with him for seven days and said nothing. Everything after that made it worse.
There is a distinction here that has to be kept. The mother on the ward is not raising the problem of evil; she is using the only words available for something that has no words. To answer her with the free-will defence is to mishear a cry as a query. Later — weeks, months, sometimes years — the question may come back in a form that genuinely wants an answer, and then the answer is a kindness. Reading which one you are being handed is most of the skill.
Paul's "we see in a mirror, dimly" (1 Corinthians 13:12) is worth holding here. It is not an excuse for having nothing to say; it is a statement about the size of the gap between what we know and what there is to know. Standing in front of that gap alongside someone is a real position, and it is honest.
Chapter 9 takes this up properly, because presence at a hospital bed or a funeral is a subject of its own.
4. Science and faith: the story that is too simple
The teacher marking papers has inherited a story: religion and science have always been at war, science keeps winning, and believing scientists are either compartmentalising or lying.
That story has a history. It was assembled in the late nineteenth century, largely by two Americans — John William Draper, in History of the Conflict between Religion and Science (1874), and Andrew Dickson White, in A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom (1896). Historians of science have spent the last several decades dismantling it, and the standard collection of the corrections is Galileo Goes to Jail and Other Myths about Science and Religion (Harvard, 2009). The real record is messier in both directions: the Galileo affair was a genuine and disgraceful failure by church authorities, and the idea that medieval Christians thought the earth was flat is a nineteenth-century invention.
Two more things belong here, stated carefully.
Different questions. Science asks how the natural world works; it is extremely good at that, and its answers do not settle why there is a world or what it is for. An explanation of a mechanism does not by itself dispose of a purpose. This is not a trick to protect God from evidence; it is the ordinary observation that a full account of how an engine works tells you nothing about why the car was built.
Believing scientists are not rare. They were not rare in the seventeenth century and they are not rare now — surveys of scientists' religious belief exist and differ by field and country, so the honest form of the claim is that a substantial minority of working scientists hold religious faith, not that most do. Either way, the teacher's assumption that the combination is impossible is answered by the existence of colleagues he could go and talk to.
5. Where orthodox Christians differ, and where they do not
How God created
On how God created, there is real variety inside orthodox Christianity: young-earth creation, old-earth creation, and evolutionary creation each have serious defenders who hold the authority of Scripture. That argument belongs to systematic theology and to biblical interpretation, and this course does not settle it.
What is not variable is the confession underneath: that the world is not self-explaining, and that God is its Creator. An evangelist can say that honestly while declining to be drawn on the mechanism — and should, because a hearer who is told they must accept a particular account of the earth's age before they can consider Christ has been handed a barrier the church did not put there.
An argument won is not a person persuaded. In this territory the point is sharper than usual, because both these questions can be answered correctly and still leave the person exactly where they were.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Question | What it is asking | The wrong move |
|---|---|---|
| Suffering, from someone in it | Not information; company | Delivering a at the bedside |
| Suffering, asked later and cold | A real account, honestly limited | Pretending the objection is weak |
| Science and faith | Whether the two can be held together | Making a view of the earth's age a condition of belief |
In short
- The problem of evil should be stated at full strength before it is answered: a wholly good and wholly powerful God, and this much suffering distributed like this.
- Four serious replies: the free-will defence, soul-making, a creation subjected to disorder, and the refusal to explain that Job models. Each holds something real and each has a cost, and this course does not choose between them.
- The book of Job contains a long explanation of suffering, offered by the friends, and God's verdict on it is not favourable.
- A cry and a query are different, and answering the first as though it were the second is the largest mistake in this territory. Chapter 9 takes up presence in loss.
- 1 Corinthians 13:12 is not an excuse for having nothing to say; it names the gap between what we know and what there is to know, and standing in front of it with someone is an honest position.
- The story of permanent war between science and faith was assembled in the late nineteenth century by Draper and White, and historians have largely dismantled it. The record is messier in both directions.
- Science asks how the world works and does not thereby settle why there is a world. A substantial minority of working scientists hold religious faith.
- Orthodox Christians differ on the mechanism of creation; the confession that God is Creator does not vary. Do not make a view of the earth's age a condition of considering Christ.
Topic: Suffering and science are the two questions that keep returning; this lecture sets out serious replies.
Remember: A cry and a query are different. Do not answer a grieving person's cry with an argument; sit with them.
Caution: None of the four replies to suffering is the course's official answer, and each has a cost. Christians differ on how God created, and the lecture does not settle it.
One line to carry into ministry: Do not make a view of the earth's age a condition of considering Christ.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- State the problem of evil in the form a person raising it would accept as fair. What did you have to stop yourself from adding?
- Take each of the four replies and name a situation in which it would be the right thing to say, and one in which it would be cruel.
- God's verdict in Job falls on the friends' explanations rather than on Job's complaints. What follows for how a Christian speaks about someone else's suffering?
- The conflict story about science and religion is largely a nineteenth-century construction — but the Galileo affair really happened. How would you say both of those in one honest sentence?
- Where have you seen a barrier put in front of a hearer that the gospel itself does not require? What did it cost?