FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-2: The Cosmological Argument — From the World to a First Cause

The cosmological argument reasons from the world to a first cause, in Aquinas's three ways and in the kalam form.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Aquinas's first three ways (from motion, from efficient causation, and from contingency) in your own words, and explain what each argues the universe cannot be the ultimate explanation of.
  • Explain the structural difference between Aquinas's ways (which do not require a temporal beginning) and the kalam cosmological argument (which does).
  • State the kalam argument's two premises and its conclusion, and identify what evidence its contemporary defenders cite for the second premise.
  • State Hume's and Kant's objections to inferring a cause of the universe from causes observed within the universe, and explain what a defender of the cosmological argument would need to answer to meet them.
The argument

From the world to a first cause

The cosmological argument reasons from some general feature of the observed universe, that things are caused, that things exist contingently, or that the universe appears to have begun, to a first, uncaused, necessary cause of everything else. The lecture examines two forms separated by about seven centuries: Aquinas's first three ways and the kalam argument. They are often run together in popular presentation, but they are structurally different.

Key idea Two arguments, kept distinct.
Scripture

Why Psalm 90:2?

The lecture uses this verse because it states, in the form of worship, the conclusion the argument reasons toward: God's being does not depend on anything coming before it.

Before the mountains were born, before you had formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, you are God." Psalm 90:2 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Hebrews 11:3?

The lecture uses this verse to note that the created status of the universe is said to be understood by faith, which cautions against treating the argument's success as itself sufficient for saving faith.

By faith, we understand that the universe has been framed by the word of God, so that what is seen has not been made out of things which are visible." Hebrews 11:3 · WEB
Aquinas

The first three ways

The first way argues from change: whatever changes is changed by something already actual, and the series cannot regress without a first changer. The second way argues from efficient causation: nothing causes itself, so there must be a first uncaused cause. The third way argues from contingency: if everything were merely contingent, nothing would exist now, so there must be something that exists necessarily.

Key idea Each argues that the chain of explanation must end in God.
Common misreading

No temporal beginning needed

None of Aquinas's three ways requires the universe to have had a temporal beginning. Aquinas, following Aristotle, was open to an eternal universe, though he held on the authority of revelation that the universe in fact began. His ways argue for a cause the universe depends on right now, at every moment of its existence.

Key idea Aquinas argues from ongoing dependency, not a first event.
Kalam argument

From a beginning to a cause

The kalam argument, revived by William Lane Craig, depends essentially on the universe having begun. Its premises are that whatever begins to exist has a cause and that the universe began to exist, so the universe has a cause. Defenders cite the standard Big Bang model and the observed expansion of the universe for the second premise. By itself it reaches something like a Creator of the universe, not yet the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.

Key idea Even granting both premises, further steps are needed to reach the God of Christian faith.
The objections

Hume and Kant, and the replies

Hume's objection

Reasoning valid within the universe is stretched to the universe as a whole, though we have never observed universes coming into being. Defenders reply that the premise is that whatever begins to exist needs a cause, which does not cover a beginningless first cause.

Kant's objection

The argument covertly relies on the ontological argument to move from a necessary being to God. Defenders like Craig reply that the properties of the first cause are derived from what is required to cause the beginning of space, time, and matter.

Where readers differ

How much weight can it bear?

Defenders

Craig and other contemporary defenders such as Robin Collins and J. P. Moreland hold that the argument, properly qualified, survives these objections.

More skeptical theists

Some in the Reformed epistemology tradition following Plantinga doubt that natural theology can carry this much weight and rest belief on other grounds.

Think about it

Now or then?

Aquinas's ways ask what the universe depends on now, while the kalam argument asks what began it.

Which of the two questions seems to you the more natural way to ask about God?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Aquinas's three ways argue from ongoing dependency and need no beginning of the universe. The kalam argument depends on a beginning. Hume's and Kant's objections are serious, and how much weight the argument bears is disputed.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13