FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-5: Presuppositionalism and Contemporary Atheism

Van Til says no reasoning is religiously neutral, and the New Atheists say the case for God fails; the chapter ends by hearing both.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Van Til's central claim that no reasoning is religiously neutral, and explain what he means by saying unbelieving thought is simultaneously dependent on and in rebellion against the God it denies.
  • Explain how presuppositionalism's approach to apologetics differs in its basic strategy from the evidentialist approach of Lectures 2-2 through 2-4.
  • Identify the central arguments of at least two New Atheist authors (for example, Dawkins's "who designed the designer" objection and Hitchens's argument from religious violence) in their strongest form, not a caricature.
  • Explain 1 Peter 3:15's charge to give "a reason for the hope" and connect it to why this course treats both classical apologetics and its critics as worth taking seriously.
Two challenges

Neither fits "argument plus objection"

This closing lecture examines two developments. Presuppositional apologetics, associated with Cornelius Van Til, argues that the earlier lectures concede there is a religiously neutral standpoint for weighing the evidence. The New Atheism, associated with Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, and Daniel Dennett, is a culturally significant and philosophically serious opponent the course engages directly. Both force the chapter to ask whether this is the right terrain for the question.

Key idea The two critiques come from opposite directions.
Scripture

Why Proverbs 1:7?

The lecture uses this verse because it calls the fear of Yahweh the beginning of knowledge, which is close to the heart of Van Til's argument that reasoning without God is not neutral ground.

The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge; but the foolish despise wisdom and instruction." Proverbs 1:7 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why 1 Peter 3:15?

The lecture uses this verse because it tells believers to be ready to give an answer, with humility and fear, to a genuine question about the hope in them.

But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear:" 1 Peter 3:15 · WEB
Van Til

No reasoning is neutral

Evidentialism presents evidence and argument that the unbeliever weighs using reasoning both parties share. Van Til rejected the premise that such neutral reasoning exists. Every act of reasoning operates within prior commitments about what reality, knowledge, and logic are, and only the Christian framework, he argued, makes sense of the fact that reasoning, logic, and science work at all.

Key idea Presuppositionalism challenges the starting point, not just the evidence.
Van Til

Dependent and in rebellion

Van Til charged that the unbeliever depends in practice on an orderly universe, stable laws of logic, and a real moral order, while denying the God whose existence alone accounts for them. More cosmological or teleological evidence therefore does not address the problem. What is needed is a transcendental argument showing that logic, science, and morality presuppose the truth of Christian theism.

Key idea The proposed argument asks what makes reasoning possible at all.
Where readers differ

Starting points compared

The evidentialist tradition

Aquinas, Craig, and the evidentialist tradition hold that reasoning about God can proceed on common ground with unbelievers, even if it does not produce saving faith.

The presuppositionalist tradition

Van Til and his followers hold that no neutral ground exists and that apologetics must begin by exposing this. Critics, including some Reformed ones, say this is hard to square with Romans 1:19-20.

New Atheism

Two arguments in their strongest form

Dawkins: who designed the designer?

A being able to design a complex universe would itself be at least as complex, so invoking God relocates the problem. Classical theism replies that God is simple and necessarily existent, a different category of explanation. Whether that satisfies the objection is contested.

Hitchens: the record of religious violence

Religious belief has historically been a persistent cause of violence and the suppression of inquiry. A response grants the record is real, and points to violence under explicitly atheistic regimes as showing a link to totalizing ideology generally. Hitchens disputed that reply.

Closing the chapter

What the chapter has and has not done

The chapter has presented real arguments, engaged serious objections, and named where Christians disagree about how much weight such reasoning can bear. It has not delivered a knockdown proof compelling every rational person, and it did not set out to. It has tried to do what 1 Peter 3:15 asks: prepare a reasoned answer, offered with humility, for anyone who asks the reason for the hope that is in you.

Key idea The aim is a humble, reasoned answer, not a proof.
Think about it

Neutral ground?

Van Til denies it exists, while the evidentialist tradition assumes it does.

When you talk with someone who does not believe, do you think you share enough common ground to weigh evidence together?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Van Til holds that no reasoning is religiously neutral, while the New Atheists hold that the case for God fails even on evidentialist terms. The chapter gives a reasoned answer with humility, as 1 Peter 3:15 asks, and does not claim a knockdown proof.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13