FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 5

Lecture 5-2: Early Heresies — Monarchianism, Adoptionism, and Modalism

Each early position pressed one true conviction so hard that another had to give way.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 14 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Monarchianism's core concern (protecting God's sole sovereignty and oneness, Greek monarchia) and explain the price it paid for that concern in its two main forms.
  • Distinguish Adoptionism (Jesus as an ordinary man elevated to divine status) from the orthodox alternative, and explain what biblical material Adoptionism cannot account for.
  • State Modalism/Sabellianism precisely — Father, Son, and Spirit as successive modes or masks of one person, not three eternally distinct persons — and explain why Tertullian's response to it shaped the church's later vocabulary.
  • Explain why each of these three positions was rejected for failing to hold together the same biblical data surveyed in Lecture 5-1, rather than for external philosophical reasons.
Fair reading

Sincere readers, not enemies of Scripture

Every position in this lecture was proposed by someone trying to be faithful to Scripture. Each took one true biblical conviction with total seriousness, such as that God is one or that Jesus is fully human. Each then pressed it so hard that another equally biblical conviction had to give way.

Key idea The church rejected the solution, not the concern behind it.
Scripture

Why 1 John 2:22-23?

The lecture quotes this text because its structure previews the logic used throughout. Getting the Father right and getting the Son right are not separate achievements that can be traded against each other.

Who is the liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the Antichrist, he who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son, the same doesn't have the Father. He who confesses the Son has the Father also. 1 John 2:22-23 · World English Bible
Monarchianism

Monarchia: one rule

Monarchia means one rule, one source of authority. It names the conviction that God's sovereignty and oneness cannot be divided among several distinct, co-equal persons without collapsing into something like three gods. Monarchians took this concern in two directions: Dynamic Monarchianism, covered as Adoptionism, and Modalistic Monarchianism, covered as Modalism.

Key idea Too strong a distinction between the persons looked like tritheism.
Adoptionism

An ordinary man elevated

Adoptionism, linked to Theodotus of Byzantium and most fully to Paul of Samosata, held that Jesus was born an ordinary human being and was later adopted into a unique relationship with God. It protects Jesus's full and unqualified humanity. It cannot account for John 1:1 and Colossians 1:17, which place Christ's status before any moment in his earthly life, and Paul of Samosata was condemned at Antioch in 268.

Key idea It protects Jesus's humanity by loosening his eternal divinity.
Modalism

One person, three masks

Modalism, linked to Noetus, Praxeas and Sabellius, affirmed Christ's divinity fully but denied that Father, Son and Spirit are eternally distinct persons. On this view the names are successive modes, roles or masks that the one God takes up at different points in redemptive history. The Greek prosopa meant something closer to theatrical masks than to later "persons".

Key idea It protects God's oneness by denying real distinction.
Tertullian

A mode cannot pray to itself

Tertullian's Against Praxeas is the decisive early response, and it is the source of much Latin vocabulary: trinitas, persona and substantia. His biblical argument is that texts in which the Father and Son address and act toward one another make no sense if they are a single person taking turns. Examples are the Son praying in Gethsemane and the Father's voice at the baptism.

Key idea Tertullian charged that Praxeas "crucified the Father".
At a glance

Two wrong turns, one starting concern

Adoptionism

Protects Jesus's full humanity. Cost: it denies his eternal divinity and cannot hold John 1:1 and Colossians 1:17. Condemned at Antioch in 268.

Modalism

Protects God's undivided oneness. Cost: it denies the real distinction of Father, Son and Spirit. Answered by Tertullian.

The test

Which view holds all the data?

Neither position was rejected because it was philosophically inelegant or because it displeased an emperor. Each was rejected because it could not hold together everything Lecture 5-1 showed the New Testament says. The standard is not which position feels more reverent, but which can hold all the data at once.

Key idea "Heresy" here does not mean bad faith or obvious falsehood.
Think about it

Your own blind spot

Adoptionism protects Jesus's humanity; Modalism protects God's oneness.

Which of the two concerns are you more naturally drawn to protect, and what blind spot might that suggest in your own theology?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Monarchianism feared that distinct persons meant three gods, and it split into Adoptionism and Modalism. Each protected one real concern at the cost of another biblical truth. The church's test was which view can hold all the biblical data at once.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13