Lecture 5-2: Early Heresies — Monarchianism, Adoptionism, and Modalism
Contents 46
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Proper Comes First
- Lecture 1-2: Calvin's Opening Move — Knowledge of God and Knowledge of Self
- Lecture 1-3: General and Special Revelation
- Lecture 1-4: Religious Language and Its Limits
- Lecture 2-1: Can God's Existence Be Proved? Setting the Terms
- Lecture 2-2: The Cosmological Argument — From the World to a First Cause
- Lecture 2-3: The Teleological and Moral Arguments
- Lecture 2-4: The Ontological Argument — From Concept to Necessary Existence
- Lecture 2-5: Presuppositionalism and Contemporary Atheism
- Lecture 3-1: Classifying the Attributes, and Divine Simplicity
- Lecture 3-2: Aseity and Independence
- Lecture 3-3: Immutability and Impassibility
- Lecture 3-4: Infinity, Eternity, and God's Relation to Time
- Lecture 3-5: Omnipresence
- Lecture 3-6: The Unity of God
- Lecture 4-1: Omniscience — God's Exhaustive and Personal Knowledge
- Lecture 4-2: Wisdom and Faithfulness — Knowledge Ordered and Kept
- Lecture 4-3: Holiness and Righteousness — Otherness and Moral Purity
- Lecture 4-4: Goodness, Love, Grace, and Mercy — Four Related but Distinct Attributes
- Lecture 4-5: Sovereignty and Omnipotence — What "God Can Do All Things" Actually Means
- Lecture 4-6: The Revealed Names of God — Self-Disclosure Through Covenant History
- Lecture 5-1: The Biblical Foundations of the Trinity
- Lecture 5-2: Early Heresies — Monarchianism, Adoptionism, and Modalism
- Lecture 5-3: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
- Lecture 5-4: The Cappadocian Fathers and the Council of Constantinople
- Lecture 5-5: Augustine's Trinitarian Theology and the Filioque Controversy
- Lecture 5-6: East and West Compared — Two Starting Points
- Lecture 6-1: The Immanent Trinity and the Economic Trinity
- Lecture 6-2: Perichoresis — Mutual Indwelling of the Divine Persons
- Lecture 6-3: Eternal Generation and Eternal Procession
- Lecture 6-4: The Twentieth-Century Revival of Trinitarian Theology
- Lecture 6-5: Social Trinitarianism and Its Critics
- Lecture 6-6: Contemporary Debates over Trinitarian Language
- Lecture 7-1: Process Theology — A God Who Grows With the World
- Lecture 7-2: Open Theism and the Future God Does Not Yet Know
- Lecture 7-3: Moltmann's Crucified God and the Question of Divine Suffering
- Lecture 7-4: Panentheism, Ecology, and the Creator/Creature Distinction
- Lecture 7-5: Contemporary Science and the Doctrine of God
- Lecture 7-6: Answering Postmodernism and the New Atheism
- Lecture 8-1: The Divine Decrees and Predestination
- Lecture 8-2: Calvinism, Arminianism, and Molinism on the Decrees
- Lecture 8-3: Creation Out of Nothing, and the Age of the Earth
- Lecture 8-4: Providence — Preservation, Concurrence, Government, and Miracle
- Lecture 8-5: The Problem of Evil and Theodicy
- Lecture 8-6: Conclusion — Knowing God, Not Only Knowing About Him
Every position this lecture covers was proposed by someone trying to be faithful to Scripture, not by someone trying to undermine it. That is the single most important thing to understand before naming any of them, and it is why this course avoids treating "heresy" as a synonym for bad faith. Each position named below arose from taking one true biblical conviction with total seriousness — God is one; Jesus is fully, ordinarily human — and pressing that conviction so hard that another, equally biblical conviction had to give way. The church's eventual rejection of these positions was not a rejection of the concern that motivated them; it was a judgment that the proposed solution paid for that concern with a coin the text would not accept.
What these 14 minutes give you
- State Monarchianism's core concern (protecting God's sole sovereignty and oneness, Greek *monarchia*) and explain the price it paid for that concern in its two main forms.
- Distinguish Adoptionism (Jesus as an ordinary man elevated to divine status) from the orthodox alternative, and explain what biblical material Adoptionism cannot account for.
- State Modalism/Sabellianism precisely — Father, Son, and Spirit as successive modes or masks of one person, not three eternally distinct persons — and explain why Tertullian's response to it shaped the church's later vocabulary.
- Explain why each of these three positions was rejected for failing to hold together the same biblical data surveyed in Lecture 5-1, rather than for external philosophical reasons.
Who is the liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the Antichrist, he who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son, the same doesn't have the Father. He who confesses the Son has the Father also. — 1 John 2:22-23
World English Bible
John's target here is almost certainly an early docetic or separationist denial of the , not the later controversies this lecture names — the text predates all three by a century or more. It is quoted here because its structure previews the logic this lecture will use repeatedly: getting the Father right and getting the Son right are not two separate achievements that can be traded against each other. A doctrine of God that secures the Father's uniqueness by demoting the Son, or secures the Son's importance by dissolving the Father's and the Son's distinctness, fails by John's own standard here — "he who confesses the Son has the Father also." The Father is not more securely held by holding the Son more loosely.
1. Monarchianism: protecting the "one rule" of God
Monarchia: one rule
Monarchia — one rule, one source of authority — names the conviction that God's sovereignty and oneness cannot be divided among several distinct, co-equal, co-eternal persons without collapsing into something functionally like three gods. Second- and third-century Monarchians took this concern in two different directions, both covered separately below because they diverge sharply once the initial concern is granted: Dynamic Monarchianism, which denied Christ's full divinity outright (covered here as ), and Modalistic Monarchianism, which affirmed Christ's full divinity but denied that the Father and Son were distinct persons (covered here as Modalism). What unites them under the single label is the motivating instinct: too strong a distinction between Father, Son, and Spirit looks, from this angle, like tritheism wearing a Christian vocabulary.
2. Adoptionism: an ordinary man elevated
Adoptionism, associated in its earliest form with Theodotus of Byzantium (late second century) and given its most developed statement by Paul of Samosata, Bishop of Antioch, in the mid-third century, held that Jesus was born an ordinary human being and was subsequently adopted into a unique relationship with God — empowered by the Spirit at his baptism, in some versions, or elevated at his resurrection in others — without possessing eternal, essential divinity from the beginning. The concern this protects is Jesus's full and unqualified humanity: an adopted human being is, at least until the moment of , straightforwardly one of us, with no risk of a divine nature quietly doing all the theological work while the human nature is merely decorative.
What Adoptionism cannot account for is the New Testament data surveyed in Lecture 5-1 that places Christ's divine status prior to, not consequent upon, any moment in his earthly life. John's Gospel opens "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (John 1:1, WEB) — a status given in eternity, not conferred at the Jordan. Paul writes to the Colossians that Christ is "before all things" (Colossians 1:17, WEB), a claim about eternal priority that a Jesus adopted partway through his human life cannot satisfy. Paul of Samosata was condemned at the Synod of Antioch in 268, decades before the proper (Lecture 5-3), which makes Adoptionism the earliest of the three positions this lecture covers to receive a formal, conciliar rejection.
3. Modalism (Sabellianism): one person, three masks
Modalism — associated with Noetus of Smyrna, then Praxeas, and most fully with Sabellius (hence "Sabellianism" as the more common historical label) in the early third century — took the opposite route to the same underlying worry. Rather than deny Christ's divinity, Modalism affirmed it fully, but at the cost of denying that Father, Son, and Spirit are eternally distinct persons at all. On this view, "Father," "Son," and "Spirit" name successive modes, roles, or masks (Greek prosopa, in a sense closer to theatrical masks than to later "persons") that the one God takes up at different points in redemptive history — as Father in creation and the giving of the law, as Son in the incarnation, as Spirit after Pentecost — rather than three simultaneously existing, eternally distinct persons.
Tertullian's Against Praxeas (early third century) is the decisive early response, and it matters for two reasons beyond its immediate polemical target. First, it is the source of much of the Latin theological vocabulary — trinitas ("," a term Tertullian appears to have coined or at least to have given currency), persona ("person"), and substantia ("substance") — that Western Trinitarian theology would use for the next seventeen centuries, including in Augustine's work covered in Lecture 5-5. Second, Tertullian's central biblical argument against Praxeas is direct and simple: texts in which the Father and Son address one another, are distinguished from one another, and act toward one another (the Son praying to the Father in Gethsemane; the Father's voice at the Son's baptism, distinct from the Son standing in the water) make no sense if Father and Son are, in fact, a single person taking turns. A mode cannot pray to itself, or speak from heaven while also standing in the river being baptized. Tertullian's memorable charge against Praxeas — that in silencing the distinction between Father and Son to protect the Father's supremacy, "he put to flight the Paraclete and crucified the Father" — names precisely the trade this lecture has been describing throughout: Modalism protects God's oneness by denying the distinctness John 2:22-23 insists on holding together with it.
4. What all three positions share, and why "heresy" here does not mean "obviously false"
Read charitably, Adoptionism and Modalism are not the errors of careless or hostile readers. They are what happens when a serious reader takes one strand of the biblical data from Lecture 5-1 — God's oneness, or Jesus's full humanity — and follows it without also holding the other strand at the same time. Adoptionism protects Jesus's humanity by loosening his eternal divinity; Modalism protects God's oneness by loosening the Father's and Son's distinctness. Neither position was rejected because it was philosophically inelegant or because it displeased an emperor (contrast the more tangled politics of the Arian controversy in Lecture 5-3); each was rejected because it could not, in the end, hold together everything Lecture 5-1 showed the New Testament actually says. That is the standard this course applies throughout this chapter, and it is worth naming once, here, before it is applied five more times: not "which position feels more reverent," but "which position can actually hold all the data at once."
5. Going to the Sources
- Read Tertullian's Against Praxeas (Adversus Praxean), chapters 1-3 especially, for his own account of the dispute and the coining of trinitas — widely available in the Ante-Nicene Fathers series.
- Look up the Synod of Antioch's condemnation of Paul of Samosata (268) in a reference such as J.N.D. Kelly's Early Christian Doctrines, chapter 4, for the specific charges brought against him.
- Read 1 John 2:18-27 in full context (not only verses 22-23) to see the letter's own stated concern about denying "that Jesus is the Christ" before applying its logic, as this lecture does, to later controversies it does not itself address.
In short
- Each early position came from someone trying to be faithful to Scripture. Each pressed one true conviction so hard that another had to give way.
- Monarchianism (from Greek monarchia, "one rule") feared that distinct persons in God meant tritheism, three gods. It took two forms, Adoptionism and Modalism.
- Adoptionism, linked to Theodotus and Paul of Samosata, said Jesus was an ordinary man later adopted by God. It cannot explain John 1:1 or Colossians 1:17. Paul was condemned at Antioch in 268.
- Modalism, linked to Noetus, Praxeas and Sabellius, said Father, Son and Spirit are successive masks of one person. Tertullian answered that a mode cannot pray to itself.
- Both were rejected because they could not hold all the biblical data from Lecture 5-1 together, not for philosophical reasons.
Topic: This lecture explains three early positions on God and Christ, Monarchianism, Adoptionism and Modalism, and why the church rejected them.
Remember: Each position protected one real concern, and the church's test was which view can hold all the biblical data at once.
Caution: "Heresy" here does not mean bad faith or obvious falsehood. The lecture reads these writers charitably, as sincere readers who followed one strand of Scripture too far.
One line to carry into ministry: Watch which truth you are most eager to protect, and make sure you are not loosening its partner truth.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Adoptionism protects Jesus's humanity; Modalism protects God's oneness. Which of the two concerns do you find yourself more naturally drawn to protect, and what does that suggest about a blind spot worth watching for in your own theology?
- Tertullian charges that Praxeas, in denying the distinction between Father and Son, effectively "crucified the Father." Restate that charge in your own words — what exactly goes wrong, biblically, if the Father and Son are not distinct persons?
- This lecture argues these positions were rejected for failing to hold the biblical data together, not for being philosophically displeasing. Do you find that a sufficient defense against the charge that later councils "read Greek philosophy into" the New Testament? Why or why not?