FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-1: Process Theology — A God Who Grows With the World

Process theology pictures a God who grows with the world; the classical objection says that makes God depend on what he made.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Whitehead's process metaphysics and Hartshorne's theological development of it (dipolar theism, the "consequent nature" of God) in terms a process theologian would accept as fair.
  • Explain why process theology's motivating concerns — the problem of evil and a God genuinely responsive to the world — are serious concerns and not merely a rhetorical launching pad for revising the doctrine of God.
  • State the classical objection that process theology compromises divine aseity and sovereignty (Chapter 3), and explain what is actually at stake in that objection.
  • Identify what a classical theist can and cannot concede to process theology's critique of an unmoved, unaffected God.
Whitehead

Reality as process

Alfred North Whitehead set out to replace the substance metaphysics that ran from Aristotle through Descartes. On his account the basic units of reality are momentary events of experience, called actual occasions, not enduring substances. Each occasion absorbs the prior ones, achieves a brief moment of experience, and perishes to become material for the next. Process theology's account of God follows from applying this metaphysics consistently to everything, including God.

Key idea In process thought, everything is becoming and event.
Hartshorne

A dipolar God

Charles Hartshorne built from Whitehead's framework a doctrine called dipolar theism. God has a primordial nature, an abstract and unchanging character that values all possibilities. God also has a consequent nature, a concrete and ever-growing experience of the actual world. Hartshorne calls God the "most moved mover," reversing Aristotle's unmoved mover.

Key idea One pole of God stays fixed and the other grows with the world.
At a glance

Classical theism and process theology

Classical theism

God is immutable, can determine outcomes, owes nothing to the world, and created the world from nothing with an absolute beginning.

Process theology

God's consequent nature changes, God lures rather than coerces, and God has always been in relation to some world or other.

Motivation

Two concerns behind the trade

Process theologians give up immutability, classical omnipotence and creation out of nothing for two serious reasons. The first is the problem of evil: if God cannot coerce any occasion, God is not even permissively the cause of evil. The second is the sense that a God unmoved by a worshiper's grief or a martyr's suffering does not fit the biblical God who grieves and relents.

Key idea The motives are serious ones and not only rhetoric.
Scripture

Why Malachi 3:6?

The lecture uses this verse as a natural starting point for anyone defending classical immutability. It notes that the verse sits in a passage about Yahweh's covenant faithfulness to people who have themselves changed.

For I, Yahweh, don't change; therefore you, sons of Jacob, are not consumed." Malachi 3:6 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Numbers 23:19?

The lecture pairs this verse with Malachi 3:6 as the second text used for classical immutability. It is spoken by Balaam about God's reliability to keep a spoken blessing, and the lecture returns to it when discussing God's promises.

God is not a man, that he should lie, nor the son of man, that he should repent. Has he said, and will he not do it? Or has he spoken, and will he not make it good?" Numbers 23:19 · WEB
Classical objection

A God who depends on the world

Chapter 3 argued for divine aseity: God depends on nothing outside himself. If God's consequent nature is constituted by what happens in the world, then God's concrete actuality depends on the world. Classical theism holds this exactly backward, because God's blessedness and character are complete in himself and the world adds nothing. A second objection concerns power: a God who can only lure cannot guarantee the outcome of history, so his promises become hopes.

Key idea The objection targets both aseity and sovereignty.
Concession

What classical theists can grant

Classical theists across traditions increasingly grant that process theology names a real problem. Impassibility stated so strongly that God is unmoved in any sense can sound like indifference rather than transcendence. They will not concede that God's own being is constituted by, and dependent on, the world's history.

Key idea Real responsiveness is not the same as being constituted by the world.
Think about it

What makes God worthy of worship?

Process theology says an unmoved God is not worthy of worship. Classical theism says a God who depends on the world is not.

State each side's criterion as precisely as you can. Where exactly do the two criteria conflict?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Process theology sees God as growing through the world's history, driven by concerns about evil and a responsive God. The classical objection is that a God constituted by the world depends on it. The central question is whether God can be fully responsive without being constituted by the world.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13