FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST1E · Chapter 7

Lecture 7-3: Moltmann's Crucified God and the Question of Divine Suffering

Moltmann says the cross is an event within the Trinity; classical theism affirms real divine engagement while keeping impassibility.

Systematic Theology I: The Doctrine of God

13 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Moltmann's central claim in The Crucified God — that the cross is an event within the Trinity's own life in which the Father suffers the loss of the Son and the Son suffers abandonment by the Father — and explain the pastoral and historical concerns that motivate it.
  • Distinguish "patripassianism" (the ancient heresy that the Father himself suffered on the cross, condemned as a form of modalism) from Moltmann's more careful claim about what happens between the Father and the Son.
  • State the classical doctrine of impassibility with the qualifications Chapter 3 already built in, and show what resources it has for affirming genuine divine engagement with suffering.
  • Explain why this remains, in this course's own judgment, one of the most actively and legitimately debated points in contemporary theology, not a settled question either side has already won.
Occasion

Why Moltmann wrote

Jürgen Moltmann was drafted into the German army as a teenager, captured, and held as a prisoner of war. He returned to a Germany confronting Auschwitz. His book The Crucified God (1972) is his mature answer to what can be said about God after Auschwitz. His target is a theism in which God watches history from total invulnerability.

Key idea His argument answers the problem of evil and a historical catastrophe.
The argument

The cross within the Trinity

Moltmann argues that the cross is an event within the Trinity's own relations. The Son experiences real abandonment by the Father, and the Father suffers the grief of losing the Son. The Spirit is the bond of love proceeding from this event, uniting Father and Son again in the resurrection. For Moltmann, no sufferer's suffering places that sufferer outside God's company.

Key idea God has entered the worst that history can do.
Careful distinction

Not patripassianism

Patripassianism is the ancient heresy that the Father himself was crucified. Moltmann explicitly denies reviving it. He distinguishes the Son's suffering, including physical death in his human nature, from the Father's distinct grief of a father losing a son. Whether this distinction fully escapes the charge is itself a live question among his critics.

Key idea Moltmann intends a real distinction between Father and Son.
Scripture

Why Isaiah 53:3?

The lecture uses this verse as the Old Testament witness to a suffering, despised figure whom the New Testament identifies as the Messiah.

He was despised, and rejected by men; a man of suffering, and acquainted with disease. He was despised as one from whom men hide their face; and we didn't respect him." Isaiah 53:3 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Isaiah 53:4?

The lecture pairs this verse with Isaiah 53:3 as part of the same Old Testament witness to the suffering figure.

Surely he has borne our sickness, and carried our suffering; yet we considered him plagued, struck by God, and afflicted." Isaiah 53:4 · WEB
Scripture

Why Hebrews 4:15?

The lecture uses this verse to show that Christ was truly touched with the feeling of our infirmities. No party in the debate denies that the incarnate Son suffered in his human nature.

For we don't have a high priest who can't be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, but one who has been in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin." Hebrews 4:15 · WEB
Classical objection

Aseity and the two natures

Classical theism objects that if God can suffer, God's blessedness is no longer unconditioned by anything outside himself. This compromises the aseity Chapter 3 established. There is also a Christological worry: Chalcedon holds the two natures united without confusion, so the divine nature does not suffer while the human nature genuinely does. Critics worry Moltmann blurs this distinction.

Key idea The objection concerns God's self-sufficiency and Christ's two natures.
Concession

What classical theism can grant

Impassibility, as Chapter 3 qualified it, means God does not suffer involuntarily, not that God is emotionally inert. Thomas Weinandy argues that God's compassion is a fully active, freely willed engagement and so makes his solidarity with sufferers more complete. Classical theism will not concede that God's divine nature or the Trinity's inner relations were altered by the cross.

Key idea Both sides affirm real, costly divine engagement with suffering.
Think about it

Does active compassion console?

Weinandy argues an impassible God's compassion is more complete because it is active, not passively undergone.

Is this a satisfying answer to Moltmann's pastoral concern, or could it sound to a sufferer like untouched invulnerability?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Moltmann holds that the cross is a suffering within the Trinity. Classical theism holds that Christ suffered in his human nature and that God is impassible. Both affirm that God has drawn near to human suffering, and the dispute is whether this requires suffering in God's own being.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13