FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST3E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-2: Three Classical Views of the Image — Substantive, Relational, Functional

The image has been read as a capacity, a relationship and a role. Each fits some of the evidence, so the course holds the three together.

Systematic Theology III: Anthropology

12 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the substantive view of the image, its typical textual support, and its principal historical and contemporary weakness.
  • State the relational view of the image, associated significantly with twentieth-century theology, and its principal weakness.
  • State the functional/royal view, its strong support in Genesis 1's own grammar and ancient Near Eastern background, and its principal weakness.
  • Explain why this lecture argues the three views are better held together as complementary aspects of one doctrine than treated as mutually exclusive options to choose between.
  • Apply this synthesis, at least provisionally, to a case the substantive view alone would struggle to answer.
Scripture

Why Genesis 1:26-27?

The lecture uses this one sentence because each of the three views finds its strongest evidence in it: "in our image," "male and female" and "let them have dominion." The text states them in the same breath and does not force a choice.

God said, 'Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the sky, and over the livestock, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth.' ... God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." Genesis 1:26-27 · World English Bible
Substantive view

The image as capacity

The oldest and most common view says the image is something a human has, classically reason or an immortal soul. Thomas Aquinas places it chiefly in the mind. This explains why humans, and not animals, are singled out, and why the image can survive the loss of the body. Its weakness is that capacities come in degrees, which could suggest degrees of image-bearing that Genesis 9:6 does not allow.

Key idea Reason and moral capacity are real, but dignity should not vary with them.
Relational view

The image as relationship

Karl Barth and Emil Brunner placed the image in relationship, with God and with other humans, beginning with the male-female relationship named in Genesis 1:27. Barth called this the analogia relationis, an analogy of relation, as the persons of the Trinity exist in relationship. Its weakness is that people who are isolated do not lose the image. The doctrine needs the capacity for relationship, not constant exercise of it.

Key idea Humanity is created for relationship, as a permanent feature of being human.
Functional view

The image as royal role

The functional view says the image is humanity's commissioned role as God's vice-regents over creation. J. Richard Middleton gives its fullest recent defense. Earlier texts used "image of god" almost only of kings, so Genesis applies to the whole human race language that elsewhere applied to one man on a throne. Its weakness is that an infant or a person with late dementia does not exercise dominion, so careful defenders speak of a permanent commissioned status.

Key idea The view explains why dominion stands in the same sentence as image.
At a glance

Three views, three weaknesses

Substantive and relational

Capacity (Aquinas): capacities vary, but dignity should not. Relationship (Barth): isolation should not remove the image.

Functional

Role (Middleton): a role can go unexercised without lapsing. Each view's best defenders move toward a status conferred at creation.

Synthesis

One conferred status

The course's position is not to pick one of the three. The image names a whole way of being human, conferred as a status at creation. Rational and moral capacity, essential relationality and a commissioned role are three true and complementary descriptions of it. The lecture says readers will not all agree, and that this is the course's own constructive judgment.

Key idea The status does not depend on moment-to-moment exercise.
Test case

The final stage of Alzheimer's disease

Take a person in the final stage of Alzheimer's disease. Reason is largely gone, and the person cannot recognize family or exercise dominion. A strict form of any one view needs real work to explain why this person still bears the image. The synthesis answers more simply: this person was created with a permanent, unrevoked status as God's image-bearer, never contingent on continuous reasoning, relating or ruling.

Key idea Status, not performance, grounds the image.
Think about it

A newborn infant

Consider an infant only minutes old.

What would the substantive, relational and functional views each say on their own about whether this infant fully bears the image, and what does the synthesis say instead?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The image has been read as capacity, relationship and role, and each view alone leaves a problem. The course holds them together as three descriptions of one status God confers at creation. A person's worth does not rise or fall with their abilities.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12