FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST4E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-5: History of the Doctrine, Part Two — Reformation and Modern Revisions

The Reformation re-asserted Augustine's view of sin, and two modern thinkers then pulled the doctrine in different directions.

Systematic Theology IV: Hamartiology

12 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State Luther's argument in The Bondage of the Will against Erasmus, and what specifically was at stake between them.
  • State Calvin's doctrine of total depravity and its relationship to Augustine's mature position.
  • Describe Schleiermacher's redefinition of sin as a deficiency of God-consciousness, and explain what shifts when sin is defined this way rather than in Augustine's or Calvin's terms.
  • Describe Niebuhr's mid-twentieth-century recovery of sin as a serious theological category, and what specifically he was reacting against.
The story so far

Two movements, not one arc

The Augustine and Pelagius controversy resurfaced in the Reformation with its terms essentially unchanged. Luther and Calvin recover a position, Schleiermacher revises it in a direction later theologians judged too optimistic, and Niebuhr reacts against that optimism from within modern theology. The lecture does not force the four into a single storyline.

Key idea Two real trajectories left the course its vocabulary.
Scripture

Why Jeremiah 17:9?

The lecture uses this verse because Luther and Calvin read it as support for the claim that a fallen will's own self-assessment cannot be trusted. Calvin cited it for a corruption reaching to the seat of human self-knowledge.

The heart is deceitful above all things, and it is exceedingly corrupt: who can know it?" Jeremiah 17:9 · World English Bible
Luther

Horizontal freedom, not vertical

In 1524 Erasmus argued carefully for a limited human freedom to cooperate with grace. Luther replied in 1525 with The Bondage of the Will. Fallen people have free will only in a narrow sense over ordinary earthly matters, but not the freedom to choose God without grace first acting on the will. Luther leaned on Augustine and saw himself recovering him.

Key idea Luther saw a resurgence of Pelagian instincts around merit.
Calvin

Total depravity

Calvin's Institutes systematized a closely related position. Total depravity does not mean every person is as evil as possible. It means sin's corruption extends to every part of the person, mind, will and affections, so that no faculty on its own can turn the person toward God. Calvin, like Luther, understood this as recovering Augustine, not innovating.

Key idea The doctrine is about reach, not degree.
At a glance

Two ways of defining sin

Augustine and Calvin

Sin is guilt before a holy Lawgiver. The remedy has to include something that resolves that guilt, which is atonement in a substantially forensic sense.

Schleiermacher

Sin is a deficiency or arrestment of God-consciousness, less something done against God. The remedy looks more like Christ's perfect God-consciousness awakening a corresponding one in the believer.

Niebuhr

Recovering sin as a serious category

Writing in the 1930s and 1940s, Niebuhr argued that liberal confidence in moral progress had been refuted by the century's own history. He did not simply return to Calvin. He developed an account of sin as pride, the self's willful overreach beyond creaturely limits, in individuals and with particular force in nations and institutions. He stayed in critical conversation with the liberal tradition.

Key idea His project was a recovery from within modern theology.
Caution

Neither is a footnote to the other

It would be tidy but false to treat Schleiermacher as a wrong turn later corrected. His attention to religious experience raised a real question about the inner side of sin and grace. Niebuhr is not simply Calvin in modern dress, since his collective pride anticipates Chapter 4's structural sin. The course still sides with Augustine, Luther and Calvin on sin's relational and legal weight.

Key idea Each figure raised real questions.
Think about it

Your own picture of sin

The lecture shows that how sin is defined shapes what the remedy looks like.

Is your own picture of sin closer to guilt, pride or deficiency, and how does that shape the help you would offer someone?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Luther and Calvin recovered Augustine's view that sin reaches the whole person. Schleiermacher redefined sin as deficient God-consciousness, and Niebuhr recovered it as pride. How sin is defined changes what the remedy looks like, and the history is not one straight line.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12