FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

ST4E Systematic Theology IV: Hamartiology

Lecture 1-5: History of the Doctrine, Part Two — Reformation and Modern Revisions

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 31
ST4E Systematic Theology IV: Hamartiology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Hamartiology Is, and Why It Comes Fourth
  1. Introduction: What Hamartiology Is, and Why It Comes Fourth
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Prolegomena: Defining Sin and the History of the Doctrine
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Sin Is — A Working Definition
  2. Lecture 1-2: Hamartiology's Place in the Systematic Sequence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Method for a Biblical Theology of Sin
  4. Lecture 1-4: History of the Doctrine, Part One — Augustine Against Pelagius
  5. Lecture 1-5: History of the Doctrine, Part Two — Reformation and Modern Revisions
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Sin in Biblical Revelation: Vocabulary and Nature
  1. Lecture 2-1: Old Testament Vocabulary of Sin
  2. Lecture 2-2: New Testament Vocabulary of Sin
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Nature of Sin as Relational Rupture and Rebellion
  4. Lecture 2-4: Sin's Legal and Ethical Dimension
  5. Lecture 2-5: The Law and Sin in Romans 7
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Origin of Sin: Satan, the Fall, and Original Sin
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Fall of Satan and the Origin of Evil Among the Angels
  2. Lecture 3-2: Adam's Fall — The Serpent's Strategy and the Shape of the First Sin
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Doctrine of Original Sin
  4. Lecture 3-4: How Original Sin Is Transmitted — Federal Headship and Realism
  5. Lecture 3-5: Total Depravity and the Bondage of the Will
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Universality and Forms of Sin
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Universality of Sin in Scripture
  2. Lecture 4-2: Original Sin, Actual Sin, and Personal Responsibility
  3. Lecture 4-3: Structural and Systemic Sin
  4. Lecture 4-4: Sin as Pride versus Sin as Sloth or Despair
  5. Lecture 4-5: Conscience, Natural Law, and the Sin of the Nations
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Consequences and Punishment of Sin
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Death
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Noetic and Psychological Effects of Sin
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sin's Effect on Creation
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Wrath and Judgment of God Against Sin
  5. Lecture 5-5: Eternal Punishment, Hell, and Final Judgment
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Sin in Contemporary and Pastoral Perspective
  1. Lecture 6-1: Evolutionary Biology and the Historicity of Adam
  2. Lecture 6-2: Guilt Cultures and Shame Cultures
  3. Lecture 6-3: Pastoral Care and Sin — Addiction, Trauma, and Spiritual Desolation
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Bridge to Soteriology
  5. Lecture 6-5: Remaining Sin in the Believer

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

The Augustine-Pelagius controversy did not end at the Council of Orange; it resurfaced, essentially unchanged in its basic terms, over a thousand years later in the Reformation, and then took two sharply different modern turns in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. This lecture follows both movements. First, the Reformation's own re-assertion of Augustinian anthropology — Luther's argument against Erasmus over the freedom (or bondage) of the will, and Calvin's doctrine of total depravity — which the Reformers understood themselves as recovering rather than inventing. Second, two very different modern departures from that Augustinian consensus: Friedrich Schleiermacher's nineteenth-century redefinition of sin in terms of a deficiency of God-consciousness, and Reinhold Niebuhr's twentieth-century argument that theological liberalism (a tradition substantially shaped by Schleiermacher's legacy) had lost sight of sin as a serious category altogether, and needed to recover it.

Placing these four figures in one lecture is not an attempt to force them into a single storyline. Luther and Calvin are recovering a position; Schleiermacher is revising it in a direction many later theologians (including Niebuhr) judged too optimistic; Niebuhr is reacting against exactly that optimism, but from within modern theology rather than by simply returning to Reformation orthodoxy. The chapter's closing claim is that this is not a tidy arc from Augustine to today — it is two real trajectories that pulled in different directions, and this course's own later chapters inherit vocabulary from both.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • State Luther's argument in *The Bondage of the Will* against Erasmus, and what specifically was at stake between them.
  • State Calvin's doctrine of total depravity and its relationship to Augustine's mature position.
  • Describe Schleiermacher's redefinition of sin as a deficiency of God-consciousness, and explain what shifts when sin is defined this way rather than in Augustine's or Calvin's terms.
  • Describe Niebuhr's mid-twentieth-century recovery of sin as a serious theological category, and what specifically he was reacting against.

The heart is deceitful above all things, and it is exceedingly corrupt: who can know it?" — Jeremiah 17:9

World English Bible

This verse became one of the Reformation's favorite texts for describing the fallen human condition, and it is worth noticing exactly what it claims and does not claim. It does not simply say the heart is capable of wrongdoing; it says the heart is "deceitful above all things" — capable of deceiving even the person whose heart it is — and "exceedingly corrupt," to the point that the prophet himself asks, seemingly rhetorically, "who can know it?" Luther and Calvin both read this verse as strong support for their claim that the fallen will's own self-assessment cannot be trusted as evidence of its actual moral capacity; a will this thoroughly compromised is not well positioned to certify its own health. Schleiermacher, working from a different starting point (described below), read the human condition in markedly gentler terms.

1. The Reformation's re-assertion: Luther against Erasmus

In 1524, Erasmus of Rotterdam published On Free Will (De Libero Arbitrio), arguing — carefully and with real learning, not as a crude Pelagian — that Scripture and the weight of Christian tradition supported a genuine, if limited, human freedom to cooperate with grace, a position closer to the semi-Pelagian and later medieval Catholic mainstream than to Pelagius's own unqualified position. Luther's 1525 response, The Bondage of the Will (De Servo Arbitrio), which Luther himself later regarded as among his most important works, argued that fallen human beings possess free will only in a narrow, "horizontal" sense — the ability to choose among ordinary earthly matters, what to eat, whom to marry, which trade to pursue — but not the "vertical" freedom to choose God or the good that pleases God without grace first and decisively acting on the will. Luther's argument leaned heavily on Augustine's mature anti-Pelagian writings, explicitly positioning himself as recovering Augustine's position against what he saw as a resurgence of Pelagian and semi-Pelagian instincts within late medieval Catholic theology and piety, particularly around and human contribution to salvation.

Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion systematized a closely related position under the heading later tradition calls — not the claim that every person is as evil as they could possibly be (a common misunderstanding this course corrects directly in Chapter 3, lecture 3-5, where the doctrine is treated at full length), but the claim that sin's corruption extends to every part of the human person — mind, will, and affections — so that no faculty remains untouched and capable, on its own, of turning the person toward God. Calvin, like Luther, understood this as a recovery of Augustine rather than an innovation, and cited Jeremiah 17:9 as direct textual support for a corruption reaching to the very seat of human self-knowledge.

2. Modern revision, direction one: Schleiermacher's redefinition

Friedrich Schleiermacher, writing in early-nineteenth-century Germany in a theological context shaped by Enlightenment rationalism and Romantic sensibility, redefined sin in terms substantially different from either Augustine's or Calvin's framework. In his major systematic work, The Christian Faith (Der christliche Glaube), Schleiermacher located the essence of religion in a feeling of "absolute dependence" on God — what he called God-consciousness. On this framework, sin is redefined as a deficiency or arrestment of that God-consciousness: not primarily rebellion against a personal God whose law has been broken (the relational and legal dimensions this course's Lecture 1-1 insisted on holding together), but an underdevelopment of the human capacity for God-consciousness relative to the sinner's own sensuous, worldly consciousness. Sin, for Schleiermacher, is less something a person does against God and more a kind of arrested spiritual development, a falling short of a capacity every human being possesses in principle.

This redefinition is not merely a matter of new vocabulary; it changes what sin's remedy looks like. If sin is guilt before a holy Lawgiver (Augustine, Calvin), the remedy has to include something that resolves that guilt — atonement, in a substantially forensic sense. If sin is arrested God-consciousness, the remedy looks more like Christ's God-consciousness (which Schleiermacher held to be perfect and unbroken) awakening and strengthening a corresponding consciousness in the believer — a real change, on Schleiermacher's own terms, but one considerably less oriented around guilt, wrath, and forensic transaction than the Reformation's account. Many later critics, including Niebuhr, judged this redefinition part of a broader nineteenth-century liberal Protestant tendency to soften sin into something more like an educational deficiency than a moral and relational catastrophe.

3. Modern revision, direction two: Niebuhr's recovery

Reinhold Niebuhr, writing in the 1930s and 1940s against the backdrop of the Great Depression, the rise of fascism, and two world wars, argued in works including Moral Man and Immoral Society and his major systematic statement The Nature and Destiny of Man that the substantially shaped by Schleiermacher's legacy — with its confidence in human moral progress, its softened account of sin, and (in some of its more optimistic strands) its assumption that better education, social reform, or religious feeling could steadily reduce human evil — had been decisively refuted by the twentieth century's own historical record. Niebuhr did not simply return to Calvin's total depravity or Augustine's inherited-guilt framework wholesale; he developed his own account (already introduced in Lecture 1-1) of sin as pride — the self's anxious, willful over-reach beyond its creaturely limits, both individually and, with particular force in his social and political writing, collectively, in nations and institutions that commit atrocities individuals within them might never commit alone. Niebuhr's project is best described as a recovery of sin as a serious theological category from within modern theology, using modern historical and psychological tools, rather than a simple return to Reformation confessional orthodoxy — he remained, in various ways, in critical conversation with the liberal tradition he was correcting, not a wholesale defector from it.

4. Two trajectories, not one arc

Not one tidy line

A caution worth stating plainly, per this course's method (Lecture 1-3) and its warning against elegance (this course's own working discipline): it would be tidy, but false, to narrate this lecture's material as a single line running from Augustine through the Reformers to a modern recovery in Niebuhr, as though Schleiermacher were simply a wrong turn later corrected. Schleiermacher's move was not merely an error to be dismissed; his attention to religious experience, and his refusal to treat sin as a purely external, forensic category disconnected from the sinner's actual felt life, raised a genuine question about the inner, experiential dimension of sin and grace that purely forensic accounts can underplay — a question this course's own attention to sin's moral dimension (Lecture 1-1) and to the noetic and psychological effects of sin (Chapter 5, lecture 5-2) takes seriously in its own way, even while ultimately siding with Augustine, Luther, and Calvin on sin's relational and legal weight. Niebuhr, likewise, is not simply "Calvin restated in modern dress" — his account of collective and structural pride anticipates concerns this course takes up directly in Chapter 4 (lecture 4-3, on structural sin) in ways Calvin's sixteenth-century context did not require him to address. Two real, different trajectories left this course's working vocabulary; neither should be flattened into a footnote to the other.


From Augustine to the Twentieth Century: Two Trajectories Augustine (1-4) Luther vs. Erasmus Bondage of the will Calvin Total depravity Schleiermacher Sin as deficient God-consciousness Niebuhr Recovers sin as pride, against liberal optimism

5. Going to the Sources

Read Martin Luther, The Bondage of the Will, especially the closing sections where Luther states his central thesis in his own summary form (widely available in the J. I. Packer and O. R. Johnston translation). For the modern side, read Reinhold Niebuhr, The Nature and Destiny of Man, Volume I, Chapter 1 ("Man as a Problem to Himself"), where Niebuhr states his critique of both naturalistic and idealistic (including liberal-Protestant) accounts of human nature before developing his own position.


In short

  • Erasmus argued in 1524 for a limited human freedom to cooperate with grace. Luther replied in 1525 that fallen people have only "horizontal" freedom over earthly matters, not "vertical" freedom to choose God without grace.
  • Calvin's total depravity means sin reaches every part of the person: mind, will and affections. It does not mean everyone is as evil as possible. Both Reformers saw themselves as recovering Augustine.
  • Schleiermacher redefined sin as a deficiency of God-consciousness, a kind of arrested development, rather than rebellion against a Lawgiver. This also changes the remedy, which becomes less forensic.
  • Niebuhr, writing against liberal optimism after the Depression, fascism and two world wars, recovered sin as pride, individual and collective, using modern tools rather than simply returning to Reformation orthodoxy.
  • The lecture warns against one tidy arc. Schleiermacher raised a real question about sin's experiential side, and Niebuhr's collective view goes beyond Calvin. Two trajectories shaped the course's vocabulary.

Topic: This lecture follows the doctrine of sin from the Reformation debates of Luther, Erasmus and Calvin to the modern revisions of Schleiermacher and Niebuhr.

Remember: How sin is defined shapes what the remedy looks like. Guilt before a Lawgiver points to atonement. Arrested God-consciousness points to a different kind of change.

Caution: Do not read the history as a straight line with Schleiermacher as a mere wrong turn. The lecture says each figure raised real questions, and the course still sides with Augustine, Luther and Calvin on relational and legal weight.

One line to carry into ministry: Notice how your own picture of sin, whether guilt, pride or deficiency, shapes the kind of help you offer.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Luther distinguished "horizontal" freedom (choosing among earthly matters) from "vertical" freedom (choosing God without grace). Do you find this distinction persuasive, or does it feel like a way of granting freedom in name while denying it in substance? Explain your reasoning.
  • Schleiermacher's redefinition of sin as deficient God-consciousness changes what the remedy for sin has to look like. If you had to state, in one sentence, what is gained and what is lost by defining sin this way rather than in Augustine's or Calvin's terms, what would you say?
  • Niebuhr wrote his major work on sin during and just after some of the twentieth century's worst atrocities. Does a doctrine of sin's seriousness need a crisis to become credible to a given generation, or can it be sustained in seasons of relative peace and prosperity? What might this course's own historical moment be doing to its readers' intuitions about how seriously to take sin?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.