FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

ST6E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: Contemporary Controversies — Excess in Both Directions

Paul names two opposite failures in one sentence, quenching the Spirit and accepting claims without testing, and the lecture holds both together.

Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology

12 cards 16 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State, with named sources, what the Toronto Blessing (1994) and the Lakeland Revival (2008) actually involved, and what specifically drew criticism in each case.
  • Extend Lecture 5-4's critique of prosperity/Word of Faith theology using at least one additional named source, without repeating that lecture's argument unchanged.
  • State the danger of institutional "quenching" of the Spirit as a real and opposite failure to uncritical enthusiasm, with at least one named example of the concern being raised.
  • Explain why 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21 requires holding both dangers together rather than treating either commandment as more important than the other.
Scripture

Why 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21?

The lecture uses this passage because Paul names two opposite failures in one breath: "Don't quench the Spirit. Don't despise prophesies," and also "Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." It insists on both, as Paul does.

Don't quench the Spirit. Don't despise prophesies. Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21 · World English Bible
Commerce

The commercialization of faith

Historian Kate Bowler traces how prosperity teaching grew with broadcast economics. A televised ministry is paid for by viewer giving, and teaching that giving is a "seed" for a larger "harvest" gives the preacher a financial incentive to keep teaching it. She describes a pattern and a structure, not the motives of any individual. The costs fall hardest where people have little financial margin.

Key idea The criticism is of a structure and its incentives.
Toronto, 1994

The Toronto Blessing

It began at the Toronto Airport Vineyard church and spread internationally. Participants described uncontrollable laughter, falling and shaking, and some witnesses described animal-like behavior. John Wimber, the Vineyard founder, grew concerned about the excesses and the lack of clear scriptural grounding, and the Toronto church was separated from the Vineyard association in December 1995. It was a dispute inside the charismatic world about order, not only charismatics against cessationists.

Key idea A dispute about disputed phenomena.
Lakeland, 2008

The Lakeland Revival

Meetings in Lakeland, Florida, drew large crowds with reports of healings and wide attention through internet broadcast. The revival collapsed within months, after revelations of the leader's marital infidelity and the withdrawal of support by the movement's own leadership. The lecture calls this first of all a leader's moral failure, and only secondly a dispute about the phenomena.

Key idea Lakeland differs in kind from Toronto.
The other danger

Institutional quenching

After documented excesses, institutions can move from legitimate caution to blanket suspicion. They may treat any unusual spiritual experience as presumptively illegitimate, or discipline pastors for practices Scripture does not forbid. The lecture notes that Paul names this failure first. As a named example it gives John MacArthur's 2013 Strange Fire conference, which urged a return to cessationism because of documented abuse. The lecture calls his concern to protect the church legitimate.

Key idea Overcaution is a real danger, not an invented one.
The reply

Grudem and Storms respond

Wayne Grudem and Sam Storms replied that Strange Fire moved from criticizing specific abuses to a categorical judgment against continuationism as such. This included scholars and congregations with no connection to the abuses cited. They argued that this broader move is itself a form of quenching, because it does not test claims individually as 1 Thessalonians 5:21 commands.

Key idea Test claims one at a time.
At a glance

Two opposite failures, one command

Uncritical acceptance

Commercialized "seed faith," the disputed phenomena at Toronto, and the leader's moral failure at Lakeland. Paul says do not despise prophesies, but test.

Institutional quenching

Blanket suspicion of any unusual spiritual experience. Paul says do not quench the Spirit.

Think it through

Quenching or discernment?

The lecture says readers will not agree which danger is more urgent in their own setting.

Have you or your church experienced caution about spiritual gifts that felt more like quenching than discernment, or an uncritical acceptance that later proved damaging? What made the difference?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Paul commands both "Don't quench the Spirit" and "Test all things." Neither command outranks the other, and honest testing sorts claims one by one. Test each claim on its own merits: do not accept everything, and do not reject everything.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12