FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

ST6E Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology

Lecture 6-4: Contemporary Controversies — Excess in Both Directions

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 31
ST6E Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Pneumatology Is, and Why It Comes Sixth
  1. Introduction: What Pneumatology Is, and Why It Comes Sixth
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Holy Spirit in Biblical History
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Spirit in Creation and the Old Testament
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Spirit and Christ
  3. Lecture 1-3: Pentecost — The Hinge of Biblical Pneumatology
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Spirit's Spread — Acts and Paul
  5. Lecture 1-5: A Biblical-Theological Synthesis — Two Honest Readings
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Person and Deity of the Holy Spirit
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Personhood of the Holy Spirit
  2. Lecture 2-2: Full Deity — from Acts 5 to Constantinople 381
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Filioque Controversy
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Spirit within the Trinity — Perichoresis, Inseparable Operations, and Appropriation
  5. Lecture 2-5: Names, Titles, and Symbols of the Holy Spirit
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Spirit and the Application of Salvation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Common Grace and the Spirit's Restraint of Evil
  2. Lecture 3-2: Conviction and Calling — Effectual, Prevenient, or Sacramental?
  3. Lecture 3-3: Regeneration, the New Birth
  4. Lecture 3-4: Indwelling, Sealing, and the Spirit as Down Payment
  5. Lecture 3-5: Assurance — the Spirit's Witness and Its Pastoral History
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Spirit and Sanctification
  1. Lecture 4-1: Definitive and Progressive Sanctification
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Fruit of the Spirit
  3. Lecture 4-3: Mortification and Vivification
  4. Lecture 4-4: Keeping in Step with the Spirit — the Ordinary Means of Grace
  5. Lecture 4-5: The Spirit and Suffering
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Spiritual Gifts and the Contested Questions
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Gifts Defined and Surveyed
  2. Lecture 5-2: Baptism and Fullness of the Spirit — the Central Debate
  3. Lecture 5-3: Tongues and Prophecy, Then and Now
  4. Lecture 5-4: Healing and the Already/Not Yet of the Kingdom
  5. Lecture 5-5: Discernment — Testing the Spirits
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Spirit, the Church, and the World Today
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Spirit and the Church's Unity and Mission
  2. Lecture 6-2: Global Renewal Movements, Historically Compared
  3. Lecture 6-3: Pentecostalism and the Charismatic Movement as a Global Phenomenon
  4. Lecture 6-4: Contemporary Controversies — Excess in Both Directions
  5. Lecture 6-5: Ecumenical Convergence and Remaining Difference

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

Paul's charge to the Thessalonian church names two opposite failures in a single breath: "Don't quench the Spirit. Don't despise prophesies. Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:19-21). The command not to quench assumes a real danger of suppressing genuine work of the Spirit out of caution, suspicion, or institutional control. The command to test assumes an equally real danger of accepting claimed spiritual experience uncritically, without the discernment Lecture 5-5 already argued the church is responsible to exercise. Most treatments of controversy in global Pentecostal and charismatic Christianity pick one danger and warn against it at length while barely mentioning the other. This lecture insists on both, in the same lecture, because Paul does.

The material here extends, rather than repeats, ground already covered: Lecture 5-4's critique of prosperity theology is revisited with specific documented episodes; Lecture 5-5's discernment framework is applied to two named events; and the danger of institutional overcaution, only mentioned in passing before now, gets its own full argument. Readers should expect this lecture to unsettle comfortable positions on both sides of the continuationist/cessationist and charismatic/institutional divides, not just one.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • State, with named sources, what the Toronto Blessing (1994) and the Lakeland Revival (2008) actually involved, and what specifically drew criticism in each case.
  • Extend Lecture 5-4's critique of prosperity/Word of Faith theology using at least one additional named source, without repeating that lecture's argument unchanged.
  • State the danger of institutional "quenching" of the Spirit as a real and opposite failure to uncritical enthusiasm, with at least one named example of the concern being raised.
  • Explain why 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21 requires holding both dangers together rather than treating either commandment as more important than the other.

Don't quench the Spirit. Don't despise prophesies. Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21

World English Bible

1. Extending the prosperity critique: the commercialization of faith

Lecture 5-4 already stated the core theological problem with prosperity/Word of Faith theology: it treats healing and material wealth as guaranteed to sufficient faith, a claim Paul's own unhealed "thorn in the flesh" (2 Corinthians 12:7-9) stands as a canonical counter-example against. This lecture does not restate that argument; it extends it into the specifically commercial dimension that becomes most visible at global scale. Historian Kate Bowler, in Blessed: A History of the American Prosperity Gospel (2013), traces how prosperity teaching developed alongside, and was shaped by, broadcast media economics: a televised ministry's operating costs are met by viewer giving, and a theology that frames giving itself as a "seed" guaranteed to produce a proportionally larger financial "harvest" (a reading often built on 2 Corinthians 9:6's "he who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly") creates a direct financial incentive for the preacher to keep teaching it, whatever the preacher's personal sincerity. Bowler is a historian describing a pattern, not a heresy-hunter assigning motive to any specific individual, and this lecture follows her caution: the criticism is of a theological structure and its commercial incentives, not an accusation that every prosperity preacher personally intends to exploit anyone.

The commercialization becomes most visible where prosperity teaching is exported into economically vulnerable communities in the Majority World — precisely the regions Lecture 6-3 identified as sites of the fastest Pentecostal and charismatic growth — where a promise that sufficient faith and sufficient giving guarantee material breakthrough carries different, and arguably higher, stakes for someone with little financial margin than for a comfortable Western television audience. Naming this is not a claim that prosperity theology is a uniquely Majority World problem — it was not invented there, and Bowler's own history is substantially about its American origins — but an honest observation about where its costs land hardest.

2. The Toronto Blessing (1994) and the Lakeland Revival (2008)

Two more recent, well-documented episodes illustrate a different kind of controversy: not doctrinal commercialization but disputed phenomena and, in one case, a catastrophic moral failure.

The Toronto Blessing began in January 1994 at the Toronto Airport Vineyard church under pastor John Arnott and spread internationally through visiting clergy and reported cross-denominational "impartation," producing phenomena that participants described as uncontrollable laughter ("holy laughter"), falling to the ground, shaking, and, more controversially, behavior some witnesses described in animal terms (roaring, barking). The movement produced a serious rift within its own Vineyard denomination: John Wimber, the Vineyard movement's founder, initially supportive, grew concerned enough about the phenomena's excesses and lack of clear scriptural grounding that the Toronto church was formally separated from the Vineyard association in December 1995 — a fact worth stating because it shows the controversy was not simply "charismatics versus cessationists" but a dispute within the continuationist and charismatic world itself about where legitimate spiritual manifestation ends and disorderly excess (the very concern 1 Corinthians 14:40's "let all things be done decently and in order" addresses) begins.

The Lakeland Revival, centered on preacher Todd Bentley's meetings in Lakeland, Florida, beginning in April 2008, drew large crowds with reports of healings and drew broad charismatic-world attention through internet broadcast, before collapsing within months amid revelations of Bentley's marital infidelity and the movement's own leadership publicly withdrawing support. The Lakeland case differs in kind from Toronto's disputed-phenomena controversy: it is, first and centrally, a moral failure by a leader, and only secondarily a dispute about the legitimacy of the phenomena reported at his meetings. Treating the two cases identically would blur an important distinction — a claimed spiritual manifestation can be judged questionable on scriptural and pastoral grounds without any accusation of personal misconduct, while Lakeland's central problem was misconduct that would have discredited the ministry regardless of what one concluded about the phenomena themselves.

3. The opposite danger: institutional quenching of the Spirit

State the other direction with equal weight, because it receives far less attention in most treatments of this material and Paul's own command in 1 Thessalonians 5:19-20 names it first. Institutions — denominations, seminaries, individual congregations — can and do respond to documented excesses like Toronto and Lakeland by moving from legitimate caution into a blanket suspicion that treats any unusual spiritual experience as presumptively illegitimate, discourages members from ever raising the subject, or disciplines pastors for permitting practices (public prayer for healing, corporate prayer in tongues conducted in good order per 1 Corinthians 14:39-40's "don't forbid speaking with other languages... let all things be done decently and in order") that Scripture itself does not forbid. This is not a hypothetical danger invented for symmetry; it is the specific failure Paul names first in his own sentence, before he names the danger of uncritical acceptance.

A concrete, named example helps make the concern precise rather than abstract, while treated with the same fairness this course has tried to extend to every contested position. John MacArthur's 2013 "Strange Fire" conference and accompanying book argued forcefully that the modern charismatic movement, taken as a whole, has produced enough documented abuse — citing episodes not unlike Toronto and Lakeland — to warrant treating continuationist claims about ongoing revelatory gifts as a serious danger to the church, effectively urging a return to the cessationist position argued in Lecture 5-3. MacArthur's concern to protect the church from real, documented harm is a legitimate pastoral instinct, and this lecture does not dismiss it. But continuationist scholars including Wayne Grudem and Sam Storms — the same figures already named in Lecture 5-3 for their case that revelatory gifts continue — responded that "Strange Fire" moved from criticizing specific documented abuses to a categorical judgment against as such, including against continuationist scholars and congregations with no connection to the abuses cited, and argued that this broader move is itself a form of quenching: treating an entire, biblically defensible position as illegitimate because some of its adherents have misused it, rather than testing claims individually as 1 Thessalonians 5:21 actually commands.

4. Holding both commands together

The temptation, for a reader who has just read about Toronto's excesses and Lakeland's scandal, is to conclude that caution should simply win — that quenching is the safer error. The temptation for a reader from a tradition that has experienced institutional suspicion firsthand is the reverse: to conclude that any criticism of charismatic excess is itself suspect, an instance of exactly the quenching this lecture has just named. Paul's own sentence structure resists both simplifications: "don't quench" and "don't despise prophesies" are not qualified or ranked against each other, and "test all things, and hold firmly that which is good" assumes testing will actually sort claims into some that should be held firmly and some that should not — not that everything untested should be rejected, and not that everything claimed should be accepted. The two documented excesses examined above and the documented danger of institutional overcaution are not, on this reading, opposite lessons pulling in different directions; they are the same command, applied honestly in both directions, which is exactly what makes this material as uncomfortable to write fairly as it is necessary to include.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Readers from traditions shaped by documented charismatic excess may weigh the case for caution more heavily; readers from traditions that have experienced institutional suspicion of any unusual spiritual experience may weigh the case against quenching more heavily. Both readings can be held by someone taking 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21 seriously; the text itself does not resolve which danger is more urgent in any particular reader's own context, only that both are real.


1 Thessalonians 5:19-21 — Two Opposite Failures, One Command Uncritical acceptance Prosperity/Word of Faith: commercialized "seed faith" (Bowler) Toronto Blessing (1994): disputed phenomena, Vineyard split Lakeland (2008): leader's moral failure, movement collapse "Don't despise prophesies" — but test Institutional quenching Blanket suspicion of any unusual spiritual experience "Strange Fire" (2013): documented abuses generalized into a categorical rejection of continuationism as such (Grudem and Storms's reply) "Don't quench the Spirit" "Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good" Neither command is subordinate to the other

5. Going to the Sources

Read the "Open Letter to Charismatics" section of Wayne Grudem's response essay in the volume Strange Fire: A Rebuttal, co-edited with Sam Storms and C. Michael Patton (2014), written in direct reply to MacArthur's "Strange Fire" conference and book. The document matters here because it is a considered, named, in-print continuationist response to a specific and influential cessationist critique, giving a reader access to both sides of a live, ongoing controversy in their own words rather than only in this lecture's summary of it.


In short

  • First Thessalonians 5:19-21 names two opposite dangers: quenching the Spirit and accepting claims without testing. The lecture insists on holding both together.
  • Kate Bowler traces how prosperity teaching grew with broadcast economics. Giving is framed as a "seed" for a larger "harvest," which gives preachers a financial incentive. She describes a pattern, not any individual's motives.
  • The Toronto Blessing (1994) brought a dispute over disputed phenomena and a Vineyard split. Lakeland (2008) was, first, a leader's moral failure. The lecture treats these as different in kind.
  • Institutions can slide from caution into blanket suspicion. John MacArthur's Strange Fire is the example. Wayne Grudem and Sam Storms replied that it condemned continuationism as such, instead of testing claims individually.
  • Both commands apply together. Readers will not agree which danger is more urgent in their own setting.

Topic: This lecture examines recent controversies in Pentecostal and charismatic Christianity and argues that excess exists in both directions.

Remember: Paul commands both "Don't quench the Spirit" and "Test all things." Neither command outranks the other, and honest testing sorts claims one by one.

Caution: The lecture does not say that prosperity preachers all intend harm, that Toronto and Lakeland were the same kind of case, or that criticism of excess is itself quenching.

One line to carry into ministry: Test each claim on its own merits. Do not accept everything, and do not reject everything.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Kate Bowler describes prosperity theology's commercial incentives as a historical pattern rather than an accusation against any individual's sincerity. Why does that distinction matter, and what would be lost by skipping it and simply calling every prosperity preacher a fraud?
  • This lecture treats the Toronto Blessing and the Lakeland Revival as different in kind — one a dispute about phenomena, the other centrally a moral failure. Why does that distinction matter for how a church should respond to each kind of case?
  • Have you (or has your church) experienced institutional caution about spiritual gifts that felt, on reflection, more like quenching than like legitimate discernment — or, alternately, uncritical acceptance of a claim that later proved damaging? What made the difference, looking back?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.