FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

ST6E Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology

Lecture 6-5: Ecumenical Convergence and Remaining Difference

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 31
ST6E Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Pneumatology Is, and Why It Comes Sixth
  1. Introduction: What Pneumatology Is, and Why It Comes Sixth
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Holy Spirit in Biblical History
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Spirit in Creation and the Old Testament
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Spirit and Christ
  3. Lecture 1-3: Pentecost — The Hinge of Biblical Pneumatology
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Spirit's Spread — Acts and Paul
  5. Lecture 1-5: A Biblical-Theological Synthesis — Two Honest Readings
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Person and Deity of the Holy Spirit
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Personhood of the Holy Spirit
  2. Lecture 2-2: Full Deity — from Acts 5 to Constantinople 381
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Filioque Controversy
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Spirit within the Trinity — Perichoresis, Inseparable Operations, and Appropriation
  5. Lecture 2-5: Names, Titles, and Symbols of the Holy Spirit
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Spirit and the Application of Salvation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Common Grace and the Spirit's Restraint of Evil
  2. Lecture 3-2: Conviction and Calling — Effectual, Prevenient, or Sacramental?
  3. Lecture 3-3: Regeneration, the New Birth
  4. Lecture 3-4: Indwelling, Sealing, and the Spirit as Down Payment
  5. Lecture 3-5: Assurance — the Spirit's Witness and Its Pastoral History
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Spirit and Sanctification
  1. Lecture 4-1: Definitive and Progressive Sanctification
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Fruit of the Spirit
  3. Lecture 4-3: Mortification and Vivification
  4. Lecture 4-4: Keeping in Step with the Spirit — the Ordinary Means of Grace
  5. Lecture 4-5: The Spirit and Suffering
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Spiritual Gifts and the Contested Questions
  1. Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Gifts Defined and Surveyed
  2. Lecture 5-2: Baptism and Fullness of the Spirit — the Central Debate
  3. Lecture 5-3: Tongues and Prophecy, Then and Now
  4. Lecture 5-4: Healing and the Already/Not Yet of the Kingdom
  5. Lecture 5-5: Discernment — Testing the Spirits
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Spirit, the Church, and the World Today
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Spirit and the Church's Unity and Mission
  2. Lecture 6-2: Global Renewal Movements, Historically Compared
  3. Lecture 6-3: Pentecostalism and the Charismatic Movement as a Global Phenomenon
  4. Lecture 6-4: Contemporary Controversies — Excess in Both Directions
  5. Lecture 6-5: Ecumenical Convergence and Remaining Difference

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

This is the closing lecture of the whole course, not only of this chapter, and it earns that role by doing something the preceding twenty-nine lectures have mostly avoided: looking back across genuinely divided traditions to ask how far they have actually moved toward each other, rather than introducing a new debate. Two developments make the question worth asking specifically here. First, the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, beginning in 1967 and now a recognized movement within the Catholic Church with explicit magisterial engagement, brought Pentecostal-style spiritual experience — tongues, healing prayer, prophecy — into full communion with Rome, a communion whose sacramental theology this course's Chapter 3 already noted differs sharply from Reformed and Wesleyan accounts of how grace is given. Second, Orthodox pneumatology has, throughout the period this chapter surveys, continued to integrate the Spirit's work with theosis — participation in the divine life — a framework with ancient patristic roots that this course has mentioned but not yet examined directly.

Real convergence exists: Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant traditions across this course's six chapters have converged on a shared conviction that the Spirit is a personal, active reality rather than an impersonal force or a mere symbol for God's general presence — the very claim Lecture 2-1 argued from Scripture at the start of this course. But convergence on that shared conviction has not dissolved the specific disputes this course has documented honestly at each point they arose: the filioque (2-3), the mechanism by which grace is given — effectual calling, prevenient grace, or sacrament (3-2) — the nature of Spirit baptism (5-2), and the frequency and legitimacy of miraculous gifts (5-3). This lecture states plainly what has converged and what has not, and resists the temptation to manufacture agreement where none exists simply because it would make a tidier ending.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • State the origin and basic character of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, and explain, with named sources, how Catholic sacramental theology has understood its relationship to the grace already given in baptism and confirmation.
  • State what *theosis* means in Orthodox theology and explain, with a named patristic source, its connection to pneumatology.
  • Name at least one point of genuine convergence and at least one point of genuine, unresolved difference between the traditions surveyed in this course.
  • Explain why this lecture treats convergence and remaining difference as both real, rather than resolving the tension by overstating either one.

Not for these only do I pray, but for those also who believe in me through their word, that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be one in us; that the world may believe that you sent me. The glory which you have given me, I have given to them; that they may be one, even as we are one; I in them, and you in me, that they may be perfected into one; that the world may know that you sent me, and loved them, even as you loved me." — John 17:20-23

World English Bible

1. The Catholic Charismatic Renewal: experience within, not against, sacramental theology

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal began in February 1967 among faculty and students at Duquesne University, a Catholic institution, when a small prayer group reported an experience of strikingly similar in character to Pentecostal testimony — a fact remarkable enough at the time that it required careful theological explanation for how such an experience could be received as an authentic development within, rather than a rupture of, Catholic sacramental theology. That explanation is the specific contribution of theologians Kilian McDonnell and George T. Montague, whose Christian Initiation and Baptism in the Holy Spirit: Evidence from the First Eight Centuries (1991), already named in this chapter's overview, argues from patristic sources that the early church understood the Spirit's fullness as already objectively given in the sacraments of Christian initiation — baptism and confirmation — such that a later experience of "Spirit baptism" is best understood not as receiving something withheld at baptism but as a conscious, experiential actualization of a grace already sacramentally present, often dormant until it is personally appropriated.

This account matters for how the Catholic Charismatic Renewal was, and largely still is, received within Catholicism rather than treated as sectarian. Cardinal Léon-Joseph Suenens, a senior figure at the Second Vatican Council, became an early and influential episcopal supporter of the movement, and his 1974 "Malines Document" (Theological and Pastoral Orientations on the Catholic Charismatic Renewal) offered the movement cautious magisterial legitimacy — encouraging charismatic prayer and gifts as a genuine renewal of baptismal grace while also insisting the movement remain accountable to, rather than separate from, ordinary parish and diocesan structures and sacramental life. The result is a form of charismatic Christianity structurally different from classical Pentecostalism: not a separate denomination born from a distinct experience claimed to be necessary for full Christian life (compare Lecture 5-2's classical Pentecostal position), but a renewal movement within an existing sacramental communion, understanding itself as making experientially vivid a grace the Catholic Church already teaches every baptized and confirmed member possesses.

2. Orthodox pneumatology and theosis

Orthodox theology's central category for describing the goal of the Christian life is — often translated "deification" or "divinization," though both English words risk misunderstanding unless qualified immediately: the claim is not that a human being becomes God in essence, which Orthodox theology explicitly denies, but that a human being is drawn into real, personal participation in the divine life and energies by grace, becoming, in 2 Peter 1:4's own phrase, "partakers of the divine nature" without ceasing to be creaturely. The classic patristic formulation, attributed in its most quoted form to Athanasius of Alexandria in On the , states that "God became man so that man might become god" — a sentence that requires exactly the qualification just given, and Orthodox theologians uniformly supply it: participation in divine life by grace, not identity of essence with God.

The pneumatological point, easy to miss if theosis is studied only as a doctrine of salvation in general, is that theosis is specifically and irreducibly the Holy Spirit's work: it is the Spirit who unites the believer to Christ and, through that union, to the Father, and Orthodox liturgical and sacramental life (especially the Eucharist, understood as genuine participation in divine life, and chrismation, the Orthodox equivalent of confirmation, understood as the personal "seal of the gift of the Holy Spirit") is structured around making that Spirit-wrought union an ongoing, embodied reality rather than a one-time forensic event. This is a substantially different structuring of the doctrine of salvation than either the Reformed surveyed across this course's earlier chapters or the Catholic sacramental-initiation framework just described, though it shares with both the conviction that the Spirit's work is not merely psychological but really, objectively transformative.

3. What has actually converged

Set against the divisions already documented across this course, three points of real convergence are worth naming plainly rather than assumed. First, Catholic, Orthodox, and the Protestant traditions surveyed in Chapter 2 now uniformly reject any picture of the Spirit as an impersonal force or a mere symbolic way of speaking about God's general presence — the very claim Lecture 2-1 argued was the New Testament's own teaching, and no significant tradition covered in this course now disputes it, whatever else divides them. Second, the shared confession of the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed's article on the Spirit — "the Lord, the Giver of Life... who together with the Father and the Son is worshiped and glorified," the very formula Lecture 2-2 traced to Basil of Caesarea's fourth-century argument against the Pneumatomachians — remains common ground across every tradition this course has engaged, even where the clause added to that same creedal article is disputed. Third, the demographic and historical material of Lectures 6-2 and 6-3 shows that charismatic-style spiritual experience is no longer confined to Pentecostal denominations alone; it has, in the Catholic and to a lesser extent Orthodox cases, become integrated into traditions whose sacramental theology once seemed structurally distant from it.

4. What has not converged, and why that is stated honestly rather than smoothed over

Three open questions

Three disputes this course has documented at the point each arose remain genuinely unresolved, and this lecture does not pretend otherwise for the sake of a tidier ending. The filioque (2-3) remains a live dispute between Western and Eastern churches over both the content of the Spirit's eternal procession and the legitimacy of how the clause was added to the Creed — the 1054 schism's proximate cause has not been theologically resolved merely because ecumenical dialogue on the question has continued for decades. The mechanism of grace surveyed in 3-2 — Reformed , Wesleyan-Arminian , and Catholic/Orthodox sacramental mediation — remains three substantively different accounts of how a person actually comes to saving faith, not three descriptions of the same underlying process in different words; McDonnell and Montague's sacramental-actualization account of Spirit baptism, however carefully argued, does not by itself resolve whether sacramental grace is the ordinary instrument of (the broadly Catholic and Orthodox position) or whether regeneration precedes and is logically independent of any sacramental act (the position most Reformed theologians in this course's earlier chapters have argued). And the frequency, legitimacy, and evidential significance of miraculous gifts — the cessationist/continuationist debate of 5-3, sharpened by the documented excesses and the opposite danger of quenching examined in 6-4 — remains argued by serious, named scholars on every side, with no consensus in view.

Naming these three as unresolved is not a failure of this course's ecumenical ambition; it is what intellectual honesty about six chapters of genuinely contested material requires. A course that claimed, in its final lecture, that careful study had resolved what centuries of careful theologians on every side have not resolved would be making exactly the kind of overreaching claim this course is careful to avoid.

5. Looking back, not introducing something new

This lecture closes the course by tracing threads already laid down rather than opening a new one: the personhood and deity of the Spirit argued in Chapter 2 is the shared ground beneath both the Catholic Charismatic Renewal's experience and Orthodox theosis; the application-of-salvation debates of Chapter 3 are the very debates the Catholic and Orthodox sacramental frameworks in this lecture answer differently than the Reformed and Wesleyan-Arminian accounts already surveyed; and the contested-gifts material of Chapters 5 and 6 remains exactly as contested as it was when first stated. Jesus's own prayer "that they may all be one" (John 17:21) is not, on the account this course has tried to give honestly throughout, a promise that doctrinal difference will dissolve before Christ returns; it is a prayer whose answer this course's readers, across every tradition represented among them, are still living into, one congregation and one honest conversation at a time.

A note on scope, and thanks for the reader's attention across six chapters. This course opened in Chapter 1 with the Spirit's Old Testament work and closes here with a demographic and ecumenical survey of the Spirit's work today; every chapter in between has tried to state genuinely contested questions in their strongest form on every side, not to settle disputes this course did not have the authority to settle. Where this lecture, or any earlier one, may have leaned too far toward one side despite that stated aim, a careful reader — precisely the kind of reader this course has tried to form — is now better equipped to notice it than at the course's start.


Converged and Unresolved, Stated Plainly Converged The Spirit is personal and active, not impersonal or symbolic (2-1) Shared Nicene-Constantinopolitan confession of the Spirit's deity (2-2) Charismatic experience now found within Catholic and Orthodox sacramental traditions, not only Pentecostal denominations Still unresolved Filioque: procession and how the Creed was amended (2-3) Mechanism of grace: effectual call, prevenient grace, or sacrament (3-2) Spirit baptism as distinct experience or conversion-identical (5-2) Cessation or continuation of gifts, and their proper limits (5-3, 6-4) "That they may all be one" — John 17:21, prayed, not yet fully answered

5. Going to the Sources

Read Athanasius of Alexandria, On the Incarnation, section 54, the passage containing the formula usually rendered "God became man so that man might become god." The passage matters here because it is the patristic root of the Orthodox doctrine of theosis discussed above, written centuries before the Catholic-Orthodox-Protestant divisions this lecture has surveyed, which is itself worth noting: theosis is not a late Orthodox innovation but an ancient claim that predates every division this course has had to document.


In short

  • The Catholic Charismatic Renewal began in 1967 at Duquesne University. McDonnell and Montague argue it actualizes a grace already given in baptism and confirmation, rather than adding something withheld.
  • Cardinal Suenens and the 1974 Malines Document gave the movement cautious approval. They asked it to stay accountable to parish, diocese and sacraments, unlike classical Pentecostalism.
  • Orthodox theology describes salvation's goal as theosis: sharing in the divine life by grace. It is not becoming God in essence. The lecture presents this as the Holy Spirit's work.
  • Three points have converged: the Spirit is personal, the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed's words about the Spirit are shared, and charismatic experience now appears in Catholic and some Orthodox life.
  • Four disputes remain open: the filioque, how grace is given, the nature of Spirit baptism, and whether miraculous gifts continue. The lecture does not declare a winner.
  • Jesus's prayer in John 17:21 "that they may all be one" is read as a prayer still being answered, not a promise that disagreement will end soon.

Topic: This closing lecture asks how far Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions have come together on the Holy Spirit, and where real differences remain.

Remember: Real convergence and real disagreement both exist. The traditions agree the Spirit is personal and active, but they still differ on the filioque, how grace is given, Spirit baptism and miraculous gifts.

Caution: Do not read agreement on the Spirit's personhood as agreement on everything. The lecture says dialogue has not resolved the main disputes, and it refuses to invent a tidy ending.

One line to carry into ministry: Name honestly what Christians share and what still divides them, and keep talking with other traditions, one congregation and one conversation at a time.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • McDonnell and Montague argue that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal's experience actualizes a grace already given at baptism, rather than supplying something new. How does this differ from the classical Pentecostal account of Spirit baptism surveyed in Lecture 5-2, and does the difference matter practically, or only theologically?
  • Theosis describes salvation's goal as participation in divine life through the Spirit, in a structure different from a Reformed ordo salutis or a Catholic sacramental-initiation framework. What does this way of describing salvation emphasize that the frameworks used more often in this course's earlier chapters might underemphasize?
  • This lecture insists that real convergence and real remaining difference both be stated honestly, without resolving the tension for a tidier ending. Looking back across the whole course, which unresolved debate (filioque, the mechanism of grace, Spirit baptism, or cessationism/continuationism) has this course's treatment left you thinking about most, and why?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.