Lecture 3-2: Evidential Apologetics
Evidential apologetics builds one cumulative historical case in which the resurrection is evidence for both God and Christianity.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Evidential apologetics builds one cumulative historical case in which the resurrection is evidence for both God and Christianity.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Evidential apologetics asks why an apologist should wait to win a separate argument that some god exists. If the historical evidence for the resurrection is strong enough to stand on its own, it is evidence both that God exists and that Christianity is true. If a dead man was credibly raised, that implies a being with power over death, which does the work of classical step one while also supplying the Christian content of step two.
Evidentialists do not reject the theistic arguments of chapter 4 as false or worthless. Many use them as supporting evidence within a larger cumulative case. The difference is architectural: those arguments contribute weight to one integrated case, rather than being a separate, logically prior stage that must be secured first.
No single piece of evidence, such as the empty tomb, the disciples' willingness to suffer or the early creed in 1 Corinthians 15, is treated as a knockdown proof alone. Each might in isolation admit some alternative explanation. The claim is that several independent strands converging on the same conclusion are stronger than any one, like a rope of many fibers rather than a chain that snaps at one weak link.
The Greek word rendered "assurance" in Hebrews 11:1, hypostasis, points toward something with real substance under it, so the verse describes well-founded confidence rather than opposing faith to evidence. In Acts 1:3 Luke speaks of "many proofs," a term used in ancient rhetoric and law for the strongest class of evidence. He describes repeated appearances over forty days, not a single ambiguous one.
Trained as a historian and a lawyer, he argued that the resurrection should be tried by ordinary historical and legal standards: witness reliability, proximity of sources, absence of motive to fabricate and coherence under scrutiny.
He has gathered and weighed the historical data across a wide range of scholarly starting points to identify facts granted by the great majority of scholars. This "minimal facts" method, developed with Mike Licona, is covered in chapter 7.
A deductive argument with true premises and valid logic guarantees its conclusion. An inductive argument moves from evidence to a conclusion that is probable, sometimes highly so, but not guaranteed. Evidentialists are explicit that they argue inductively: the resurrection is the best explanation of the available data, not logically inescapable. That is why chapter 7 treats rival explanations such as the swoon and hallucination theories at length.
Some apologists, both classical and presuppositional, regard resting an entire case on historical probability as the central weakness, since a skeptic can always hold out for more evidence. Evidentialists reply that no event in ancient history is known with strict deductive certainty. Holding the resurrection to a stricter standard than ordinary historical inquiry uses elsewhere would be a moving goalpost. The course leaves the exchange open.
The lecture compares a cumulative case to a rope of many fibers rather than a chain.
What is the difference, and why does it matter for how a single weak piece of evidence should be handled?
Evidentialists argue that the resurrection is the best explanation of the historical data, and that one combined case does the work of both classical steps. The case is probable, not logically certain, and the lecture leaves open whether that is a weakness. Be honest that historical arguments give strong reasons, not mathematical proof, and let the evidence work as a whole.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.