FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-3: The Moral Argument

The moral argument says objective moral values and duties point to a moral lawgiver, and the classical answer grounds the good in God's nature.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the moral argument in standard form: objective moral values and duties exist; objective moral values and duties are best explained by a transcendent moral lawgiver; therefore a transcendent moral lawgiver exists.
  • Summarize C.S. Lewis's argument in Mere Christianity for a "Law of Human Nature" that people know and regularly fail to keep, and explain what Lewis takes this to show.
  • State the Euthyphro dilemma fairly, in both its ancient and its modern forms, and explain the classical theist response that God's own unchanging nature, rather than his arbitrary will, is what grounds the good.
  • Connect Romans 2:14-15's language of a law "written in their hearts" to the argument's first premise, and explain what that passage does and does not claim.
Lewis

The Law of Human Nature

C.S. Lewis opens Mere Christianity with ordinary quarrels. People say "That's my seat, I was there first," and the other person almost never denies the standard. Both appeal to a shared standard of fair behavior and argue about whether it was violated, not about whether there is one.

Key idea Real disagreement about how a standard applies presupposes the standard.
Lewis's observation

Known, and not kept

Lewis notes that people everywhere seem to know this law in broad outline, even when customs differ. He also notes that everyone regularly fails to live up to the standard they recognize. He takes this as evidence that morality is something people discover and are answerable to, not something they invent and adjust to excuse themselves.

Key idea This lecture focuses on the moral-argument portion of his reasoning.
Standard form

Three lines again

Contemporary philosophers, including William Lane Craig, present the argument like this: if God does not exist, objective moral values and duties do not exist; they do exist; therefore God exists. "Objective" means true independent of what any person or culture believes. A "duty" adds that people are actually obligated to pursue the good.

Key idea The claim is about a fact's status, not how many people agree.
At a glance

The two premises

Premise two

It is defended by shared intuitions that are hard to abandon. Most people are more confident that cruelty to an innocent child is really wrong than in any argument for moral relativism.

Premise one

It is the more contested. A purely naturalistic account seems to lack a source for binding obligation, while a personal moral lawgiver is argued to supply exactly that.

The oldest objection

The Euthyphro dilemma

Plato's dialogue asks whether something is pious because the gods love it, or the gods love it because it is pious. Applied here: is an act good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good? The first horn makes morality seem arbitrary. The second makes goodness independent of God.

Key idea Both horns cause a problem for theism if left unanswered.
The classical answer

God's nature grounds the good

Robert Adams and William Alston, with roots in Aquinas, offer a third option. The good is grounded neither in arbitrary commands nor in a standard above God, but in God's unchanging nature, which is essentially loving, just and faithful. God cannot command cruelty, since that would conflict with who he is.

Key idea A student who only knows "God commands it, so it's good" will be caught by the first horn.
Still debated

Is God's nature enough?

Some philosophers, including some theists, worry that grounding goodness in God's nature only relocates the difficulty. The classical reply is that this is an identity claim: God's nature is what "goodness" refers to, as "water" refers to H2O.

Key idea The lecture names the dispute and does not settle it.
Think about it

In your own words

The lecture asks you to restate the dilemma.

Can you state the Euthyphro dilemma and the classical answer in your own words? Does the answer satisfy you?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The moral argument claims that objective moral values and duties are best explained by a transcendent moral lawgiver. The classical answer to the Euthyphro dilemma grounds goodness in God's own unchanging nature. In conversation, explain that goodness reflects God's loving, just and faithful character.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12