FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-4: Objections and Responses

The multiverse and evolutionary ethics are the main objections to chapter 4's arguments, and the chapter closes by asking for a modest, honest cumulative case.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the multiverse hypothesis as an alternative explanation for fine-tuning, and explain at least two of its own unresolved questions - what would generate a multiverse, and whether it can be tested even in principle.
  • Summarize at least one naturalistic account of the origin of morality (evolutionary ethics) and state the theist response to it fairly.
  • Describe, with a specific example, how a serious atheist philosopher such as Graham Oppy contests one of these arguments' premises rather than dismissing the arguments outright.
  • Explain, using this chapter's own principle, why a cumulative case built from several modest arguments is a different - and in some ways stronger - kind of case than claiming any single argument as a complete proof.
Objection one

The multiverse

The multiverse hypothesis proposes that our universe is one among an enormous number, each with randomly set constants. If enough universes exist, it is unsurprising that at least one has life-permitting values, as with lottery tickets. On this view fine-tuning is a selection effect: we could only find ourselves in a universe that supports observers.

Key idea The lecture says it should be presented in its strongest form, not dismissed.
Open questions

What generates the multiverse?

First, the mechanism that generates the multiverse may itself need an explanation. John Leslie and Robin Collins argue that many such mechanisms need a certain amount of tuning, which could push the question back a level. Second, most proposals are not testable even in principle, since other universes are causally disconnected from ours.

Key idea Untestable is not automatically false, but it cannot simply be assumed more scientific.
Objection two

Evolutionary ethics

Evolutionary ethics proposes that the moral sense is explained by natural selection, which favored cooperation, reciprocity and care for offspring. Michael Ruse describes morality as an illusion put in place by our genes to make us good cooperators. Sharon Street argues that selection for survival would give no reason to expect our intuitions to track objective moral truth.

Key idea Students should state these positions in a form their holders would call fair.
At a glance

Two theist replies

How a belief arose

Explaining how a belief-forming mechanism arose does not show the belief is false, any more than explaining how the eye evolved shows that trees do not exist.

Feeling versus obligation

Craig and others argue that evolution explains why we have moral feelings, not why anyone is actually, objectively bound to act a certain way.

Honest acknowledgment

Reasonable disagreement

Graham Oppy, an atheist philosopher, argues that the case against an actual infinite does not rule out a beginningless universe. He makes similar moves against versions of the fine-tuning and moral arguments. His claim is not that theists make an obvious logical error but that, at specific premises, equally rational people can reasonably disagree.

Key idea Naming this is not a concession that the arguments fail.
The chapter's principle

Each argument is narrow

Each argument supports a narrower conclusion than "the Christian God exists": a beginningless, powerful first cause; an intelligent designer of the constants; a transcendent ground of objective morality. None alone establishes the Trinity, the incarnation or the resurrection.

Key idea A student who has only heard these as decisive has not met them in their real setting.
Cumulative case

Harder to dismiss together

A cumulative case is built from several independent lines that each point in a broadly theistic direction. A critic has to answer each line separately rather than finding one weak link that brings down the whole. The course presents the arguments with strengths and live objections, and lets the student weigh the result.

Key idea Nothing here is oversold as a knockdown proof.
Think about it

Presenting arguments

The lecture ends by asking for honesty about objections.

How would you present one of these arguments to a friend while naming its live objections?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A cumulative case built from several modest arguments is harder to dismiss with one objection than any single argument oversold as a complete proof. Naming serious objections is not conceding that the arguments fail. Present them honestly, and respect that thoughtful people weigh the same evidence differently.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12