Lecture 10-3: The New Atheism and Secular Objections
Three objections from the new atheist writers are met at their strongest, and scientism fails its own test.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Three objections from the new atheist writers are met at their strongest, and scientism fails its own test.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Dawkins argues that any being complex enough to design a universe would itself be at least as complex, so positing God only pushes the problem back one step. The classical theist reply is that the kalam argument says everything that begins to exist has a cause, and classical theism never held that God began to exist. God is a necessary, eternal, uncaused being, the point where a causal chain ends.
Hitchens charges that religion has been a uniquely destructive force, citing the Crusades, the Inquisition, European wars of religion and contemporary terrorism. The lecture says these episodes are real, well documented and indefensible by any Christian standard. A response that denies or downplays them fails before it starts.
The first part is comparative. The most lethal ideological violence of the twentieth century, under Stalin's Soviet Union, Mao's China and the Khmer Rouge, was carried out by explicitly atheist regimes. This does not excuse religious violence, but it shows that removing religion does not remove the capacity for mass violence. The second part is self-critical. Much violence in Christianity's name fused religious authority with state power in ways the New Testament does not endorse, as in Jesus's rebuke to Peter in Matthew 26:52.
The working assumption within science that natural causes are what science investigates. It is a sound operating principle used by believing and unbelieving scientists alike, and the course does not dispute it.
The further claim that nothing beyond the natural, physical world exists. It does not follow automatically from the success of the first. It is a philosophical argument, not a scientific finding.
Much new atheist writing claims that scientific explanation can in principle account for everything real, leaving God no role. The lecture says this is a confident extrapolation from science's track record, not a conclusion science itself has reached. Stated carefully, it claims that methodological naturalism's success has established metaphysical naturalism. That larger step is a philosophical argument open to philosophical evaluation.
Scientism says only scientifically verifiable statements are meaningful or true. Its ancestor, the verification principle of A. J. Ayer, said a statement is meaningful only if true by definition or empirically verifiable. Critics noticed that the principle is neither, so it fails its own test. The same problem applies to scientism, because its central sentence is a philosophical claim, not something an experiment could verify.
The self-referential problem is a logical point, not a rhetorical one. It does not show that science is untrustworthy, that most scientific claims are false, or that religious claims are therefore true. It shows only that the claim "only scientific statements are meaningful or true" cannot be true. Any honest account of knowledge must make room for logical, mathematical, ethical and metaphysical claims.
The lecture warns that Psalm 14:1 and Psalm 53:1 are easy to hear as a blanket insult toward atheists.
How does the lecture try to use these verses more carefully, and do you think it succeeds?
God is answered as a necessary, uncaused being, real religious wrongs are admitted, and methodological naturalism is separated from metaphysical naturalism. Scientism cannot be verified scientifically, so it undermines itself. Do not use Psalm 14:1 as an insult, and meet atheist arguments at their strongest.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.