Lecture 5-1: The Hypostatic Union and the Extra Calvinisticum
Contents 34
- Lecture 1-1: Revelation and Theological Epistemology
- Lecture 1-2: Inspiration and Inerrancy
- Lecture 1-3: Speech-Act Theory and Biblical Authority
- Lecture 1-4: The Sufficiency of Scripture and the Scripture-Tradition Question
- Lecture 2-1: The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Settlement
- Lecture 2-2: The Filioque Controversy
- Lecture 2-3: Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission
- Lecture 2-4: Rahner's Rule, Social Trinitarianism, and the Church's Life
- Lecture 3-1: Divine Decree and Human Freedom — Compatibilism and Libertarian Freedom
- Lecture 3-2: Open Theism and Process Theology — Challenges to Classical Providence
- Lecture 3-3: Divine Impassibility — Classical and Revisionist Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Theodicy at the Doctrinal Level — Privation and Soul-Making
- Lecture 4-1: The Image of God — Structural, Relational, and Functional Readings
- Lecture 4-2: Original Sin and Federal Headship
- Lecture 4-3: The Bondage or Freedom of the Will After the Fall
- Lecture 4-4: The Soul-Body Question, and Transhumanism's Challenge
- Lecture 5-1: The Hypostatic Union and the Extra Calvinisticum
- Lecture 5-2: Kenotic Christology
- Lecture 5-3: Christ's Sinlessness and Obedience
- Lecture 5-4: The Extent of the Atonement
- Lecture 6-1: Union with Christ as an Integrating Motif for Soteriology
- Lecture 6-2: Election
- Lecture 6-3: Justification and Its Contemporary Challenges
- Lecture 6-4: Sanctification and Perseverance
- Lecture 7-1: Christological Pneumatology and the Spirit's Cosmic Work
- Lecture 7-2: The Church's Identity and Marks
- Lecture 7-3: The Sacraments/Ordinances Across Traditions
- Lecture 7-4: The Church and Culture/Society
Every tradition in this course confesses the same formula for who Jesus Christ is. The Council of Chalcedon (451) declared him "one and the same Son... acknowledged in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation" - fully God and fully man, one person, not a blend of the two and not two persons sharing a body. Reformed, Lutheran, Catholic, and Orthodox Christology all start here. This lecture assumes that starting point rather than re-deriving it, and goes to the place Chalcedon's four negative adverbs leave open: given that the natures are neither confused nor divided, what exactly can be said to belong to the one person as a result of each nature, and does the eternal Son's incarnation change anything about what he continues to do outside of, or alongside, his human body?
That second question produced a genuine and unresolved disagreement between the two great Reformation traditions that otherwise agree on almost everything else in Christology. The Reformed answer is called, by its later Lutheran critics, the extra Calvinisticum - "the Calvinist outside-ness." The name was not chosen by the Reformed, and it is worth knowing that going in: it names a dispute that only one side thought was a problem.
What these 19 minutes give you
- State Chalcedon's four negative adverbs precisely and explain what each one rules out.
- Define the *communicatio idiomatum* and give an example of a property predicated of the person on the basis of each nature.
- State the Reformed *extra Calvinisticum* and the Lutheran objection to it, each in a form its own theologians would recognize as accurate.
- Explain why this dispute is not merely academic - what it is actually preparing the ground for in chapter 7.
Colossians 1:17 - "He is before all things, and in him all things are held together." (World English Bible)
1 Corinthians 2:8 - "which none of the rulers of this world has known. For had they known it, they wouldn't have crucified the Lord of glory." (WEB)
John 1:14 - "The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." (WEB)
1. Chalcedon's grammar
The Definition of Chalcedon is usually remembered for what it affirms - one person, two natures - but its actual theological work is done by four adverbs, each ruling out a specific way of getting Christology wrong that some faction in the fifth century had already tried:
- Without confusion (asynchytos) - against Eutyches, who taught that the divine and human natures blended into a third, hybrid nature. Chalcedon insists the two natures remain what they are; humanity is not partly absorbed into deity.
- Without change (atreptos) - the divine nature is not altered, diminished, or converted into something else by the union. Whatever the means, it does not mean God stopped being fully God.
- Without division (adiairetos) - against a reading of Nestorius (fairly or not - historians still argue how close Nestorius himself came to the position that bears his name) that would split Christ into two separate subjects, a divine one and a human one, loosely associated. There is one person, one "who."
- Without separation (achoristos) - the two natures are never, even for a moment, disjoined. Whatever is true of the incarnate Son is true of him as a single, continuous subject.
Chalcedon is a fence, not a mechanism. It tells you where the boundary is - do not confuse the natures, do not divide the person - without explaining exactly how a single person sustains two complete natures at once. That silence is deliberate; the bishops at Chalcedon were stopping a set of specific errors, not offering a metaphysical theory of the incarnation to replace them. Everything downstream in Christian Christology, including the two disagreements this lecture covers, is an attempt to work out implications Chalcedon left as an open field bounded by four fences.
2. The communicatio idiomatum
Because the one person genuinely possesses two complete natures, properties that strictly belong to only one nature can be predicated of the person as a whole. This transfer of properties across natures onto the single person is the - "the communication of properties" (or "idioms"). It is not a claim that divine properties leak into the human nature or human properties into the divine nature; Chalcedon's "without confusion" rules that out. It is a claim about what can rightly be said of the person, who is one, even though the properties in question each originate in only one of his two natures.
Paul supplies the classic instance without using the technical vocabulary. "They wouldn't have crucified the Lord of glory" (1 Cor 2:8, WEB) predicates crucifixion - something that can only happen to a body, a strictly human-nature property - of "the Lord of glory," a divine title. Strictly speaking, God the Son's divine nature cannot suffer or die; deity is not the kind of thing that bleeds. But the person who died on the cross is the same person who is, without qualification, the Lord of glory - so it is entirely proper to say that the Lord of glory was crucified, meaning: the person who is Lord of glory suffered death in his human nature. Take away the communicatio, and you either have to deny that God the Son really died (undercutting the reality of the incarnation and the cross alike) or claim that deity itself somehow suffered (undercutting divine , a question chapter 3 covers in its own right). The communicatio is what lets orthodox Christology affirm both without contradiction: the person suffered; the divine nature, considered in itself, did not.
The same logic runs the other direction. "He is before all things, and in him all things are held together" (Col 1:17, WEB) predicates eternal pre-existence and the sustaining of the entire created order - strictly divine-nature properties - of the same "he" who, two verses earlier, is called "the firstborn of all creation," described in thoroughly human, historically located terms elsewhere in the same letter. One person; properties from both natures; the communicatio is the grammatical hinge that makes coherent sense of predicating both kinds of properties of a single "he."
3. The extra Calvinisticum
Colossians 1:17 is also where the specifically Reformed-Lutheran dispute of this lecture starts, because it raises a pointed question: if the eternal Son "holds all things together" as an ongoing, continuous divine activity, did that activity stop, or pause, or shrink down to the size of a human body, during the thirty-some years the Son was incarnate on earth?
The Reformed answer, worked out most influentially by John Calvin (hence the name later Lutheran critics gave it, not entirely as a compliment) but drawing on patristic and medieval precedent well before Calvin, is no. The eternal Son's divine nature is not, and by its very nature as infinite divine nature cannot be, contained within, confined to, or limited by the finite human nature it assumed. The Son who became incarnate continued, even in the manger and even on the cross, to fill and sustain the entire universe as God the Son always has - "even outside the flesh" (etiam extra carnem), which is where the Latin name comes from. The human nature is genuinely, fully assumed and nothing about it is diminished; the point is only that the divine nature's infinity is not something incarnation could shrink. A God who could be spatially contained by a human body would not have been infinite to begin with, and Reformed theologians argue that denying the extra effectively asks the divine nature to stop being divine for the duration of the incarnation - which collides directly with Chalcedon's "without change."
Lutheran theologians, beginning with the generation after Luther working out the implications of his eucharistic theology, raised a serious and specific objection: does the extra not, in practice, divide the person Chalcedon's fourth adverb forbids dividing? If the Son-outside-the-flesh is doing something (sustaining the universe) that the Son-in-the-flesh is not doing at the same moment, have you not quietly reintroduced two centers of activity - one bounded by the body, one not - inside a single person who was supposed to act as one "who" in everything? The Lutheran alternative leans on the communicatio idiomatum far more heavily than the Reformed account does: because the properties of each nature are communicated to the one person, and the person is genuinely one, Lutheran Christology has historically argued that the human nature itself comes to share, through its personal union with the divine nature, in properties like - not by the human nature becoming divine (Chalcedon's "without confusion" still holds), but by the human nature being pervaded by the divine nature's presence in a way analogous to how iron placed in fire takes on the fire's heat without becoming fire. On this account there is no "outside the flesh" for the personal Son to occupy, because the flesh itself, in personal union with deity, is not confined the way an ordinary human body is.
Two views of the Son
This is a point where readers will not agree. The Reformed case (representative: the Reformed tradition following Calvin, Institutes 2.13) holds that the extra is required by taking divine infinity seriously and does not in fact divide the person, because "sustaining the universe" and "living a human life" are both, without remainder, the acts of the one Son - acting through two natures is not the same as acting as two persons, and no orthodox Christology has ever denied that the one person acts differently according to each nature (he grew in wisdom according to his human nature, Luke 2:52, and knew all things according to his divine nature, without that being read as two persons). The Lutheran case (representative: the Lutheran tradition following the Formula of Concord's Christological article) holds that the Reformed position, whatever its intentions, functions as a Nestorianizing tendency - not accusing Reformed theologians of the ancient heresy directly, but arguing that the structure of the claim, an activity the human nature's person is not personally involved in, pulls in that direction, and that the communicatio's whole point is to prevent exactly that kind of split. Serious, orthodox, Chalcedonian theologians hold both positions today; this is not a case where one side has quietly drifted from Chalcedon and the other has not.
4. Why this is not idle scholasticism
This dispute is not an argument for its own sake. Chapter 7 will show that it is the load-bearing premise underneath one of the four historic positions on the Lord's Supper. The Lutheran doctrine of the Son's human nature sharing (through the communicatio) in a form of omnipresence is precisely what licenses the Lutheran claim that Christ's body and blood are genuinely, bodily present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine at every altar simultaneously - a claim the Reformed tradition rejects in part because it rejects the christological premise that makes it coherent. A sacramental disagreement that can look, from the outside, like a dispute over ritual technicalities turns out to rest on this lecture's Christological question. Get 5-1 wrong, or skip it as a technicality, and 7-3 will not make sense.
6. Further Reading
- Oliver Crisp, Divinity and Humanity: The Incarnation Reconsidered (Cambridge University Press, 2007) - a contemporary analytic defense and critique of Reformed Christology, including a careful treatment of the extra Calvinisticum.
- Richard A. Muller, Christ and the Decree: Christology and in Reformed Theology from Calvin to Perkins (Baker Academic, 2008 reprint) - historical grounding for the Reformed position in its own theological context.
- David P. Scaer, Christology (Confessional Lutheran Dogmatics, vol. VI) (The Luther Academy, 2014) - a contemporary confessional Lutheran statement of the communicatio's implications, including the objection to the Reformed extra.
- Robert W. Jenson, Systematic Theology, Volume 1: The Triune God (Oxford University Press, 1997) - a modern Lutheran-influenced Christology attentive to the same dispute from a different angle.
- Thomas G. Weinandy, Does God Suffer? (University of Notre Dame Press, 2000) - a Catholic contribution to the communicatio idiomatum and its bearing on divine impassibility, connecting this lecture forward to chapter 3.
- John McGuckin, Saint Cyril of Alexandria and the Christological Controversy (St Vladimir's Seminary Press, 2004) - an Orthodox scholar's treatment of the patristic background Chalcedon inherited and the Alexandrian theology (Cyril's) that shaped the communicatio idiomatum before either Reformation tradition existed.
In short
- Reformed, Lutheran, Catholic and Orthodox Christians all accept Chalcedon (451): one person in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. Each of the four phrases rules out a specific error.
- Chalcedon is a fence, not a mechanism. It marks boundaries without explaining how one person holds two natures.
- The communicatio idiomatum means properties of either nature can be said of the one person. 1 Corinthians 2:8 says the Lord of glory was crucified, though the divine nature itself did not suffer.
- The Reformed extra Calvinisticum says the Son kept sustaining the universe "even outside the flesh" (Colossians 1:17), because infinity cannot be confined. Lutherans object that this risks dividing the person.
- The Lutheran alternative says the human nature shares in the divine presence through the union. This matters because chapter 7's Lord's Supper debate rests on it. Orthodox Chalcedonian theologians hold both views.
Topic: This lecture explains Chalcedon's four phrases and the communicatio idiomatum, and presents the Reformed and Lutheran disagreement over the extra Calvinisticum.
Remember: One person holds two complete natures, and what belongs to either nature may be said of the person. The Reformed and Lutheran traditions agree on this but differ on whether the Son acts outside the flesh.
Caution: The lecture does not say either side has left Chalcedon. Lutherans do not directly accuse Reformed theologians of the ancient heresy, only of a tendency toward it.
One line to carry into ministry: Say plainly that the one who died on the cross is truly God and truly human, and treat Christians who explain this differently as fellow believers in Chalcedon.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Chalcedon's four adverbs are negative - they say what the union is *not*. Why might the council have chosen to define the union this way rather than offering a positive explanation of how it works?
- Restate 1 Corinthians 2:8's logic in your own words: what would be lost, theologically, if you denied that it is proper to say "the Lord of glory was crucified"?
- State the Reformed *extra Calvinisticum* in a form a Reformed theologian would recognize as their own view, and then state the Lutheran objection in a form a Lutheran theologian would recognize as their own view. Which concern - dividing the person, or limiting the infinite - do you find more pressing, and why?
- This lecture claims the *extra Calvinisticum* dispute is not merely academic because of what it prepares for in chapter 7. Before reading chapter 7, what do you predict the connection to the Lord's Supper will be?