FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL3E Advanced Systematic Theology

Lecture 3-3: Divine Impassibility — Classical and Revisionist Accounts

Contents 34
STEL3E Advanced Systematic Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Is Advanced Systematic Theology, and Why Study It?
  1. Introduction: What Is Advanced Systematic Theology, and Why Study It?
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Scripture, Revelation, and Authority
  1. Lecture 1-1: Revelation and Theological Epistemology
  2. Lecture 1-2: Inspiration and Inerrancy
  3. Lecture 1-3: Speech-Act Theory and Biblical Authority
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Sufficiency of Scripture and the Scripture-Tradition Question
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Holy Trinity
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Settlement
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Filioque Controversy
  3. Lecture 2-3: Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission
  4. Lecture 2-4: Rahner's Rule, Social Trinitarianism, and the Church's Life
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Providence, Sovereignty, and Theodicy
  1. Lecture 3-1: Divine Decree and Human Freedom — Compatibilism and Libertarian Freedom
  2. Lecture 3-2: Open Theism and Process Theology — Challenges to Classical Providence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Divine Impassibility — Classical and Revisionist Accounts
  4. Lecture 3-4: Theodicy at the Doctrinal Level — Privation and Soul-Making
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Theological Anthropology — Image, Fall, and Nature
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Image of God — Structural, Relational, and Functional Readings
  2. Lecture 4-2: Original Sin and Federal Headship
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Bondage or Freedom of the Will After the Fall
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Soul-Body Question, and Transhumanism's Challenge
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Christology and the Atonement
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Hypostatic Union and the Extra Calvinisticum
  2. Lecture 5-2: Kenotic Christology
  3. Lecture 5-3: Christ's Sinlessness and Obedience
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Extent of the Atonement
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Salvation — Union with Christ and the Order of Salvation
  1. Lecture 6-1: Union with Christ as an Integrating Motif for Soteriology
  2. Lecture 6-2: Election
  3. Lecture 6-3: Justification and Its Contemporary Challenges
  4. Lecture 6-4: Sanctification and Perseverance
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The Spirit and the Church
  1. Lecture 7-1: Christological Pneumatology and the Spirit's Cosmic Work
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Church's Identity and Marks
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Sacraments/Ordinances Across Traditions
  4. Lecture 7-4: The Church and Culture/Society
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Eschatology — Already and Not Yet
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Hermeneutical Structure of Biblical Eschatology
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Intermediate State
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Millennium
  4. Lecture 8-4: The Resurrection of the Body and Final Judgment
  5. Lecture 8-5: Cosmic Renewal — The New Heavens and New Earth

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

Classical Christian theology, East and West, has historically affirmed that God does not suffer or undergo emotional change — a doctrine called impassibility, tied closely to divine simplicity (God is not composed of parts, including a "part" that could be acted upon) and immutability (God does not change). Since the mid-twentieth century, a widely influential revision — most associated with Jürgen Moltmann's The Crucified God, whose fuller argument this track's modern theology course covers — holds that this classical consensus got something important wrong: that God, in Christ, genuinely suffers, and that a God incapable of suffering cannot be the God revealed at the cross. This lecture states both positions in the strongest form their own defenders give them, rather than treating impassibility as an outdated view awaiting correction or treating its revision as an obvious improvement.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • State the classical doctrine of impassibility precisely, including its connection to simplicity and immutability.
  • State the contemporary revisionist objection to impassibility precisely, including its christological and pastoral grounds.
  • Explain the classical concern about a suffering God and the revisionist concern about an impassible one, each in a form its defenders would recognize as fair.
  • Read Hebrews 4:15 and Isaiah 63:9 and explain how each side's reading handles them.

For we don't have a high priest who can't be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, but one who has been in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin.

In all their affliction he was afflicted, and the angel of his presence saved them: in his love and in his pity he redeemed them; and he bore them, and carried them all the days of old.

Hebrews 4:15 (World English Bible)

Isaiah 63:9 (WEB)

1. The classical doctrine and its logic

The classical doctrine of , articulated across patristic, medieval, and Reformation theology in both East and West, holds that God does not suffer, does not undergo emotional change, and is not acted upon or altered by anything outside himself. This is not, in its classical statement, a claim that God is indifferent, unfeeling in the ordinary sense, or emotionally cold toward creation — the who articulated impassibility most carefully (Athanasius, the Cappadocians, Augustine) are also among the most vivid biblical writers on God's love, wrath, and compassion. Rather, impassibility follows from a tightly connected set of prior commitments about what it means for God to be God at all. holds that God is not composed of separable parts, attributes, or potentials that could be actualized or altered by an outside cause; God simply is his own perfection, fully and eternally. Divine holds that God does not change, in any respect, because any change would mean either God became better (impossible, since God is already infinitely perfect) or worse (impossible, for the same reason). Impassibility follows from both: to suffer, in the classical philosophical sense at stake here, is to be acted upon by something outside oneself and thereby changed or diminished by it — and a being who is simple and immutable cannot be acted upon or changed in that way by anything, including the world's evil and suffering.

Classical theologians press a specific, carefully stated concern against any revision of this doctrine: if God can be made to suffer by the world's evil, then evil possesses a kind of causal power over God, and God is, to that extent, not fully sovereign or self-sufficient but dependent on and vulnerable to his own creation — precisely the picture 3-2 showed resisting in 's account of divine power. On this reasoning, a God capable of being harmed by suffering is not sufficiently distinct from a creature; creatures are, definitionally, beings that can be acted upon and changed by things outside themselves, and if God can be too, the line between Creator and creature has been blurred in exactly the place classical theology worked hardest to keep it clear. Impassibility, on this account, is not a denial that God loves, grieves over sin, or is moved with compassion — scripture's language of divine grief, jealousy, and pity is affirmed as true — but a claim that such language describes, in creaturely terms suited to human understanding, God's unchanging disposition of love and justice toward changing creaturely circumstances, not an actual alteration in God's own inner life caused by those circumstances.

2. The contemporary revisionist objection

The most influential contemporary challenge to impassibility, associated with Jürgen Moltmann's The Crucified God (1972) and developed by other theologians since — the movement's fuller history and figures belong to this track's modern theology course — argues that classical impassibility, whatever its philosophical coherence, cannot do justice to the cross. If the Son of God genuinely became human, genuinely died, and if what happened at Golgotha is truly an event in God's own life and not merely in Christ's human nature considered in isolation from his deity, then God himself, revisionists argue, is genuinely affected by human suffering and death in the event of the cross — and a doctrine that rules this out by definition has let a piece of Greek metaphysics (the philosophical assumption that perfection cannot include suffering) override what the cross itself discloses about who God actually is. Moltmann's proposal draws directly on Jesus's cry of dereliction (Mark 15:34, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?") as depicting something genuinely happening within the 's own relations, not only within Christ's human experience — the Father's own grief at the Son's abandonment, and the Son's own genuine God-forsakenness, both taken as real divine experience rather than merely human experience predicated of a divine person.

The revisionist concern, stated in its own strongest form, is pastoral as much as it is exegetical: a God who cannot suffer, the argument runs, cannot be genuinely present to human beings in their own suffering; such a God can only observe suffering from an unaffected distance and respond to it, which is a lesser and less comforting form of solidarity than a God who has actually, in himself, undergone what a sufferer undergoes. Isaiah 63:9's "in all their affliction he was afflicted" is read by revisionists as describing exactly this kind of genuine divine participation in Israel's suffering, not merely an unaffected compassionate response to suffering observed from outside — and Hebrews 4:15's claim that the high priest can be "touched with the feeling of our infirmities" because he was "tempted like we are" is read as extending that participation into the itself, where God does not merely know about human weakness but has actually undergone it.

3. Where the disagreement actually lies, and the shared ground beneath it

It is worth being precise about what is and is not in dispute, because both sides can seem, stated carelessly, to be denying something the other side also affirms. Classical impassibilists fully affirm that Christ's human nature genuinely suffered on the cross — this is not in question for either side, and denying it would be a form of the ancient docetist heresy neither side holds. The dispute is narrower: whether that suffering can also, without qualification, be predicated of God's own divine nature and inner life, or whether it must be predicated of Christ's human nature specifically, with the (the exchange of properties across the two natures in the one person, examined more fully in chapter 5's lecture on the ) allowing the person of the Son to be truly said to suffer without requiring that the divine nature as such underwent change. Classical theologians read Hebrews 4:15 as describing exactly this: the high priest's capacity for sympathy is grounded in the incarnate Son's genuine human experience of temptation and weakness, which the divine nature does not need to have itself undergone in order for the whole person to be genuinely sympathetic. Revisionists find this distinction theologically thin at exactly the point where it matters most, arguing that a suffering confined to a human nature that the divine Son merely "has" rather than a suffering that reaches the divine life itself falls short of what texts like Isaiah 63:9 seem to claim about God himself.

Shared ground, open question

Both sides also share more ground than the sharpness of the disagreement might suggest. Neither classical impassibilists nor contemporary revisionists want to say God is indifferent to suffering, uninvolved in the world, or emotionally inert; the disagreement is over whether God's genuine, active love and compassion require or exclude the further claim that God is changed or acted upon by what he loves and is compassionate toward. A concept sometimes offered as a middle path — that God freely and voluntarily wills to be moved by creation, so that any "suffering" in God is itself an act of sovereign love rather than something imposed on God from outside — draws criticism from strict classical impassibilists (who see it as impassibility in name only) and from strict revisionists (who see it as impassibility's essential problem, God's invulnerability, merely relocated) alike, which is itself a sign of how sharply contested this remains.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Thomas Weinandy and other contemporary defenders of classical impassibility state the traditional position with real philosophical and patristic sophistication; Jürgen Moltmann and a wide swath of contemporary theology, cutting across several traditions, state the revision with equal seriousness. This course states both and adjudicates neither.

Does God suffer? Classical impassibility and its contemporary revision Classical impassibility God does not suffer or change Tied to simplicity and immutability Concern: A God who can be harmed by evil is not sufficiently distinct from a creature Cross: suffering is Christ's human nature Contemporary revisionism (post-Moltmann) God genuinely suffers, esp. at the cross Concern: A God who cannot suffer cannot be truly present in human suffering Cross: the Father's grief, the Son's forsakenness are events in God's own life Shared ground Both affirm God's real love and compassion. Neither denies Christ's human nature truly suffered. The dispute is whether that reaches God's own inner life. Heb 4:15 and Isa 63:9 - both sides cite them, and read them differently Genuine sympathy through a human nature, or genuine affliction in God himself?

6. Further Reading

  • Jürgen Moltmann, The Crucified God: The Cross of Christ as the Foundation and Criticism of Christian Theology, trans. R. A. Wilson and John Bowden (Fortress Press, 1993 [1972]).
  • Thomas G. Weinandy, Does God Suffer? (University of Notre Dame Press, 2000).
  • Richard Bauckham, "'Only the Suffering God Can Help': Divine Passibility in Modern Theology," Themelios 9.3 (1984).
  • Paul L. Gavrilyuk, The Suffering of the Impassible God: The Dialectics of Patristic Thought (Oxford University Press, 2004).
  • Rob Lister, God Is Impassible and Impassioned: Toward a Theology of Divine Emotion (Crossway, 2013).

In short

  • Classical Christian theology, East and West, says God does not suffer or undergo emotional change. This is called impassibility, and it follows from divine simplicity (God has no parts) and immutability (God does not change).
  • Classical theologians worry that a God who can be harmed by evil is not clearly distinct from a creature. They still affirm that Scripture's language of divine grief and pity is true.
  • Jürgen Moltmann and later revisionists argue that impassibility cannot do justice to the cross. They read Mark 15:34 as something real within the Trinity's own relations.
  • The revisionist concern is also pastoral: a God who cannot suffer seems unable to be truly present with sufferers. Revisionists read Isaiah 63:9 and Hebrews 4:15 this way.
  • Both sides agree that Christ's human nature truly suffered and that God is not indifferent. They differ on whether this suffering reaches God's own inner life. The lecture adjudicates neither.

Topic: This lecture states the classical doctrine that God does not suffer and its modern revision, each in the strongest form its defenders give it.

Remember: Both sides affirm God's real love and Christ's real suffering. The dispute is whether that suffering can be said of God's own divine nature, or only of Christ's human nature.

Caution: Impassibility does not mean God is cold or indifferent, and the revision does not deny the classical concern for God's sovereignty. The lecture presents both fairly and declares no winner.

One line to carry into ministry: Be ready to comfort sufferers with the cross and with God's real compassion, while honestly saying that Christians disagree about how God is affected.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • State divine simplicity and immutability in your own words, and explain how impassibility follows from them in the classical account.
  • State Moltmann's christological argument against impassibility in your own words. Why does he think the cross specifically, rather than suffering in general, is the decisive case?
  • Read Isaiah 63:9 again. Does "in all their affliction he was afflicted" read more naturally as describing God's own inner state, or God's compassionate response from an unaffected position? Can you state the case for the reading you find less natural?
  • The lecture notes that a "voluntary suffering" middle position draws criticism from both classical impassibilists and strict revisionists. Why might a genuine middle position between two well-worked-out views satisfy neither side fully?
  • What pastoral difference, if any, does it make to a suffering believer whether God is impassible or capable of suffering? Can you state a pastoral case for each side, not only the one you find more persuasive?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.