Lecture 10-2: The Exemplary-Only Trap
Not every character is an example to copy
Introduction to Biblical Hermeneutics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Not every character is an example to copy
Introduction to Biblical Hermeneutics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The exemplary-only trap reduces every character to an example to imitate or a warning to avoid. David is faith, Goliath is fear, Ruth is loyalty, Orpah is compromise. It is attractive because it gives a tidy takeaway. But it is usually a flattening of what the text does. Applied consistently, it teaches that every Old Testament character exists to model a virtue.
Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart, in How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth, note that most Old Testament narratives have no explicit, stated moral. A reader who insists on one imposes the fable, with its moral tag, on a genre that does not work that way. Most narratives are about what God is doing across Israel's history. Human characters, with their mixture of faith and failure, take part in that story and are not moral mannequins.
The lecture uses this verse to show that Scripture's usefulness is broader than teaching us whom to imitate. It lists teaching, reproof, correction and instruction in righteousness. The lecture says this authorizes narrative's usefulness but does not require every passage to give a character to copy.
Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness," — 2 Timothy 3:16 World English Bible
Sometimes a narrative does offer a character as an example. In Ruth 1:16-17 the narrative sets Ruth's declaration at a real fork in the road, with another woman's different choice beside it, and the book vindicates her loyalty. Reading it as showing covenant loyalty fits the narrative's own shape. The trap is treating this as the default for every character in every story.
Famine drives Abram to Egypt, and fearing for his life he tells Sarai to say she is his sister. That puts her at serious risk to protect himself. An exemplary-only reader must either excuse him as a man of faith or call him a pure negative example. The narrator reports the fear and the scheme without editorial comment. The narrative's interest is God's promise proceeding despite a patriarch's genuine failure.
Here the narrative is unmistakably critical. The next chapter brings a prophet, a parable and an explicit charge of wrongdoing. A reader trained to see David as the model may soften this chapter and rush to his repentance. The text does not allow David to be a consistent positive example. Its claim is that even the man after God's own heart sinned seriously, was confronted, and needed grace he could not manufacture.
Joshua 2:1 introduces Rahab, who hides Israel's spies. The New Testament speaks well of her faith. Still, the exemplary-only instinct can slide into treating every detail, including a later lie to Jericho's authorities, as commended because the outcome was good. A narrative reporting that a character did something is not the same as commending it. Some actions are praised, some condemned, and many are simply reported.
What does the story as a whole show about God's character and purposes?
Use a narrator's comment, a prophet's rebuke or a stated consequence where the text gives one.
Do not force a tidy verdict that the narrative withholds.
The exemplary-only trap treats every character as a model or a warning, which treats narrative as a fable. Ruth's loyalty is signaled by the story's shape, but Abram, David and Rahab resist a tidy grid. A narrative reporting an action is not commending it. Narrative forms a reader by showing what it looks like for God to remain faithful to flawed people.