Lecture 2-2: Source Criticism and the Documentary Hypothesis
Real textual features, and one famous theory built to explain them
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Real textual features, and one famous theory built to explain them
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
A careful reader of the Pentateuch notices that some stories are told twice, such as the creation of humanity in Genesis 1 and Genesis 2. Some passages call God "Elohim" and others "Yahweh," and the pattern clusters. Leviticus and Numbers read like priestly manuals, while Deuteronomy is sermonic. The lecture stresses these observations are older than Wellhausen by more than a century. They are separate from the theory built to explain them.
A seventeenth-century French scholar, Jean Astruc, is usually credited as the first to use the divine-name pattern systematically. He proposed that Moses had compiled Genesis from at least two earlier written sources. The lecture notes that Astruc believed this defended Mosaic authorship. On his view, the doublets showed an honest compiler using good older material, not evidence against Moses.
The lecture uses this verse narrowly, to name the traditional claim that source criticism set out to examine. It says the Pentateuch presents itself, at points like this one, as substantially the work of a single author at a single moment. The lecture says the verse becomes part of an actual argument for Mosaic authorship only in chapter 3.
Moses wrote all Yahweh's words, and rose up early in the morning, and built an altar under the mountain, and twelve pillars for the twelve tribes of Israel. World English Bible, Exodus 24:4
Julius Wellhausen (1844-1918) did not invent source criticism of the Pentateuch. In his 1878 Prolegomena to the History of Israel, he combined decades of source-critical observation with an argument about how Israelite religion developed. The result was a single, coherent account of how the whole Pentateuch came to exist. That combination, more than any new observation, is why the theory carries his name.
Uses the name Yahweh from the start and portrays God vividly. Dated by Wellhausen to roughly the tenth or ninth century BC, in Judah.
Uses "Elohim" until the name is revealed in Exodus 3, and is more reserved about God. Placed slightly later, in the northern kingdom.
Identified with Deuteronomy and its insistence on one place of sacrifice. Linked to King Josiah's reform in 622 BC.
Bulk of Leviticus, much of Numbers and Genesis 1, with a focus on genealogy and sacrifice. Dated latest, to the sixth or fifth century BC.
Wellhausen read the order J, E, D, P as tracking development in Israelite religion, from spontaneous and close to nature toward centralized, codified and priestly. The lecture says this piece of his proposal was most shaped by the intellectual currents of his century, which favored developmental explanations. Critics, including Kenneth Kitchen, have argued this scheme did at least as much work in the dating as the literary evidence did. The lecture names the critique only so the account is not mistaken for a neutral one.
The labels J, E, D and P still appear in critical commentaries, often as a working assumption. Wellhausen's account also shaped how the history of Israelite worship was taught for over a century. The lecture says a student should recognize this influence in a commentary or classroom, whether or not they accept the conclusions. It adds that the observations behind the theory are real features that any theory, including one affirming Mosaic authorship, must account for.
Doublets, the Elohim and Yahweh pattern, and stylistic variation were noticed long before Wellhausen. Astruc first used the divine names to defend Mosaic authorship. Wellhausen's 1878 synthesis proposed four sources in the order J, E, D, P, with a developmental picture of Israelite religion beneath the dating. The lecture presents the theory fairly but does not argue for or against it. That debate belongs to chapter 3.