Lecture 16-3: Esther's Contested Canon and the Festival It Founded
Esther in the canon, and Purim
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Esther in the canon, and Purim
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Esther's place in the canon was argued over for centuries by both Jewish and Christian readers, largely for the reason lecture 16-2 explored: its silence about God. This lecture looks at that reception history briefly. It then turns to Purim, the festival the book explains, and asks what its continuing observance says about how Jewish communities have answered the question left open.
The Mishnah and later rabbinic writings preserve debate over whether Esther "defiles the hands", the technical term for a book's sacred status. Some sages questioned it because the divine name is absent. The violent self-defense in Esther 9, including Esther's request for an extra day in Susa, also caused discomfort. The book's acceptance in the Hebrew canon is not in serious doubt, but it was argued for, not assumed.
Several early church fathers omitted Esther from their lists or noted its unusual status. The Greek text of Esther has six substantial additions not found in the Hebrew, including prayers by Mordecai and Esther that call on God directly. Catholic and Orthodox Christians accept these additions as canonical. Protestant Bibles follow the shorter Hebrew text and treat them as apocryphal or deuterocanonical.
The shorter book, with no divine name and no prayers; the text Protestant Bibles follow.
Six additional passages, including prayers that name God; accepted as canonical by Catholic and Orthodox Christians.
The difference traces to the Beckwith and Sundberg question of how the canon's scope was settled.
After the Jews conquer those who hated them (Esther 9:1), they institute an annual commemoration of days of feasting, gladness, gifts of food to one another and gifts to the needy (Esther 9:22). It is to be kept in every generation, family, province and city (Esther 9:28). The name Purim comes from "Pur", the lot Haman cast to fix the date of destruction. The book appears aware of the irony that the mechanism of chance becomes the name of the celebration.
Purim is still kept. The scroll of Esther, the Megillah, is read aloud, traditionally with noisemaking to drown out Haman's name. People exchange food gifts, give to the poor and share a festive meal, continuing the pattern in Esther 9:22. The lecture notes that few Old Testament narratives have an institution that continues so unbroken, and that the festival answers the silence question in practice, by treating the deliverance as worth remembering.
Esther's journey through the canon was contested among the rabbis and supplemented among Christian scribes, and it is still resolved differently in Jewish, Protestant and Catholic or Orthodox traditions. The lecture says this history is not a footnote to the question of 16-2. It is that question playing out among real readers over centuries, none of whom found the silence easy.
The Greek additions fill the Hebrew book's silence with explicit prayers.
What do you think is gained, and what might be lost, when a text says outright what the shorter version leaves for readers to infer?
Esther's place in the canon was argued over among the rabbis, partly because the divine name never appears, and among Christians, where six Greek additions with explicit prayers are canonical for Catholics and Orthodox and not for Protestants. The festival of Purim, named after the lot Haman cast, is still kept with the Megillah, food gifts and gifts to the poor, giving the silence a concrete answer in practice.