Lecture 24-2: The Authorship Debate
Two serious positions on who wrote Isaiah, reading the same evidence
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Two serious positions on who wrote Isaiah, reading the same evidence
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Isaiah 44:28 and 45:1 name Cyrus of Persia, a specific ruler, as Yahweh's instrument to end the exile. Cyrus began his rise in the 550s BC and conquered Babylon in 539 BC. Isaiah of Jerusalem's ministry, dated by the book's heading, falls in the eighth century BC, about a century and a half earlier. Chapters 40-55 also address a people already exiled and grieving. Both positions agree on these observations and disagree about what they mean.
Bernhard Duhm's 1892 commentary gave the critical position its lasting form. Proto-Isaiah (chapters 1-39) is substantially the eighth-century prophet. Deutero-Isaiah (40-55) is an anonymous prophet among the exiles in Babylon near the end of the exile. Trito-Isaiah (56-66) is a further voice or voices after the return. On this view Cyrus can be named confidently because the prophet is writing during or just before his campaign.
Duhm and later scholars point to differences of vocabulary and style between the sections. They also note a shift in theological emphasis, since chapters 40-55 argue more fully against idols and for Yahweh's uniqueness. And they note that the assumed historical setting of 40-55 matches the late-exilic Babylonian one. The lecture says this position has been the working consensus of critical Old Testament scholarship for over a century. Its details are still debated: some subdivide Trito-Isaiah, propose several hands in Deutero-Isaiah, or stress unity across the whole book.
John Oswalt, in his commentary in the New International Commentary on the Old Testament series, defends one author, the eighth-century prophet. He does not deny the differences in tone and vocabulary. He argues they do not require several authors, and that many scholars treat the Cyrus naming as decisive because they assume specific prediction does not happen. Isaiah 41:21-23 has Yahweh challenge the nations' gods to "declare the former things... or show us things to come." Oswalt reads this as the book's own claim that such prediction marks Yahweh as different from an idol.
Oswalt cites themes running through all three sections, such as the title "the Holy One of Israel," Zion's future exaltation and Yahweh's incomparability. He notes that no ancient manuscript or tradition names a second or third Isaiah. He also notes that John 12:38-41 quotes Isaiah 53:1 and 6:10 together and speaks of "Isaiah" as one figure. The lecture adds that critics reply a New Testament author's use of a conventional attribution does not by itself settle a question about composition.
Duhm's tradition: the prophet wrote during or near Cyrus's 539 BC campaign. Oswalt: the specificity is the book's own claimed proof of Yahweh's uniqueness.
Critics of single authorship see different hands. Defenders see one author changing register for a new subject and audience, as one writer addresses grief differently from triumph.
The shifts exist. They disagree about how much a single skilled author's range can account for.
The Great Isaiah Scroll, found at Qumran and dated to about the second century BC, preserves all sixty-six chapters as one continuous scroll. There is no break at chapter 39/40 or 55/56. This shows Isaiah already circulated as one unified scroll by the second century BC. It does not prove or disprove single authorship of the original composition centuries earlier, because separate material could have been combined into one scroll long before then.
For Oswalt, the deeper issue is whether Scripture can contain specific predictive prophecy, since any specific prediction could be explained away by a later date of composition. For Duhm's tradition, it is whether the historical-critical method should be applied consistently to all evidence, including evidence that a text's content does not match its claimed setting. The lecture says serious, careful scholars hold both views and the course does not choose.
Can you state each position the way its own defenders would recognize, and say what is at stake beyond who gets the dates right?
Isaiah 44:28 and 45:1 name Cyrus, and two positions explain this differently. Duhm's tradition sees three voices across two centuries, with Deutero-Isaiah writing near Cyrus's 539 BC rise. Oswalt defends one eighth-century author, arguing that specific prediction is the book's own proof of Yahweh's uniqueness. The Great Isaiah Scroll shows one unified scroll by the second century BC, but settles transmission, not authorship. The course states both positions and does not choose.