Lecture 27-2: When Was Daniel Written? The Dating Debate and What Is at Stake
Two datings of Daniel, and the question underneath both
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Two datings of Daniel, and the question underneath both
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
If Daniel was written substantially as it claims, by or about a sixth-century exile, then chapter 11 is genuine predictive prophecy reaching more than three hundred years ahead. If it was written in the second century BC, during the crisis under the Seleucid king Antiochus IV Epiphanes, then chapter 11 narrates recent history in the guise of ancient prophecy. That was a real and attested ancient literary practice, but a different kind of book. The manuscripts, the language and the historical detail are real data that every position has to explain.
Daniel 9:24-27 names, in coded but specific terms, an anointed figure who is "cut off" after a stated span, followed by the destruction of "the city and the sanctuary." The lecture calls it the most fought-over paragraph in the book. Every reader, on every side of the dating question, must decide what it describes and when it was written relative to that. It is the dating debate in miniature.
The book's own frame places Daniel in exile under Nebuchadnezzar in 605 BC, with his last visions in the third year of Cyrus (10:1), in the 530s BC. Read at face value, it records one exile's life across roughly seventy years. On this view the specificity of chapter 11 is what predictive prophecy should look like: specific, because the God who reveals the future to his prophets is understood to know it in detail.
An Egyptologist and ancient Near Eastern historian. He points to the book's Persian-period loanwords, its Babylonian court terminology and its portrait of sixth-century imperial administration.
An Old Testament scholar and Hebraist. He argues the Aramaic of the middle chapters resembles the Imperial Aramaic of fifth-century documents such as the Elephantine papyri, and that the Hebrew fits exilic and early post-exilic Hebrew.
The critical consensus among historical-critical scholars places the final composition in the 160s BC. Antiochus IV desecrated the Jerusalem temple in 167 BC, an event traditionally linked to the "abomination that makes desolate" in 9:27, 11:31 and 12:11, and his persecution provoked the Maccabean revolt. The central argument is chapter 11's detail, which holds with unusual accuracy through Antiochus's reign and then breaks down. His death in 11:40-45 does not match the historical record. This view reads the break as the point where writing about the past gives way to genuine looking forward.
Daniel sits in the Writings, not the Prophets. The lecture notes this can reflect genre or editorial history, not only date.
Sirach 48-49, written about 180 BC, surveys earlier prophets without naming Daniel. Critical scholars take this to suggest the book was not yet known in its present form.
Greek words for instruments in chapter 3 have been read as showing a post-Alexander setting. The lecture says this carries less weight than it once did.
Why chapter 11 is so precise, and the features some scholars read as later Aramaic and Hebrew. Kitchen and Archer's linguistic arguments are contested by other specialists.
Fragments of Daniel at Qumran dated as early as the mid-second century BC leave a short window after a 160s composition. It must also explain 9:1's claim to date from the first year of Darius.
The lecture says the deepest disagreement is not about Aramaic grammar but about whether specific, centuries-ahead predictive prophecy is the kind of thing that happens. It calls both positions coherent and examined, held by careful scholars who have read the same texts.
What would have to be true about how God relates to history for each reading of chapter 11 to be the more natural one?
Daniel's dating turns on chapter 11's precision about the Ptolemaic and Seleucid wars. Kitchen and Archer read it as a sixth-century exile's prophecy, while the critical consensus reads it as a second-century writer under Antiochus IV, with the detail breaking down near 11:39-40. Each side must answer real counter-evidence, on language or on the Qumran window. The lecture states the deeper disagreement without settling it, and asks you to be able to explain either side.