Lecture 32-2: The Apocrypha and the Unfinished Canon Debate
The Apocrypha question: how many books belong in the Old Testament?
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
The Apocrypha question: how many books belong in the Old Testament?
Introduction to the Old Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Chapter 1 named two poles: Roger Beckwith's case for a Hebrew canon substantially closed before the Christian era, and the case for a wider, Septuagint-shaped canon associated with Albert Sundberg. This lecture returns to that debate now that the intertestamental history is known. A large share of the course's readers are Catholic or Orthodox and hold these books as Scripture, so the lecture treats the question as open.
"Apocrypha" is a Protestant label meaning roughly "hidden" or "of doubtful authority." "Deuterocanon" is a Catholic label meaning "second canon." They name substantially the same writings: Tobit, Judith, additions to Esther, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Baruch, additions to Daniel, and 1 and 2 Maccabees. Orthodox canons add more, so there is no single wider list.
Wisdom of Solomon and Sirach extend the wisdom tradition. Tobit and Judith are edifying narrative, closer to Esther than to Kings. 1 Maccabees is sober history that many historians value, while 2 Maccabees is more theologically interpretive. Serious Protestant scholars do not call these books fabricated. The disagreement is about canonical status, not historical reliability.
The Hebrew Scriptures were substantially fixed before the New Testament era. The wider books entered some Christian Bibles through the Greek-speaking church's use of the Septuagint.
No single fixed Jewish canon existed in the Second Temple period; communities held different collections. The thirty-nine-book canon was consolidated after AD 70.
The Scrolls include copies of every Old Testament book except Esther, and also some later classed as apocryphal, such as Tobit and Sirach. Sundberg-leaning scholars read this as Scripture-like use. Beckwith-leaning scholars read it only as reading and valuing, which is not the same as counting as Scripture. The manuscripts alone cannot decide.
The Septuagint circulated with these books interspersed, and early Christians generally used it. Jerome, translating from Hebrew, found no Hebrew original behind several and classed them separately. Augustine held that the church's settled use was the relevant authority. Luther and the Reformers set them apart. Trent affirmed the wider canon in 1546 for the Catholic Church, and the Orthodox kept their own wider tradition.
Revelation warns against adding to or taking from "this book." The lecture says the grammar restricts the warning to Revelation itself, a stock closing formula like Deuteronomy 4:2 and 12:32. Using it as a blanket argument asks the text to do something it does not claim. The real argument must come from historical and textual evidence.
The lecture says both positions are serious historical arguments, and that each reader's own tradition has probably decided the question already.
How would you state the strongest case for the position you do not hold?
The books called Apocrypha by Protestants and deuterocanonical by Catholics include Tobit, Judith, Sirach and 1 and 2 Maccabees. Beckwith and Sundberg give two serious historical accounts of how the canon formed, and the evidence does not decide between them. Revelation 22:18-19 protects Revelation itself and cannot settle the question.