Lecture 4-2: The Synoptic Problem
Three live answers to how Matthew, Mark and Luke are related
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Three live answers to how Matthew, Mark and Luke are related
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Read side by side, Matthew, Mark and Luke recur nearly word for word across two or all three. The order of episodes also tracks closely for long stretches, and even narrator's asides such as "let the reader understand" reappear almost verbatim. This is not the pattern of independent eyewitnesses. Explaining how the literary relationship works is called the Synoptic Problem, and it has occupied scholars for more than two centuries without a consensus.
The lecture uses Luke's preface because Luke says plainly that many had already written accounts and that his own work involved tracing and arranging events. It shows a Gospel writer working with existing written material.
Since many have undertaken to set in order a narrative concerning those matters which have been fulfilled among us, even as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and servants of the word delivered them to us, it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus. Luke 1:1-3, World English Bible
The triple tradition is material in all three Gospels, such as the healing of the paralytic let down through a roof. The double tradition is mostly sayings found in Matthew and Luke but not Mark. The order pattern is that Matthew and Luke rarely agree with each other in order against Mark. Minor agreements are small wording matches between Matthew and Luke against Mark, such as the added question "Who is it that struck you?" in Matthew 26:68 and Luke 22:64.
The dominant position holds that Mark was written first, and that Matthew and Luke each used Mark independently. It also holds that they each used a hypothetical sayings source called Q, from the German Quelle, "source." Q is not a surviving document, and no manuscript of it has been found. It is a scholarly reconstruction inferred from material Matthew and Luke share but Mark lacks.
This minority view, first proposed by Johann Jakob Griesbach and revived by William Farmer, holds that Matthew was written first, Luke used Matthew, and Mark came last as a condensed combination of both. It needs no Q. Farmer argued that the case for Mark coming first was an unexamined consensus, and that early church writers who list Matthew first deserved more weight. The difficulty raised against it is why Mark would leave out material both sources shared, such as the birth narratives and most of the Sermon on the Mount.
Austin Farrer proposed, and Mark Goodacre has developed, a view that keeps Mark first but removes Q. Matthew used Mark, and Luke used both Mark and Matthew. Goodacre argues Q was invented to explain an agreement that Luke's direct use of Matthew already explains, and that it also accounts for the minor agreements. The difficulty raised against it is why Luke would scatter Matthew's Sermon on the Mount sayings across many settings, which defenders put down to Luke's habit of spreading teaching through a travel narrative.
Strength: the order argument and Mark's rougher style. Difficulty: Q has never been found.
Strength: early church testimony and no undiscovered document. Difficulty: Mark's omissions on this account.
Strength: Mark first without Q, and an explanation of minor agreements. Difficulty: Luke's handling of Matthew's sayings.
The lecture says a Christian's confidence in the Gospels' truthfulness does not depend on settling this question. All three positions agree the result is four books the church received as authoritative Scripture.
Does the lack of a resolution affect your confidence in the Gospels' content? Why should it, or why should it not?
The Synoptic Problem asks how the shared wording, order and asides of Matthew, Mark and Luke are best explained. Three positions remain live: Two-Source, Griesbach and Farrer. Each explains some of the evidence more naturally than its rivals, and this is a point where readers will not agree. All three accept the same four received books and differ only about the writing process behind three of them.