Lecture 31-1: Marcion, the Muratorian Fragment, and Athanasius's List
From Marcion to Athanasius: a photograph of a growing consensus
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
From Marcion to Athanasius: a photograph of a growing consensus
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
It is easy to read backward and assume early Christians were waiting for someone to tell them which books to trust. The evidence suggests something calmer. By the early second century, most congregations used at least one written Gospel and a collection of Paul's letters in worship. The list-making came later, largely in response to a problem: how to tell a genuine apostolic letter from an imitation once forgeries and edited versions began to circulate.
Marcion of Sinope, active in Rome around AD 144, held that the God of the Old Testament was a different and lesser being than the God of Jesus Christ. He rejected the whole Old Testament and kept a purged Luke and ten edited letters of Paul. This was the first known closed, exclusive list of Christian scripture. F. F. Bruce argues it is best understood as a provocation the church had to answer, and Tertullian and Irenaeus rejected his dualism quickly and explicitly.
The Muratorian Fragment survives in a single damaged Latin manuscript and is named for the scholar who found it. Most scholars date it to roughly AD 170-200 in Rome, though a minority argue for a later date. It lists the four Gospels, Acts, thirteen letters of Paul, Jude, two letters of John and Revelation. In what survives it omits Hebrews, James and both letters of Peter, which shows a process still underway.
The fragment explains some of its choices. It says the Shepherd of Hermas was written "very recently, in our times," so it may be read privately but not in church among the prophets or the apostles. Two criteria are visible in that sentence: recency, since it was not written near the apostolic era, and category. These are the same kinds of tests, closeness to the apostolic generation and agreement with what the church held true, that chapter 1 calls apostolicity and orthodoxy.
Athanasius of Alexandria used part of a routine annual letter announcing the date of Easter to list the books he judged canonical. His New Testament list names exactly the twenty-seven books later Christianity received, and it is the earliest surviving document to do so. He counted Hebrews among fourteen Pauline letters, writing in the Greek-speaking East. He presented the list as handing on what had been delivered, not as a new ruling.
Athanasius's authority was regional, so his letter could not bind the whole church alone. Its list matches decisions reached independently soon after by councils in the Latin West, at Hippo in 393 and Carthage in 397. Uniformity still took time. Some regions, especially parts of the Syriac-speaking church, kept using collections that omitted books like Revelation or included others for a considerable time afterward.
A gradual, principled recognition of books that were already functioning as scripture in worship.
A more skeptical picture of a contest in which some theological factions won out over others.
The evidence shows a real process with argument at the edges, and both models remain live among serious historians. The course does not pretend the evidence alone settles it.
The fragment excluded the Shepherd of Hermas partly because it was written "very recently."
Is closeness to the apostolic era a defensible test on its own? What could go wrong if it is applied too strictly, or too loosely?
The twenty-seven-book New Testament did not arrive by one vote or decree. Marcion's exclusive canon around AD 144 pushed the church to produce positive lists of its own. The Muratorian Fragment shows an early attempt, visibly incomplete. Athanasius's letter of AD 367 is the first surviving document to name exactly the twenty-seven, reporting a consensus that independent councils soon confirmed.