Lecture 31-2: What "Closing" a Canon Actually Means
Three tests together: apostolicity, orthodoxy, catholicity
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Three tests together: apostolicity, orthodoxy, catholicity
Introduction to the New Testament
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The last lecture gave a timeline. This one asks a different question: what test did a book have to pass to end up on the list, and why did some valued, early writings still fail? Historians such as F. F. Bruce and Bruce Metzger find three criteria operating across the church's slow recognition of its scriptures. None worked alone, and seeing how they fit together is more useful than memorizing three words.
Apostolicity asked whether a document could be credibly traced to an apostle or to someone in close contact with one. Mark's traditional link to Peter and Luke's link to Paul are the standard examples for the Gospels. Hebrews' anonymity is why its status took longer to settle. Apostolicity also had a time dimension: Hermas wrote in the generation of the fragment's author, not in the apostolic generation, and that gap was treated as decisive.
Orthodoxy asked whether a document's teaching matched what the wider church already held to be true, judged independently of the document itself. The usual measure was the rule of faith, an early summary of apostolic teaching used in most churches by the second century. This test excluded most of the writings now called New Testament apocrypha. The Gospel of Thomas, for example, taught a secret salvation for elite initiates, which conflicted with what churches across a wide area already taught.
Catholicity here means "universal" in its original sense, not the Roman Catholic Church in particular. It asked whether a document was received and used in worship across a wide spread of churches, not only in one city or faction. This is the slowest of the three tests. It explains why books like 2 Peter were slower to be accepted: not because of a named doctrinal defect, but because they were shorter, more obscure and less widely used.
Some excluded documents were heretical or forged, such as Marcion's edited Luke. Others were read, valued and quoted approvingly. The Shepherd of Hermas was popular enough to appear in Codex Sinaiticus, a great fourth-century manuscript, alongside the Epistle of Barnabas. Canonicity was not a report card on spiritual usefulness. It named documents traceable to the apostolic circle and received as such across the church.
Closing a canon did not mean the church stopped writing theology or that God stopped speaking. It meant declaring that the documents eligible for this apostolically grounded collection were complete, because the apostolic generation had ended. That is why later works such as Augustine's Confessions were never candidates, whatever their quality. The task of collecting eyewitness and near-eyewitness testimony to Christ could not be extended indefinitely.
Its anonymity meant its apostolicity had to be argued. The Eastern church linked it to Paul earlier than the West did.
Its late external attestation reflects a catholicity gap. No heretical content was identified.
Some mostly Eastern leaders hesitated over its genre and authorship into the fourth century, after the Latin West had accepted it.
The Shepherd of Hermas was valued and even copied beside biblical books, yet it was left out of the canon.
What does this tell you about the difference between "spiritually useful" and "canonical"?
A book became canonical by passing three tests together: apostolicity, orthodoxy and catholicity. Hermas shows that good and edifying is not the same as canonical. Closing the canon meant the apostolic testimony was complete, not that theology stopped. Hebrews, 2 Peter and Revelation took longer because wide use accumulates slowly. The lecture says these delays are not evidence that the process was arbitrary.