Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
Rome tolerated almost everything. It made an exception for Christians because Roman religion was about doing the right public things, and Christians would not do them.
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Rome tolerated almost everything. It made an exception for Christians because Roman religion was about doing the right public things, and Christians would not do them.
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Rome absorbed the gods of every people it conquered, and nobody was required to stop believing anything. So the question is not why an intolerant empire attacked a religion, but why a tolerant one made an exception. Roman religion was not primarily about belief but about doing the right things publicly, so that the gods stayed favourable to the community. A group that would not do the public things was, from a Roman point of view, endangering the city.
The lecture calls this the sentence that generates the whole chapter. Peter answers a court by conceding its power while refusing its authority, which shows there is a case where its instruction cannot be followed.
But Peter and the apostles answered, 'We must obey God rather than men.'" Acts 5:29 · World English Bible
The earliest confession we can reconstruct is Kyrios Iesous, Jesus is Lord. Kyrios stood in for the divine name in the Greek Old Testament, and in the eastern provinces it was also used of the emperor. So a confession meant as worship reached Roman ears as a comparison. Most emperors did not claim to be gods, and the imperial cult did not require belief but only honour, such as sacrifice or incense.
Christians had no temple, image, sacrifice or visible priest, and they refused the public rites. In the only civic sense that mattered, they were without gods.
They met privately for a meal at which they spoke of consuming a body and blood. Athenagoras, Justin and Minucius Felix all answered the charge.
Members called each other brother and sister, greeted with a kiss and met at night behind closed doors.
The usual story says Judaism was a licensed religion and Christianity lost that cover. But Roman law had no register of permitted religions, and the phrase appears in Tertullian, not in Roman legal sources. Jews held specific privileges granted piecemeal, and Christians were at first covered incidentally. Christians never acquired any protection of their own, and with no anti-Christian statute for most of this period, governors acted under their general power to keep order.
Romans held that the safety of the community depended on the pax deorum, maintained by correct public worship. If the city was not safe, the gods had been offended, and the people who refused to honour them were blamed. Tertullian describes the cry at every flood, drought or plague: Christians to the lion. Most of the killing began with crowds, not emperors, and the required remedy was always an act, because you cannot repair the peace of the gods by changing your mind.
The rumours were not invented from nothing. They were what a hostile outsider could construct from the true facts of a closed community's life. Private meetings, family language and a meal about a body are each real, and each becomes monstrous when only frightened outsiders describe it. The early church's answer was neither to become secretive nor to drop the practices, but to explain them in public, in writing, to hostile readers.
If a congregation is a minority where it lives, it probably carries a story about what it does at its meetings that is not quite a lie and not remotely true.
What story do your neighbours tell about your church, and how could you explain the real practice in public?
Christians became a problem for four reasons: the loyalty collision of Kyrios, three rumours built from real practices, the lack of any protection of their own, and the belief that they endangered the peace of the gods. What Rome asked was always a small public act. Persecution was popular and erratic because crowds and governors drove it more than law.