Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
Nicaea did not explain how the Son is God. It ruled out one sentence: "there was when he was not."
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Nicaea did not explain how the Son is God. It ruled out one sentence: "there was when he was not."
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Arius was a senior presbyter in Alexandria and an able preacher, not a maverick. He believed he was defending God's oneness. If the Son was begotten, then the begetting happened at some point, so the Son had a beginning. Whatever has a beginning is on the creature's side of the line between God and everything else.
The lecture uses this verse because both sides quoted it, and it holds the whole problem in one sentence: the Word is with God, and the Word is God.
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." John 1:1 · World English Bible
Athanasius argued from salvation. The human problem is corruption and death, so what is needed is re-creation, not improvement. A creature cannot restore creation to God because a creature does not have that to give. Christians also worship Jesus and are baptised into his name, which would be idolatry if he were a creature.
Constantine, who wanted the church to hold the empire together, summoned bishops to Nicaea. About three hundred attended, almost all from the East, and the traditional 318 is symbolic. Nicaea did not decide the canon of Scripture. It also did not produce the creed most Christians recite, which is the longer text associated with Constantinople in 381.
Scriptural phrases such as "from God" or "like the Father" could be signed by Arius's party, so the council chose homoousios, "of the same being." The word is not in the Bible, a synod at Antioch had condemned it in 268, and it could be misread. The council chose it because it could not be evaded.
The Son is the first and highest of God's works, but on the created side. The concern is the oneness of God. Key texts include Proverbs 8:22, Colossians 1:15, John 14:28 and Mark 13:32.
The Son is begotten, not made, and on God's side. The concern is salvation. The term chosen is homoousios, which is unscriptural, once condemned and open to misreading.
Homoiousios, "of like being," was not Arius's position, since he held the Son to be a creature. It appears in the 350s as a moderate position. Athanasius himself came to treat its holders as allies, and most of them ended on the Nicene side. The iota is a real difference, but it is not the line between orthodoxy and heresy.
The lecture asks you to take Arius seriously first, because a course that presents him as absurd cannot explain why so much of the church agreed with him for so long.
Can you state a view you disagree with so that someone who holds it would recognise it, and what did you have to concede to do so?
Nicaea set a boundary and refused to move it: whatever the Son's relation to the Father is, it is not that of a creature to its maker. It leaves the mystery intact and rules out one road. It took a hundred and thirty years, five exiles and a great deal of politics to make that stick.