Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
When Rome was sacked, Augustine answered by defining two cities as two loves, with no chosen empire in the middle of history.
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
When Rome was sacked, Augustine answered by defining two cities as two loves, with no chosen empire in the middle of history.
Early Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
In August 410 Alaric's Goths entered Rome, looted for three days and left. Rome was no longer the seat of government, and the Western empire lasted another sixty-six years. What broke was an idea, that this city was permanent and that history had a chosen city in it. Augustine spent thirteen years and twenty-two books taking that idea apart.
The pagan senatorial class argued that Rome kept the gods and grew, and that abandoning them brought the sack. This was the standard Roman theory of politics, and it landed on Christians who had read the empire as providential. Augustine answered that Rome had suffered catastrophes while the gods were still fed. Outward goods and disasters fall on the good and the bad alike, and what separates people is what they love.
Love of self to the contempt of God made the earthly city, and love of God to the contempt of self made the heavenly one. A city is defined by what its members love, and in what order. So neither city is a visible institution: the earthly city is not the Roman state, and the heavenly city is not the church. The two are mixed together in this age and cannot be sorted by us.
The lecture notes the Greek word behind citizenship is politeuma, a civic term, written to a Roman colony. It says Paul tells them where their standing is registered, which is the claim Augustine builds on.
For our citizenship is in heaven, from where we also wait for a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ;" Philippians 3:20 · World English Bible
Government restrains violence, and the pilgrim city uses the earthly peace, obeys the laws and prays for the city where it lives.
Rome can be called a people and judged by what it loved, which he names as the lust for domination. No state can claim to be the City of God.
Augustine argues against the idea that the ages revolve and everything returns, because Christ died once for our sins. History has a centre in the incarnation and an end that is not a return to the start. He holds that God governs the rise and fall of empires, but he offers no method for reading current events as reward or punishment. His contribution is the removal of the chosen empire from the middle of history.
Medieval writers on both sides of the investiture struggles took the two cities to mean the papacy and the empire, which Augustine had explicitly denied. His scattered remarks on war supplied seeds for the just war tradition, and his hedged justifications often survived without the hedges. The lecture says a book written to stop Christians believing in a chosen empire was used to build one.
Augustine could not say which city a person belongs to, only that the two are mixed.
What would it change in your own church or country to stop treating any institution as identical with the good?
The sack of 410 broke the idea of a permanent Rome, and Augustine replaced it with two cities defined by love. Neither city is the church or the state, and history runs under providence that cannot be read off events. The doctrine protects against any state claiming to be the City of God, and it also leaves nothing outward to measure.