Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
The crusades followed from the idea that fighting a named enemy is itself meritorious. The lecture counts what they cost and who bore it.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
The crusades followed from the idea that fighting a named enemy is itself meritorious. The lecture counts what they cost and who bore it.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The lecture notes that Jesus spoke these words while an armed disciple was defending him from arrest. It calls this the most defensible case of religious violence in the New Testament.
Then Jesus said to him, 'Put your sword back into its place, for all those who take the sword will die by the sword.'" Matthew 26:52 · World English Bible
In the spring of 1096, bands led by Count Emicho attacked the Jewish communities of Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne. Thousands were killed. Church teaching held that Jews were to be protected, and the bishop of Speyer sheltered his city's Jewish community. But the lecture says it followed from the theology anyway. Once killing the enemies of Christ earns merit, you do not control who is put into that category.
Jerusalem fell on 15 July 1099, and a general massacre of its Muslim and Jewish inhabitants followed. The Latin chronicler Raymond of Aguilers is not confessing but exulting. He presents the scene as the winepress of God's wrath. The taking of Jerusalem was received in the West as proof that God had authorised the enterprise.
Failure could be read as the sin of the crusaders needing purification. Success could be read as divine endorsement. After the failed Second Crusade, Bernard of Clairvaux explained it by the sins of the crusaders, and the theology was not questioned. A theology that can absorb both outcomes as confirmation has stopped being answerable to evidence.
Preached by Bernard of Clairvaux. It achieved nothing and ended in a botched siege of Damascus.
A response to Saladin's recapture of Jerusalem in 1187. Richard I did not take the city, and a truce gave pilgrims access.
Aimed at Egypt, but it sacked Constantinople and never reached a Muslim opponent at all.
An idea licensed for one enemy did not stay pointed at that enemy. Crusades were later preached against Cathars in southern France, against pagan Balts, and against Christian political opponents of the papacy. When Saladin took Jerusalem in 1187 there was no general massacre, and inhabitants were ransomed. Western writers had to account for that.
The First Crusade inaugurated mass anti-Jewish violence in Christian Europe.
1204, and the failure of every reunion afterwards.
A regional frontier disturbance at the time, but central in modern memory.
An argument that violence in God's name can sanctify the violent, and a memory that mission in Muslim-majority places still works against.
In 2000, John Paul II led a public request for forgiveness for sins committed by Christians against other groups, including Jews and members of other faiths. In 2001, in Athens, he expressed sorrow for the sack of Constantinople in 1204. Nine hundred years is a long time. The lecture still thinks it worth marking that it happened.
Some historians warn against reading the crusades only through modern relations. Others say a church assessing its own past is asking what it owes.
What do you think a church owes when it looks honestly at its own history, apart from the question of proportion?
The crusades were not a lapse in medieval thinking but an application of it: fighting a designated enemy is itself meritorious. Victory proved God's favour and defeat proved the crusaders' sin, so neither put the premise in question. The cost fell on Jews, Eastern Christians, Muslims and the church's own witness.