Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
Two movements wanted to live like the apostles. The church condemned one and welcomed the other, and the lecture asks why.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Two movements wanted to live like the apostles. The church condemned one and welcomed the other, and the lecture asks why.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Around 1173 a rich merchant of Lyons gave away his wealth and began to preach in the street. Within twenty years his followers were excommunicated. Thirty-odd years later a young man in Assisi did something similar and was made a saint. The lecture says the difference was not mainly doctrine. It was obedience.
The medieval church's wealth grew because people left it property when they died, to pay for prayers for the dead. Simony, which is the buying and selling of church office, became normal. The eleventh-century reformers wanted a church free from lay control and morally serious. They did not want a poor church.
The lecture says almost every figure in it could quote this verse. What divided them was whether it was addressed to everyone, to a special class of Christians, or to no one in particular any more.
Jesus said to him, 'If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me.'" Matthew 19:21 · World English Bible
The vita apostolica means the apostolic life. The claim was that the church of Acts held everything in common, and the apostles went out with no purse and no bag. That was not a temporary rule for the first generation. It was what the church is supposed to look like. It was a lay movement, and it came with a critique attached.
Peter Waldo gave away his property around 1173 and began to preach. In 1179 the pope approved his vow of poverty but forbade him to preach without local permission. His followers preached anyway, and in 1184 they were excommunicated at Verona. Only after that did they develop their own distinct doctrines.
The Cathars, as the sources describe them, were dualists. A good God made spirit, and an evil principle made matter. If matter is evil, then the incarnation is impossible and the sacraments are worthless. Their elite, the perfecti, were visibly poor and holy, while papal legates arrived with horses and fine clothing.
Orthodox Christians. They were excommunicated for preaching without permission. They survived and joined the Reformation.
Dualists who held that matter is evil. A crusade was preached against them, then the Inquisition followed.
R. I. Moore and Mark Gregory Pegg, among others, argue that Catharism as an organised counter-church is largely a construct of the inquisitors. Other historians hold that the dualist theology is well attested. The course states the traditional account because readers will meet it everywhere, and it flags that this account is under challenge.
In 1209 Innocent III preached a crusade against the Cathars of southern France, and the Inquisition began in the 1230s. At the same time the papacy authorised two new orders whose members would be poor, mobile, urban and licensed to preach. These were everything the Waldensians had asked to be, with the one thing they had refused: permission.
The papal legates lost the argument in Languedoc before they opened their mouths.
What is your church's equivalent of arriving on a fine horse?
The church applied the criterion of obedience, not orthodoxy. It destroyed the movement that left its authority and canonised the one that stayed inside it. Condemnation can create the dissent it names.