Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
Anselm began from faith and reasoned from there. This lecture follows the move from monastic to scholastic theology and two of his famous arguments.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Anselm began from faith and reasoned from there. This lecture follows the move from monastic to scholastic theology and two of his famous arguments.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Around 1077 the abbot Anselm searched for one self-contained argument that God exists and is what Christians say he is. He wrote it down in a book he first called Faith Seeking Understanding. The phrase does not mean faith looking for evidence. Anselm already believed, and he held that what he believed was intelligible.
The lecture calls this verse the charter of the whole chapter. It notes two halves: a demand to always be ready to give a reason, and a manner, which is humility and fear. Scholasticism was magnificent at the first, and chapter 4 asks what happened to the second.
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts. Always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear." 1 Peter 3:15 · WEB
Slow reading, called lectio divina. Its aim was to be changed by the text. Its forms were the sermon, the commentary and the meditation.
The question was its central practice. It gathered authorities on both sides and reasoned to a resolution. Its forms were the disputed question and the summa.
Dialectic means logic, the art of reasoned argument, and the West's grasp of it improved sharply in the eleventh century. In the 1120s Peter Abelard wrote Sic et Non, which lines up quotations from Scripture and the Fathers that contradict one another. He gave no answers, but he did offer rules for handling apparent contradiction. Bernard of Clairvaux fought him, because a method that can question anything can also corrode anything.
Anselm wrote: I believe in order that I may understand. It does not mean you must believe first and evidence will be supplied. It means faith is the starting position from which the thinking is done. You begin inside and reason from there. Anselm also set out to argue from reason alone, while believing on the authority of Scripture.
Anselm defines God as that than which nothing greater can be conceived. It is greater to exist in reality than only in the mind. So if that being existed only in the mind, we could conceive of something greater, which is a contradiction. The argument uses no observation of the world and works purely from what the word God means.
A monk called Gaunilo replied that the same reasoning could prove an island than which no greater island can be conceived. Seven centuries later Kant objected that existence is not a property. In the twentieth century philosophers such as Plantinga rebuilt the argument using modal logic. The lecture says it has been refuted often and is still in the journals.
Anselm says sin withholds from God the honour due to him. Justice requires satisfaction, which restores what was taken. A human being must pay the debt, but it is infinite, so only God can pay it. Therefore the one who pays must be a God-man, who offers his life freely.
Anselm's atonement theology uses feudal words: honour, debt and satisfaction.
What vocabulary does your own church's atonement theology borrow, and from where?
Faith seeking understanding means beginning inside faith and reasoning from there. It does not mean looking for evidence to reassure an anxious believer. The lecture warns that this confidence cannot, by itself, keep a church honest.