Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the rest of Aristotle reached Latin Europe. This lecture follows how it arrived and the three ways the West answered.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the rest of Aristotle reached Latin Europe. This lecture follows how it arrived and the three ways the West answered.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
For most of the Middle Ages the Latin West knew Aristotle only as a logician. Then, over about a century from 1150, the rest of his works arrived. They gave a complete account of the natural world, the soul and the good life, without reference to the God of Israel, the incarnation or Scripture. It was the greatest intellectual shock the medieval West ever received.
The Islamic world had all of Aristotle in Arabic, translated in Baghdad from the eighth century onward. Europe recovered him largely from Muslim scholarship, in places such as Toledo. Three names came with the texts: Avicenna, Averroes and the Jewish philosopher Maimonides. On this road, the lecture says, the traffic went both ways, and Europe was the one receiving.
On several points Aristotle appeared to contradict Christian doctrine directly. He argued that the world has no beginning, while Genesis says it did. He treated the soul as the form of the body, which seemed to mean it goes when the body dies. His Prime Mover does not create, intervene or answer prayer. And nature seemed to run by its own causes without ever mentioning God.
The lecture says the thirteenth century read its two verses hard, in opposite directions. One party heard this verse as saying to keep pagan philosophy out.
throwing down imaginations and every high thing that is exalted against the knowledge of God, and bringing every thought into captivity to the obedience of Christ." 2 Corinthians 10:5 · World English Bible
The lecture says the other party heard this verse as saying that God is owed your mind. On that reading, a mind that refuses the best available argument is not loving God with it.
Jesus said to him, 'You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.'" Matthew 22:37 · WEB
Ban the books. Paris forbade lecturing on Aristotle's natural philosophy in 1210. The ban failed, and by 1255 the works were required reading.
Arts masters such as Siger of Brabant reported what philosophy concludes, even when it disagreed with faith. Opponents called this double truth.
Deny that the conflict is real and do the work of showing it. This was the project of Aquinas.
No Averroist text states the double-truth doctrine in that form, and Siger denied holding it. Most historians now treat it as a construction by his opponents rather than anyone's actual view. The lecture says the charge is worth knowing because it dominated the controversy, and worth doubting because it may never have been anyone's position.
Aquinas held that nature, including human reason, is God's work, so reason used properly cannot arrive at what is false. Reason can reach that God exists and that the soul is immortal. It cannot reach the Trinity, the incarnation or that the world began in time. These are above reason, not contrary to it. He held that the world began, yet argued that you cannot prove it philosophically.
Aristotle separates what a thing is, its substance, from its observable properties, its accidents. The Eucharist doctrine of 1215 uses exactly this vocabulary. Aquinas accepted that the soul is the form of the body, and he did not go back to Plato's soul in a body. He kept Aristotle's analysis of motion but said it reaches a being of pure actuality, who is also the Creator.
In 1270 the bishop of Paris condemned thirteen propositions. In 1277, three years after Aquinas died, he condemned 219. Some of them were positions Aquinas himself held. Aquinas was canonised in 1323, and in 1325 the condemnation was annulled so far as it touched his teaching.
Aristotle reached the West through Muslim and Jewish scholars and offered a complete account of the world without God. Aquinas answered that grace does not destroy nature but perfects it. Reason can reach far, but not everything.