Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
Many devout people did not rebel and did not leave. They quietly moved their religious lives to where those lives could still be lived.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Many devout people did not rebel and did not leave. They quietly moved their religious lives to where those lives could still be lived.
Medieval Church History
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Imagine a devout Christian in the Rhineland in 1380. There are two popes, and the parish priest was ordained in a hurry after the plague. This person has not lost faith. The confidence that the institution is where faith is best served has gone. So a great many people went around the institution, not out of it. They built their religious lives at one remove from the machinery.
The lecture says that Christ quotes Hosea here against a religious establishment that had the ritual correct. Every movement in the lecture read this verse as addressed to their own century.
But you go and learn what this means: 'I desire mercy, and not sacrifice,' for I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance." Matthew 9:13 · World English Bible
From the late twelfth century, women in the Low Countries and the Rhineland began to live together in communities that fitted no category. They took no permanent vows, were not enclosed and belonged to no order. They supported themselves by spinning, weaving, nursing and teaching. They offered the religious life to women who were neither rich nor willing to be enclosed for ever. They were also suspect, because they were women living religiously outside male supervision.
The Council of Vienne (1311-12) issued decrees restricting the Beguines. It also condemned a set of errors called the heresy of the Free Spirit. Whether any organised group held those errors is disputed by historians. In Paris in 1310 Marguerite Porete was burned for refusing to withdraw her book, The Mirror of Simple Souls. It was a work of mystical theology written in French for lay readers.
Meister Eckhart was a Dominican and a senior administrator of his order. He preached in German, largely to Beguines and nuns. He taught that in the deepest part of a human being there is a point where God and the soul meet without mediation. He called it the ground of the soul. He also taught the birth of the Word in the soul, and Gelassenheit, which means letting go of attachment.
In 1329, a year after Eckhart's death, twenty-eight propositions from his work were censured by a papal bull. His pupils Johannes Tauler and Henry Suso carried the teaching forward in a more cautious form. The anonymous Theologia Germanica came out of the same current. Luther edited and published it in 1516 and again in 1518.
Geert Groote of Deventer gave up his benefices and began preaching repentance. Around him gathered the Brethren and Sisters of the Common Life, who took no vows, held goods in common and copied manuscripts for a living. Their spirituality, the modern devotion, was inward and practical, centred on Christ, and methodical. They practised daily self-examination and structured meditation, and they were suspicious of scholasticism.
Thomas a Kempis compiled The Imitation of Christ in the 1420s. It became the most widely read Christian book after the Bible. It has short chapters, plain sentences and no technical vocabulary, and it is addressed to the individual reader. The Brethren also ran good schools in Deventer, Zwolle and 's-Hertogenbosch. Erasmus was educated in them.
A religious life without vows or enclosure. Outside supervision, not outside the church.
The ground of the soul and the Word born within. Loyal, but the decisive event is unadministered.
Methodical, practical, Christ-centred piety. Sacramental and devout, and impatient with speculation.
The lecture warns against telling the story as lay religion leading to Luther. The Devotio Moderna was intensely sacramental, and Eckhart was a Dominican in good standing to the end. The same mysticism fed Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross. What these movements prepared was conditions, not doctrine. Historians read them differently, and the course does not settle that.
Eckhart never told anyone to leave the church, but he located the decisive event where no institution administers it.
Can a church contain that teaching safely? Should it want to?
People did not rebel and did not leave. They moved their religious lives to where they could still be lived, and they went on attending Mass. Authority does not usually leave through the front door with a manifesto. It is simply stopped being consulted.