Lecture 1-3: Conciliarism and the Council of Constance
Conciliarism was a Catholic idea that worked once. By the time Luther appealed to a future council, the papacy had already closed that door.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Conciliarism was a Catholic idea that worked once. By the time Luther appealed to a future council, the papacy had already closed that door.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Jean Gerson was chancellor of theology at the University of Paris, an insider who defended orthodox positions. Watching rival popes each insist on legitimacy with no appeal, he argued that the church could not be left permanently without a way to resolve such a dispute. Christ's promise to preserve the church from fatal error was made to the whole church, and a general council best expressed that whole-church authority. In an extreme case it could judge between claimants or depose a pope.
The lecture uses the Jerusalem council as the New Testament's own account of a gathered body settling a disputed question, which conciliarists cited as precedent and their opponents read differently.
Some men came down from Judea and taught the brothers, "Unless you are circumcised after the custom of Moses, you can't be saved." ... The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter. When there had been much discussion, Peter rose up and said to them, "Brothers, you know that a good while ago God made a choice among you, that by my mouth the nations should hear the word of the Good News, and believe. ... Therefore my judgment is that we don't trouble those from among the Gentiles who turn to God, but that we write to them that they abstain from the pollution of idols, from sexual immorality, from what is strangled, and from blood."" Acts 15:1, 6-7, 19-20 · World English Bible
The apostles and elders resolved the gravest early controversy as a gathered body, so a council's authority to settle disputes, including who holds office, has warrant reaching back to the apostles.
Peter's testimony carries weight and James, presiding, delivers the judgment. On this reading even a council needs apostolic authority within it. The lecture does not adjudicate between the two.
The Council of Constance met in 1414 with the backing of Emperor Sigismund. John XXIII fled in an attempt to dissolve it, and the council answered with the decree Haec Sancta, stating that a legitimate general council holds power directly from Christ and binds all, including a pope, on ending the Schism. It deposed John, accepted Gregory XII's resignation, and declared Benedict XIII deposed. It then elected Martin V, accepted across virtually the whole of Western Christendom.
A council that had ended a schism by asserting its authority over the papacy left every later pope asking what would stop it happening to them. Popes worked to contain the principle, and Basel, which met from 1431 to 1449, spiraled into its own conflict with Pope Eugenius IV. The Fifth Lateran Council of 1512-17 reaffirmed papal primacy over any council and treated Haec Sancta as an emergency measure. It closed in March 1517, months before Luther's Ninety-Five Theses.
In 1518 and 1520 Luther appealed beyond the pope to a future general council. That tool had real, recent, successful precedent, since Constance had deposed popes within living memory. But the papacy had spent a century working to prevent such an appeal and had just said so formally at Lateran V. The appeal produced no council, and Luther's argument moved toward Scripture as the court of last appeal.
Conciliarists argued that no pope could be trusted to resolve a dispute about his own legitimacy.
When a leader cannot be trusted to judge his own case, what kind of wider body with accountability would you want in your own church?
Conciliarism is the Catholic argument that a general council holds authority above a single pope in a crisis, and at Constance it ended the Schism. The papacy later reversed it, and Lateran V closed in 1517. So when Luther appealed to a council, that route was already shut.