Lecture 7-1: Leipzig and the Turn Toward 1520
At Leipzig in 1519 a debate about grace became a debate about authority. A year later Luther's three treatises set out a coordinated program.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
At Leipzig in 1519 a debate about grace became a debate about authority. A year later Luther's three treatises set out a coordinated program.
The History of the Reformation
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Andreas Karlstadt drew Johann Eck's fire first, over free will and grace. Eck had studied Luther's writing closely enough to see where the argument was heading, and over several weeks in June and July 1519 he steered the disputation toward Luther directly. The question underneath was by what authority anyone settles a disputed point of Christian doctrine.
Eck was a genuine Thomist scholar and not a bureaucrat sent to intimidate a monk. He had already engaged Luther's theses in print before Leipzig. His strategy of drawing the argument toward councils and then toward Hus reflects real insight into where Luther's position would have to land. He was not wrong that a challenge to papal authority raises the question of whether a council can err.
The lecture uses this verse to name the standard Luther increasingly applied against every other authority at Leipzig, and notes that Eck, Cajetan and the theologians of Trent all affirmed it too.
Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness," 2 Timothy 3:16 · World English Bible
Eck asked Luther whether he sided with Jan Hus, condemned at Constance in 1415. Luther answered that several of Hus's condemned propositions were "most Christian and evangelical" and that the council had erred, because a council is a human assembly capable of mistake. This did not make him a Hussite, but it placed him publicly beside a man everyone knew had been executed for heresy. Luther later described finding how much matched his own views as an unsettling surprise.
Conciliarism had risen at Constance and been defeated at the Fifth Lateran Council (1512-17), and by 1519 no strong conciliarist party was left. Luther's repeated appeal to a future, free, Christian council was therefore a gamble and not an obviously available remedy. He was reaching for a tool that his own century's church had spent decades dismantling.
To the Christian Nobility addresses the structure of authority and answers with the priesthood of all believers. The Babylonian Captivity addresses sacramental practice and reduces seven sacraments to two or arguably three. The Freedom of a Christian addresses the individual believer and describes what a life shaped by justification by faith looks like. It is the most personal and least polemical of the three.
See a single, coherent theological vision unfolding with remarkable speed.
See a move within one year from correcting an abuse to dismantling the church's structure, faster than the seriousness of that step warranted.
At Leipzig, Eck steered a debate on grace toward the question of final authority, and Luther said a council can err because Scripture cannot. This placed him publicly beside Hus. Both readings of the 1520 treatises agree on the documents and dates, and disagree on whether their speed shows clarity or haste.