무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

CH202E · 4장

Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About

Deism began as a search for a God nobody would kill over. The lecture takes that motive seriously, follows the argument to its cost, and sets out the answers of Butler and the revivals.

The Church in the Modern World

13장 전체 강의 20분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • Set out the philosophical roots of Deism and the "watchmaker" account of God, in the terms its own defenders used.
  • State the contrast between revealed religion and natural religion, and explain why natural religion looked to many like the reasonable and humane option.
  • Trace the argument by which Deism ruled out miracle and revelation, and follow it through to what happened to the doctrines of atonement, incarnation and the Trinity.
  • Describe the Christian responses — Butler's Analogy and the revival movements — and assess what each achieved and what it left unanswered.
The motive

Five points and no revelation

Lord Herbert of Cherbury published De Veritate in 1624, six years into the Thirty Years War. He proposed stripping religion down to what any honest person could recognise without a priest, a council or a confession. There is a supreme God, who should be worshipped. Worship is mainly living well, wrongdoing must be repented, and there is reward and punishment after death. Nothing in it was worth killing a neighbour over.

핵심 Take the motive seriously before weighing the cost.
The watchmaker

A perfect clock needs no mending

A perfect maker builds a mechanism that does not need adjusting. A clock brought back to the workshop every month is a badly made clock. So on this account denying miracles is a compliment to God's competence. Leibniz used this reasoning against Newton in 1715–16. The lecture calls it two Christians disagreeing about what honours God more.

핵심 The argument was a good one, and it was made by Christians too.
At a glance

Natural and revealed religion

Natural religion

What people can know of God from the world and conscience. Its evidence is public. Tindal argued the gospel only republishes it, and that confining saving truth to those with the Scriptures would condemn most of humanity by an accident of geography.

Revealed religion

What God has said and done in particular places at particular times. Its defenders say a personal God acts personally, and personal action is always particular.

Scripture

Why 2 Chronicles 16:9?

The lecture reads the verse whole as the prophet Hanani telling King Asa that war will follow. It says the God of this sentence is watching, involved and has preferences, which is not the watchmaker.

For the eyes of Yahweh run back and forth throughout the whole earth, to show himself strong in the behalf of them whose heart is perfect toward him. Herein you have done foolishly; for from henceforth you shall have wars.”" 2 Chronicles 16:9 · World English Bible
The cost

A God who never speaks

A God who has never spoken cannot be disobeyed and cannot be trusted, only inferred. Prayer becomes at best self-composure, and forgiveness has no mechanism. A God with nothing to do turns out to be a God nobody thinks about. The practical end of Deism was a slow, polite disappearance.

핵심 The cost is easy to state and hard to feel.
Down the chain

From miracle to atonement

Once revelation is set aside, the deductions run quickly. Miracles were treated as allegory, and Hume's 1748 essay put the case against them most formidably as a sceptic's argument. Incarnation and Trinity were pressed as unintelligible. A cross became an inspiring example rather than a rescue. The lecture says this is the conclusion of the chain, not the motive at its start.

핵심 Each step was taken for a reason a Christian could respect.
What was gained

Toleration

The Deist argument for toleration was not a pose. If God is known through a reason all people share, coercing belief is both wicked and pointless. That reasoning fed into the case for religious liberty, and it is present in the American founding. The lecture says a church that received religious freedom partly from these men should say so. The same root also gave the idea that no religion is the way, which removes the ground for mission.

핵심 Toleration and relativism came from one root.
At a glance

Two answers in two registers

Butler's Analogy (1736)

He accepted the Deists' premise that nature displays God, then showed nature contains the same difficulties they found in revelation. He won by arguing on their ground, so defence became a case to be made rather than a message to be announced.

The revivals

They answered the question underneath, whether God does anything, with a claim that people were experiencing him. The lecture says they were not mainly a rebuttal of Deism, and that two things in the same decades are not automatically cause and effect.

Think about it

Prayer and a God who speaks

The lecture says a God who never speaks cannot be disobeyed, only inferred.

Where does your own practice of prayer assume God speaks, and where does it assume he does not?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Deism started with a peaceful motive, but it left a God who never speaks. Deism forced the church to say plainly that God is not merely the origin of the world but an agent within it who speaks, acts and can be dealt with.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 13