무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

CH401E · 2장

Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology

The filioque is the one break in this chapter that is still unhealed. It began as a Spanish anti-Arian tool and grew into an East-West divide, and the lecture states both sides fairly.

The History of Christian Doctrine

14장 전체 강의 23분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • Trace the filioque's origin at the regional Council of Toledo (late sixth century) and explain its original anti-Arian purpose in Visigothic Spain.
  • Explain how and why the phrase spread through the Carolingian West, including Charlemagne's own involvement, well before Rome itself formally adopted it.
  • Describe the filioque's role — one among several factors — in the mutual excommunications of 1054, without treating it as the sole or even necessarily the primary cause.
  • State fairly, from both the Eastern and Western sides, the theological argument over whether the Spirit's procession includes the Son — this course's central test case for a live, unresolved doctrinal disagreement.
  • Describe Augustine's psychological analogy of the Trinity and its uneven Eastern reception, and summarize Aquinas's systematic treatment of Trinitarian doctrine.
Origin

A local defense in Visigothic Spain

The filioque, Latin for and the Son, was added to the creed's statement that the Spirit proceeds from the Father. It did not begin as an attack on the East. In sixth-century Spain the ruling Visigothic elite had held a homoian form of Christianity until the Third Council of Toledo in 589. A Spanish liturgical tradition added and the Son to underline that the Son shares in everything the Father does, as a pastoral tool to keep a recently converted population Nicene.

핵심 The lecture calls the original setting a blunt pastoral tool.
The procedural fact

Never approved by an ecumenical council

The filioque entered Western use regionally in Spain, spread through Frankish territory, and was adopted at Rome only in 1014 under pressure from Emperor Henry II. That is more than four centuries after Toledo and more than six after Constantinople finished the creed. Every ecumenical council recognized by both East and West produced the creed without it. The lecture calls this procedural fact the strongest plank in the Eastern objection.

핵심 The procedure matters alongside the theology.
Carolingian spread

Charlemagne and Leo III

Charlemagne, crowned emperor in 800, promoted the filioque and convened a council at Aachen in 809 that affirmed it. He urged Pope Leo III to insert it in the creed used at Mass. Leo agreed with the theology but refused to alter a text fixed by ecumenical council, and reportedly had the original creed inscribed on silver plates at St. Peter's. The lecture says the spread was substantially about Carolingian ambition to distinguish Frankish Christendom from Byzantium.

핵심 It was not simply Rome forcing the filioque on the East.
1054

One grievance among several

In 1054 Cardinal Humbert and Patriarch Michael Cerularius excommunicated each other's side. The filioque was a named grievance, but so were unleavened versus leavened bread, papal jurisdiction and clerical celibacy, along with long political and cultural estrangement. The lecture says 1054 was not experienced as a final break and local relations continued for generations. The schism hardened gradually, reinforced by events such as the sack of Constantinople in 1204.

핵심 Do not treat 1054 as caused by the filioque alone.
Readers will not agree

East and West on the procession

The Eastern position

Only an ecumenical council could change the creed. The Father alone is the source, the monarchy of the Father, and a double procession risks two sources or lowers the Spirit's dignity.

The Western position

All that the Father has belongs to the Son (John 16:15), and the Spirit is tied to the Son's sending in John 20:22, Galatians 4:6 and Romans 8:9. Father and Son are one principle of the Spirit, not two sources.

Fairness

Each side protects something real

The lecture says neither side is careless with Scripture or the doctrine of God. The East protects the Father's unique place as the Trinity's sole source. The West protects the full, equal sharing of Father and Son in everything except what distinguishes them as persons. Some dialogue documents have proposed from the Father through the Son as compatible content, though that proposal is itself contested. The lecture leaves the disagreement standing because it still stands.

핵심 A bridging formula is proposed but not settled.
Augustine

The psychological analogy

Augustine's On the Trinity, from the early fifth century, supplied much of the Western apparatus. Since humans are made in God's image, he sought an analogy in the human mind, most famously memory, understanding and will. They are three distinct faculties in one undivided mind, avoiding tritheism. Eastern critics say his essence-first starting point differs from the Cappadocian persons-first approach and makes the filioque easier to reach. The lecture says it remains debated how fair that reading of Augustine is.

핵심 The objection is a serious historiographical argument.
Aquinas

Persons as subsistent relations

Thomas Aquinas, in the Summa Theologiae, defined each person by relation. The Father is paternity, the Son is filiation, and the Spirit is procession from Father and Son as from one principle. Since God's essence is absolutely simple, he argued, a real distinction of persons can only be one of relation. He defended the filioque as following from this logic. Eastern theologians contest it by locating the Son's and Spirit's distinction in different manners of origin, both from the Father alone.

핵심 Without the Son as a principle, Aquinas said, the Spirit could not be distinguished.
Scripture

Why John 15:26?

The lecture says this verse states the Spirit's procession from the Father without mentioning the Son. It is the verse the Eastern position leans on most heavily.

When the Counselor has come, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father, he will testify about me." John 15:26 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why John 20:22?

The lecture says the Western position most often cites the risen Son breathing the Spirit on the disciples. Whether that implies eternal procession is the question the controversy turns on.

When he had said this, he breathed on them, and said to them, 'Receive the Holy Spirit!'" John 20:22 · WEB
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The filioque began in sixth-century Spain as an anti-Arian tool, was never approved by an ecumenical council, and reached Rome in 1014. In 1054 it was one grievance among several. The East protects the Father as sole source and the West protects the full sharing of Father and Son, and the lecture treats both as serious. Know which form of the creed your church uses and speak of the other fairly.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 14