무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

CH401E · 3장

Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument

Chalcedon did not end the argument. It left a division that has never healed, and two more councils had to clarify what it meant.

The History of Christian Doctrine

14장 전체 강의 22분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • Explain why Chalcedon's definition satisfied neither strict Cyrillians (who heard "two natures" as a return to Nestorianism) nor committed Antiochenes, and describe the origin and present-day reality of the Oriental Orthodox/Chalcedonian split.
  • State what the Three Chapters controversy was actually about (three specific writers and writings judged Nestorian-leaning, condemned decades after their deaths) and what the Second Council of Constantinople (553) decided.
  • Define monothelitism (one will in Christ) as a seventh-century attempt at a compromise formula with the miaphysite churches, and explain why it failed on the same logic that had condemned Apollinarianism and Eutychianism.
  • Describe Maximus the Confessor's argument for two wills in Christ, the price he paid for it (his tongue and right hand, by imperial order, after the Third Council of Constantinople condemned monothelitism in 680–681), and why the church has remembered his mutilation as itself part of the theological argument.
The definition

A fence, not a solution

The Chalcedonian Definition confesses one Christ acknowledged in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. The four negatives rule out Eutyches's blending and Nestorius's splitting without explaining the union philosophically. That restraint was deliberate: it drew a fence wide enough to keep the church inside while real theological work continued. Strict Cyrillians heard a return to Nestorianism, and committed Antiochenes thought it did not protect Christ's humanity enough.

핵심 Both sides signed the same document and read two different councils into it.
A lasting split

The miaphysite churches

Egypt and much of Syria rejected Chalcedon outright, judging that its two-natures language divided Christ. They held mia physis, one united nature that is both fully divine and fully human, which is why miaphysite is the more careful label than monophysite. Their descendants are the Oriental Orthodox communion: the Coptic, Ethiopian, Eritrean, Syriac, Armenian and Malankara churches, among others. Modern dialogues suggest the dispute may owe much to terminology and mistrust, yet communion is still not restored.

핵심 The lecture states both positions fairly and does not judge between them.
Constantinople II

The Three Chapters (553)

Emperor Justinian proposed condemning three items: Theodore of Mopsuestia and his writings, certain writings of Theodoret of Cyrus, and a letter attributed to Ibas of Edessa. Many Western bishops saw this as undoing Chalcedon, since Theodoret and Ibas had been received as orthodox there. The council condemned the Three Chapters while explicitly reaffirming Chalcedon. It did not win back the miaphysite churches, because the split had already hardened.

핵심 It was a fight over dead men's writings, aimed at pruning an over-Antiochene reading.
Monothelitism

One will, one old mistake

Facing conquest in Egypt and Syria, Emperor Heraclius wanted reconciliation, and Patriarch Sergius proposed that Christ has two natures but only one energy and one will. The lecture shows the argument has the shape of Apollinarius's: two wills would mean two agents, so let there be one. It is Apollinarianism's logic one faculty later. The Third Council of Constantinople (680-681) condemned it.

핵심 The same underlying mistake returned under new vocabulary.
Maximus

A nature without a will is not complete

Maximus the Confessor, a monk with little institutional power, argued from Chalcedon's own logic. Will is a natural faculty, so a complete human nature has a human will alongside the divine one, always freely conformed to it. Take it away and Gethsemane becomes a divine will performing a human-looking gesture. A human will that was never truly Christ's own is a human will that was never healed.

핵심 The soteriological axiom from the previous lecture is back on the table.
Scripture

Why Matthew 26:39?

Gethsemane shows Jesus asking for one thing and submitting to another, which Maximus read as a real human will conforming itself to the divine will.

He went forward a little, fell on his face, and prayed, saying, 'My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass away from me; nevertheless, not what I desire, but what you desire.'" Matthew 26:39 · World English Bible
The cost

What Maximus paid

Tried for treason as much as heresy, Maximus was subjected by imperial order in 662 to the amputation of his tongue and right hand. The aim was that he could neither preach nor write his position again. He died in exile about two decades before the council that confirmed he was right. The church has remembered this as part of the argument itself.

핵심 Being right did not protect a theologian from a severe personal price.
Scripture

Why Hebrews 5:7?

The lecture uses "strong crying and tears" as the language of a will that felt the full weight of what it asked and then chose to submit.

He, in the days of his flesh, having offered up prayers and petitions with strong crying and tears to him who was able to save him from death, and having been heard for his godly fear," Hebrews 5:7 · WEB
At a glance

Two ways to read Chalcedon's "two natures"

Chalcedonian churches

Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and most Protestants hold that the two-natures language is the necessary safeguard against a real and historically demonstrated danger.

Oriental Orthodox churches

They hold, with their own unbroken tradition running back through Cyril, that Chalcedon's formula is not the necessary or best way to confess the same Christ.

Think about it

When does a formula divide?

If recent dialogues are right that the split rests more on terminology and mistrust than on a real difference about Christ, a form of words had become a test of communion.

How careful does the church need to be before letting a doctrinal formula become a communion-dividing test?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Chalcedon drew a fence but did not end the argument, and the Chalcedonian and Oriental Orthodox churches remain apart. Constantinople II (553) pruned an over-Antiochene reading, and Constantinople III (680-681) affirmed two wills, human and divine, with the human will freely following the divine. Everyone in these disputes was protecting the same claim. Be slow to make a form of words a test of communion.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 14