Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Youth, Marriage and Singleness
- Lecture 1-2: Who Is a Young Adult? Who Is Single?
- Lecture 1-3: How Churches Talk About Marriage and Singleness
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Go: Honest Motives
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The People Near Me and My Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: Work, Money, Home and the Unfinished Years
- Lecture 2-2: Belonging, Friendship and the Screen
- Lecture 2-3: Doubt, Questions and Leaving
- Lecture 2-4: Cultures of Young Adult Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Week in a Young Adult's Life
- Lecture 3-1: What Peer Ministry Is
- Lecture 3-2: Groups and Tables Anyone Can Join
- Lecture 3-3: Loneliness and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-4: Across Ages: Mentors, Elders and One-to-One Safely
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Message and a Table
- Lecture 4-1: Scripture on Love and Marriage, and How Traditions Differ
- Lecture 4-2: Dating and Sexual Ethics Without Condemnation
- Lecture 4-3: When Things Go Wrong
- Lecture 4-4: Dating Online, Messaging and Digital Life
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Hearing a Hard Story
- Lecture 5-1: Called to Singleness, Waiting to Marry, Choosing Not To
- Lecture 5-2: Divorced, Widowed, and Alone Again
- Lecture 5-3: Mental Health, Addiction and Crisis: Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-4: Single Parents, Carers and the People We Overlook
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Warm Referral
Nobody walks toward another person for one reason only. A friend who invites a new colleague to the young adult group wants that person to have a place. She also wants the group to feel lively. She is also a little lonely herself. All three are true on the same Thursday.
This lecture is about the reasons we have for walking beside young adults and single people, and about what to do with the ones we do not like. It argues that mixed motives are normal, that the question is not "are my motives pure?" but "do my motives harm the person?", and that a person is not a project. It also shows a short way to look at your own heart without punishing yourself.
If lecture 1-3 asked us to hear our words as others hear them, this lecture asks us to hear our motives as honestly as we can.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- Name several common motives for walking beside young adults and single people, including ones that are hard to admit.
- Explain why mixed motives are normal and why the useful question is whether a motive harms the person.
- Describe why treating a person as a project, a number, a volunteer or a possible spouse presses on them.
- Use a short, kind check on your own heart and decide what to do with a motive you do not like.
Therefore when you do merciful deeds, don’t sound a trumpet before yourself, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may get glory from men. Most certainly I tell you, they have received their reward." — Matthew 6:2
World English Bible
But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does," — Matthew 6:3
WEB
But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she came up to him, and said, “Lord, don’t you care that my sister left me to serve alone? Ask her therefore to help me.”" — Luke 10:40
WEB
If I dole out all my goods to feed the poor, and if I give my body to be burned, but don’t have love, it profits me nothing." — 1 Corinthians 13:3
WEB
No longer do I call you servants, for the servant doesn’t know what his lord does. But I have called you friends, for everything that I heard from my Father, I have made known to you." — John 15:15
WEB
Jesus does not ask us to have pure motives before we act. He asks us to look at them, and he names friendship, not service, as the form he gave his followers.
1. The honest list
(an invented example) A church asks Ruth, who is 29, to lead a small group for people in their twenties. She says yes. If you asked her why, on the first evening, she would say: "Because I want young people to feel at home." That is true. If you asked her again after a month, on a tired night, she might also say these things.
- "Because I was lonely in my twenties and nobody walked beside me."
- "Because I was asked and I find it hard to say no."
- "Because the pastor trusts me, and I like that."
- "Because the room was nearly empty, and I want it full."
- "Because I want to be needed."
- "Because I hope someone in the group will turn out to be a good friend."
- "Because I feel I ought to."
None of these cancels the first. All of them are in the room. A leader who has never admitted the second list is not more holy than Ruth. She is only less aware.
2. Common motives, named without shame
Here are some motives that many people who walk beside young adults and single people recognise. Read the list slowly and notice which ones you would prefer not to find.
Love. A real care for the person, which needs no explanation. Do not be embarrassed by it.
Duty. "It is my job", "I was asked", "this is what a good member does". Duty keeps people coming on tired days, and it is nothing to apologise for. It can also become a heavy sense of obligation that leaves no room for the person.
Gratitude. Someone once walked beside you. You want to pass it on.
Your own old wound. You were lonely, or misunderstood, or alone in a hard season, and you want to make sure someone else is not. This is one of the best motives and also the one that most needs watching, because you may begin to hear your own story in theirs and answer the wrong question.
Wanting a fuller room. A group of three feels like failure; a group of thirty feels like success. If the pull of numbers is strong, the person starts to look like a seat to be filled.
Wanting to be needed. To be the person someone turns to is a pleasant feeling, and for some people it is a hunger. It can lead to a helper who cannot let a friend grow, or cannot step back.
Wanting to be seen. A leader who likes to be admired, or to have a name in the church, is not unusual. The warning in Matthew 6:2 is for this: giving that is done to be seen already has its reward.
Fear for the person's faith. "If he leaves the church, what will happen?" Real concern, but it can slide into pressure, and the pressure is felt as distrust.
Wanting to fix. You see a person in pain and cannot bear it, so you act: advice, plans, introductions. Sometimes the act is for your comfort more than theirs.
Wanting a couple to look right. This one needs saying. In some churches there is a quiet longing to see single people paired up, because it makes the community feel complete. It is rarely admitted, and it leads straight to the matchmaking and the remarks that lecture 1-3 warned about.
Wanting to be liked. A leader who cannot bear to be disliked will give way where a friend should hold a line.
Wanting a friend. Leading is a way to meet people. Admitting that you want friendship, and not only to give it, is honest, and it is a good reason to be in the room, as long as you do not use the people in your care to meet it.
3. Why mixed motives are normal
Matthew 6:2-4 does not say "make sure your motives are perfect before you give". It says do not do it to be seen. The standard is a direction, not a perfect state. Paul says in 1 Corinthians 13:3 that a person can give everything and still lack love, which tells us that outward generosity is not proof of inner purity, and also that inner purity is not required to start. Martha in Luke 10:40 was serving, and serving well; the trouble was that her service had left her resentful, and she tried to hand the resentment to her sister. Jesus' reply (10:41-42) names what was happening to her. He does not tell her to stop serving, and he does not scold her. He sees her. (Some readers hear a mild rebuke in his words; either way, he answers her as a person and not as a worker.)
That gives a working rule. The question is not "are my motives pure?" because they never are. The question is "does this motive harm the person I am with?" A wish to be needed that makes me hover over a friend does harm. A wish to be needed that sits quietly in the background, while I let the friend do their own growing, harms nobody. The first has to change. The second can be named and left alone.
4. A person is not a project
There is one line that is easy to cross without noticing. It is when a person becomes the means to something else.
- A project. "I'm working on" a friend: to bring them back to church, to change a habit, to make them more committed. A person who senses that they are being worked on will withdraw, and they will be right to. The better phrase is "I'm with".
- A number. A friend who counts toward attendance, a growth chart or a report. Lecture 6-4 deals with this fully; for now, notice that a person should not have to be a statistic to be welcome.
- A volunteer. A friend who is valued for the tasks they take on. See lecture 1-3. A friend is not an employee, and the rule of thumb is that you should be asking about their week more often than you are asking for their help.
- A possible spouse. Treating a single friend as a candidate, for yourself, for someone you know or for the community's sense of order, is a form of use. If you notice yourself sizing someone up, step back and tell a trusted person.
- A proof of success. A young adult whose good outcome the leader needs for themselves. If the friend makes a choice you grieve, can you still sit beside them?
Notice what John 15:15 says. Jesus does not call his followers servants, who are told what to do without being told why. He calls them friends, to whom he makes known what he has heard. Friendship is the model for walking beside: mutual, open, not instrumental.
5. What about hoping for faith?
Some readers will wonder whether wanting a friend to know God is itself a bad motive. It is not. Most Christians hope for this and most will say so. The question is whether the hope is held or used.
A hope that is held says: "I would be glad if my friend came to faith or came back to it, and I will not make my friendship depend on it." A hope that is used says: "I will keep this friendship as long as it is leading somewhere." The person can usually tell the difference. A friend who has been treated as a conversion project will remember it for years, and so will their other friends.
This applies equally to the young adult who has left church and the single person who has never been. They are not a gap in your record. A person who is of another faith, or none, is not a project; a person who is of the same church is not a duty either.
6. A short, kind check of your own heart
When a motive in yourself troubles you, four plain questions help. They are not a test. They are a way to look.
- Name it. "Part of me is here because I want the room to look full." Say it, to yourself, in words. A named motive loses some of its grip.
- Ask whether it harms. Does this motive push the person, flatter them, use them or hold them? If not, you can let it be.
- Tell someone. A trusted friend, a mentor or your responsible person. Motives that stay secret tend to grow. A motive said aloud to a safe listener tends to shrink.
- Adjust one thing. Not everything, one. If you are leading because you want to be needed, you might this month let someone else set up the room.
What this check does not ask is self-punishment. Finding a motive in yourself that you do not like is not a failure. It is the beginning of honesty. Some people hear "examine your heart" as a call to condemn themselves, and then become so anxious that they cannot be present to anyone. That is a different kind of self-focus, and not what is asked.
7. When the motive is about your own life
A particular case deserves its own paragraph. If you are young or single yourself, some of your reasons for being in this ministry will be about your own life: loneliness, a hope to meet someone, a need for belonging. These are not shameful. You are one of the people this course is about.
But they do change what you must watch. Lecture 6-2 returns to this at length. For now: if you find that your feelings for a person you lead are growing, or that you are using your position to see a particular person, tell your responsible person early. That is not a confession of failure. It is what a wise leader does.
Diagram 1. A short, kind check
핵심 요약
- Mixed motives are normal; love, duty, gratitude, old wounds, wanting a full room and wanting to be needed can all be present at once.
- The useful question is whether a motive harms the person, not whether it is pure.
- A person is not a project, a number, a volunteer, a possible spouse or a proof of success.
- Friendship, not service, is the model Jesus names in John 15:15.
- A hope for a friend's faith may be held, but not used as a condition of the friendship.
- A short check: name the motive, ask whether it harms, tell someone, adjust one thing, without self-punishment.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Are mixed motives a failure? | No; they are normal. The question is whether a motive harms the person. |
| What does "a person is not a project" mean? | Do not treat anyone as something to work on, count, use as labour, pair off or prove yourself by. |
| What is the difference between holding and using a hope for faith? | Held: glad if it happens, friendship does not depend on it. Used: the friendship lasts only while it leads somewhere. |
| The four-step check? | Name it; ask whether it harms; tell someone; adjust one thing. |
One sentence to remember Look at your motives honestly and kindly, and ask not whether they are pure but whether they harm the person beside you.
This week's action Write down, privately, one motive you would rather not admit, and tell it to one trusted person.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which motive on the list would you least like to admit? What would change if you named it to a trusted person?
- Why does the lecture say the useful question is "does this motive harm the person?" and not "are my motives pure?"
- What is the difference between a hope for a friend's faith that is held and one that is used? How could a friend tell?
- Think of a time when you felt like a project, a number or a volunteer. What did you do?
- If you are young or single, what is one reason in your own life for wanting to be in this ministry? Does it need a boundary?