Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Call to Love the Truth
- Lecture 1-2: Kinds of Wrong Information and How They Work
- Lecture 1-3: Why We Are Fooled
- Lecture 1-4: Looking at My Information Habits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day of Information
- Lecture 2-1: Who Decides What I See
- Lecture 2-2: Why Anger and Fear Travel Fast
- Lecture 2-3: Bubbles and Echoes
- Lecture 2-4: Looking at My Screens and Adjusting Them
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, Review a Day of Feed and Make One Change
- Lecture 3-1: Asking Where It Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: Pausing and Checking
- Lecture 3-3: Manipulated Photos, Video and Audio
- Lecture 3-4: Checking One Claim
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Check One Claim
- Lecture 4-1: What Travels in Church Circles
- Lecture 4-2: Why Conspiracy Theories Attract
- Lecture 4-3: Correcting Gently and Truthfully
- Lecture 4-4: One Step Before Answering a Rumour
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Answer a Rumour in the Group Chat
- Lecture 5-1: Facing Questions That Divide
- Lecture 5-2: At the Table and in the Comments
- Lecture 5-3: Truth and Love Together
- Lecture 5-4: Preparing for a Hard Conversation
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Rehearse a Hard Conversation
The first three lectures of this week gave you ideas: sort the question, speak with care in the places where disagreement happens, and hold truth and love together. This lecture turns them into one small tool you can use before a hard conversation: a short plan, written on one page.
A hard conversation is one you would rather avoid. You may need to correct someone you love, answer a relative who has said something that troubles you, ask a friend to take down a post, or speak up in a meeting where a view is being treated as settled. Most people do not plan such conversations. They either avoid them for months or go in with a head full of heat. A plan does not make the conversation easy. It makes it likelier that you will say what you mean and not what you regret.
The plan is a help and not a script. People do not follow scripts, and a conversation that has been rehearsed to the last word will break at the first surprise. What a plan gives you is a purpose, a first sentence and a way out.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Name the six parts of a plan for a hard conversation and say what each is for.
- Decide, using the purpose question, what you want from a conversation before you begin.
- Write an opening sentence that states one concern without a label or an accusation.
- Recognise situations in which a conversation should not be held, and say who to go to instead.
Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29
World English Bible
Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:6
WEB
Paul asks that speech be good for building up as the need may be, and that it be seasoned with grace so that I know how to answer each person. Both verses suggest that speech can be prepared. The plan in this lecture is one way to prepare it. These verses are read as principles; they do not tell you what to say on any contested question.
1. Why plan at all
People who prepare for a talk with a doctor, a landlord or an employer know the feeling. Without preparation, the important thing is forgotten and the unimportant thing is said at length. Hard conversations in family and church are harder, because feelings are stronger and the relationship matters more.
A plan helps in four ways.
- It slows you down. Writing takes longer than speaking, and a slower pace gives you time to think.
- It separates the things you want to say from the things you only want to feel. You can see which is which on paper.
- It gives you a first sentence, which is often the hardest part.
- It prepares you for what you will do if it goes badly, so that you do not have to decide in the heat.
A plan also protects the other person. When you know what you want, you are less likely to unload everything that has been building.
2. The six parts of the plan
1. My purpose: what do I want from this conversation? Write one sentence. Be honest. The common purposes are these:
- To understand what the person thinks and why.
- To correct a fact that was passed on in error.
- To repair something that went wrong between us.
- To say where I stand, once, plainly, with no demand that they agree.
- To ask for something (to take down a post, to stop forwarding, to change a habit).
If your honest purpose is "to win" or "to make them feel bad," stop. That is not a purpose this course can help with, and it will not go well. Ask yourself what you are afraid of, and whether you need to talk to someone else first.
Notice that changing their mind is not on the list. You can hope for it. You cannot plan for it, because it is not in your power. A purpose should be something you can do.
2. Sorting: fact, value or interpretation? Look at what you want to say and sort it as in lecture 5-1. Which parts are facts you have checked? Which are values? Which are your reading of what someone meant? Mark the ones that are your interpretation, and plan to say them as such: "I read it as...", "It seemed to me...". And if there is a fact you have not checked, check it before you speak, or say "I am not sure."
3. The person: what do I know? Write a few lines. What does this person care about? What are they afraid of? What is their history with this subject? What time of day or week are they at their best? Is there someone else whose presence will help or harm? You are not preparing to manage them. You are preparing to see them.
4. The first words, and one question. Write your opening sentence. It should do four things:
- say that you care about the person or the relationship,
- state one concern, without a label or an accusation,
- say what you hope for,
- and invite the other person in.
Then write one question, one that really seeks to understand. If you have only a statement and no question, you are not planning a conversation. You are planning a speech.
5. One thing I might be wrong about. Write one sentence: "I may be wrong about..." It might be a fact you have not fully checked. It might be your reading of their motive. It might be how heavily to weigh something. This line is not a trick. It is a discipline, and it makes the conversation lighter. A person who has said "I may be wrong about..." and meant it is easier to talk to.
6. My way out. Write what you will do if it goes badly. Where will you stop? What sentence will you say? ("I think we should leave this for today.") Whom will you speak to afterward? And, importantly: what would make me stop at once? Threats, shouting that frightens you, any sign that someone is in danger or is being harmed: the conversation ends, and you go to a person who can help.
The plan in six lines
Purpose. Sorting. The person. First words and one question. One thing I may be wrong about. My way out.
3. Where you can use the plan, and where you cannot
The plan fits a wide range of situations where two people disagree or where one has a concern about the other: a forwarded message, a remark at a meal, a post that troubled you, a view stated in a meeting.
It does not fit some situations, and a person who uses it in those situations may do harm.
- Abuse, violence or a danger to a child. A conversation with the person is not the first step, and may make things worse. Go to the responsible person in your community's written policy (or the one above them, if that person is involved), the proper authorities under local law, and the local emergency number if there is danger now.
- A person in crisis. If someone seems to be in severe distress, speaks of harming themselves, or has lost touch with the things around them, they need a person who can be with them: a pastor, a qualified professional, the local emergency number if the danger is now. Do not argue with them about a news story. This course does not cover that care.
- A person who has power over you and who may punish you. Such a talk needs a trusted person beside you, and sometimes does not need to take place.
- A group that is already shouting. A hard conversation is for two, or a small circle. A crowded comment box is not the place.
4. A worked example: a message at the family table
(An invented example.) Lucia is a member of a congregation. Her cousin Tomasz has posted, in the family group, a message about a public matter. The message states a number as a fact, and Lucia has looked and found that the number is not supported by the source it names. She also finds the message unkind to people on one side. She knows that Tomasz is quick to take offence and that he is under strain at work.
Her plan:
- Purpose. To tell him that the number looks wrong, and to ask him to check it. I do not need him to agree with the rest.
- Sorting. Fact: the number is not in the source. Value: I think the tone toward the people is unfair; I will leave that for another day, because one thing at a time. Interpretation: I do not know whether he knew it was wrong.
- The person. Proud. Sensitive to being corrected in front of others. At his best on weekends, after the family lunch. Tired on weekdays.
- First words and question. "Tomasz, I wanted to talk to you privately, because I care about you and about the family group. I looked up the number in your post and I could not find it in the source. Did you see it there?"
- I may be wrong about. The source; there may be another one.
- My way out. If he gets angry, I will say, "I did not mean to start a quarrel. Let us leave it for now," and send him the link in a quiet message later. If he does not wish to speak, I will let it go. I will not write about it in the group.
Notice what Lucia did not plan. She did not plan to prove that Tomasz's whole view is wrong. She did not plan a rebuke in the family group. She did not plan to get him to apologise. Her purpose was small: one fact, between two people, with a way out.
A reader who thinks of the opposite case should note: if Tomasz's post had been unkind to the other side, and Lucia had held the view that the post supported, the plan would be the same. The number would still be unsupported, and she would still need to ask. That is the test from lecture 5-3: would I correct it if it were on the other side?
5. A second example: a view stated in a meeting
(An invented example.) In a church committee, Elena hears a member say that "everyone knows" a certain public plan is a plot of the other side. She believes the claim is both unfair and unproved. She is not sure it is her place, because she is not the chair.
Her plan is different from Lucia's, because the setting is different.
- Purpose. To say once, in the meeting, that I do not think we know that, and that I would like us to keep to what we can show. Not to correct the member in public beyond this.
- Sorting. Interpretation of motive, which cannot be shown.
- The person. A respected older member; a good heart.
- First words and question. "I want to be careful here. I do not think we can know what people intend, and I would like the committee to keep to what we can show. Could we agree to talk about the plan itself?" And a quiet word with the member after the meeting.
- I may be wrong about. That I heard him correctly.
- My way out. If the chair moves on, I will let it rest and follow up with the member in private.
This plan has a public part, and it stays small and aimed at the group's task. The private part is for the person. The two together are the shape of Matthew 18:15 in a small way: private for the person, public only where the group has a stake.
6. Writing the first sentence
The opening is the hardest part. A few forms that work, and a few that do not.
| Opens a door | Closes it |
|---|---|
| "I care about you, and there is something I would like to ask about." | "We need to talk." |
| "I noticed something in your post, and I wondered where you found it." | "I cannot believe you posted that." |
| "I may have this wrong, and I would like to understand." | "You are wrong, and here is why." |
| "I would like to say one thing, and then I will listen." | "Someone has to tell you." |
An opening that says only "We need to talk" frightens people. An opening that begins with an accusation starts a defence. A good opening gives a reason, names one concern, and leaves a door open.
7. After the conversation
Plan for the day after, too.
Thank them, briefly, for listening, whether or not they agreed.
Do not tell the story to others in a way that makes the other person look foolish. If you need to speak to a friend or pastor, keep it short and without names.
If you were wrong, say so quickly. "I looked again, and you were right about that part. I am sorry."
If it went badly, do not decide that the relationship is over. Many people need days to think. Send a short message of care. Then wait.
Look at the plan again. Which part helped? Which did you not use? What would you change next time? A plan improves with use.
A word for the person who says, "I did not use the plan, and it went fine." Good. A plan is a training aid. A person who has done it a few times may carry it in their head. The plan is for the times that frighten you.
Diagram 1. A plan for a hard conversation
핵심 요약
- A short written plan slows you down, separates what you want to say from what you want to feel, and gives you a first sentence and a way out.
- The plan has six parts: purpose, sorting, the person, first words and one question, one thing I may be wrong about, and my way out.
- A purpose must be something you can do. "Changing their mind" is a hope, not a purpose.
- A good opening gives a reason, names one concern and leaves a door open.
- The plan does not fit abuse, danger, a person in crisis or a shouting crowd: go to the responsible person.
- After the talk, thank them, do not tell the story to make them look foolish, and say quickly if you were wrong.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The six parts of the plan | Purpose; sorting; the person; first words and one question; one thing I may be wrong about; my way out. |
| Why "to change their mind" is not a purpose | It is not in my power; a purpose must be something I can do. |
| A good opening | Gives a reason, names one concern without a label, states a hope, and invites the other person. |
| When not to use the plan | Abuse, danger to a child, a person in crisis, a shouting group; go to a responsible person or the emergency number. |
One sentence to remember Before a hard conversation I write one page: what I want, what is fact, who this person is, my first words and one question, what I may be wrong about, and how I will stop.
This week's action Write the six lines for one conversation you have been avoiding, or for an invented one, and show them to nobody unless you choose to.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the five honest purposes is yours when you want to speak to someone? Which would you be ashamed to write?
- Why is "changing their mind" not a purpose the plan can use?
- What is the line in the plan you would find hardest to write: the person, the question, or the thing you may be wrong about?
- Think of a situation in which a conversation should not be held. Whom would you go to instead?
- Which opening sentence from the table do you tend to use?