무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

← 전체 강의

PT6E · 12장

Lecture 12-2: A Fair Evaluation of Short-Term Mission

The evidence on short-term mission is mixed, so the lecture sets the critique and the defense side by side and does not pick a winner.

Missiology: The Theology and Practice of Christian Mission

13장 전체 강의 12분

옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →

이 강의에서 배우는 것
  • State the documented critiques of short-term mission — dependency creation, disruption of national ministries' timelines, and questionable cost-effectiveness — in their strongest form, with named sources.
  • State the documented benefits — long-term recruitment, giving increases, and genuine partnership when done well — equally fairly, with named sources.
  • Explain why this course does not resolve this evaluation for the reader, and what a responsible reader should do with an unresolved question instead of forcing a premature conclusion.
Scripture

Why 1 Corinthians 10:33?

The lecture lists this verse as its scripture for the evaluation. It speaks of not seeking one's own profit but the profit of the many.

even as I also please all men in all things, not seeking my own profit, but the profit of the many, that they may be saved." 1 Corinthians 10:33 · World English Bible
The critique

Dependency and dignity

Robert Lupton's Toxic Charity gives the sharpest, most cited case against poorly structured service. His claim is that well-meant charity, including trips that arrive, do a task the community could do itself, and leave, can create dependency and weaken local dignity. His oath begins: never do for the poor what they have the capacity to do for themselves.

핵심 Doing what locals could do can do harm.
The evidence

The Honduras house study

Kurt Alan Ver Beek studied house rebuilding after Hurricane Mitch in Honduras. He compared homes built by short-term volunteer teams with homes built by other means. He found no statistically significant difference in the families' long-term satisfaction or well-being, though the volunteer houses cost much more. The study does not claim the teams caused harm.

핵심 Benefit to recipients may not match the cost.
More concerns

Other critics' worries

Other critics add related concerns. One is poverty tourism, where the main benefit goes to the visitors' own spiritual experience. Another is disruption when a team's schedule interrupts a national ministry's timeline or the local labor market. A third is unequal power when a wealthier team arrives with resources a national partner cannot match.

핵심 Critics point to tourism, disruption, and power.
The defense

Lasting change in the sender

Defenders look at a different kind of evidence: whether the trip changes the sender in ways that bear lasting fruit. Robert Priest's edited volume gathers researchers who take the criticisms seriously. It documents that a meaningful share of long-term missionaries and agency staff call a short-term trip, often in youth or college years, a formative or decisive step toward their calling.

핵심 Trips are a commonly reported activating experience.
More benefits

Giving and partnership

Robert Wuthnow's research found that congregations with active short-term programs tend to give more to international mission and stay more engaged. Defenders also point to trips built around a national partner's own request and existing relationship. The next lecture describes this model as the corrective.

핵심 Giving rises, and partner-led trips do better.
Common ground

Where the two sides agree

Lupton

He does not argue that all outside help is harmful. His objection is to help that bypasses or displaces a community's own capacity.

Priest's volume

It does not argue that every trip is beneficial. It documents real harm and real benefit, and asks what separates them.

The real dispute

Both sides agree harm and benefit occur. They differ on which is more typical and how to weigh sender benefit against recipient cost.

Left open

Why no winner is declared

The evidence is mixed because cost-effectiveness research and vocational-impact research measure different things. A reader could weigh them differently depending on what a church's program is trying to do. What the course insists on is that a church cannot claim the benefits while ignoring the conditions under which the critiques do not apply.

핵심 An honest reckoning, not a declared winner.
Think about it

Strongest form first

The lecture asks readers to state each side in its strongest form before adding any rebuttal.

How would you state Lupton's critique in your own words, without immediately answering it?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Both sides agree that harm and benefit occur. The real dispute is which is more typical and how to weigh sender benefit against recipient cost. Decide what your short-term program is for, and weigh both the critique and the benefits against that purpose.

이것은 강의가 아니라 개요입니다.

이 카드는 짧은 미리보기입니다. 읽은 기록은 전체 강의를 읽을 때만 남고, 장 퀴즈와 시험은 전체 강의의 내용을 묻습니다.

전체 강의 읽기 →

1 / 13