Lecture 5-3: War, Peace, and Just War Theory
Pacifism and just war theory read the same two texts and reach different conclusions about how they fit together.
Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Pacifism and just war theory read the same two texts and reach different conclusions about how they fit together.
Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Few questions in Christian ethics divide careful believers more sharply, and both sides claim the same Lord and the same canon. The pacifist position is represented by the historic peace churches and Stanley Hauerwas. The just war tradition runs from Augustine into a defined set of criteria. The lecture states both at the strength their own best defenders would recognize as fair.
The lecture uses this verse as the root of the pacifist case. Jesus intensifies the principle of an eye for an eye into a refusal to retaliate, though the lecture notes the blow described is an insult, not a lethal attack.
'You have heard that it was said, "An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth." But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also.'" Matthew 5:38-39 · World English Bible
The lecture uses this verse as the text the just war tradition reads as authorizing the state's use of force. It describes the ruler as a servant of God who does not bear the sword in vain.
for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn't bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." Romans 13:4 · WEB
The pacifist case rests on Jesus's whole life, including his rebuke of Peter in Gethsemane and his going to the cross without resistance. Hauerwas, in The Peaceable Kingdom, argues that nonviolence is not one policy among others. He says it is constitutive of what the church is for, a visible alternative community. The historic peace churches hold a related conviction through refusing military service and accepting persecution rather than take up arms.
Augustine wrote in the early fifth century, partly in response to Rome's sack in 410. His starting point was a sober judgment that a fallen world sometimes offers a choice between kinds of violence, not between violence and peace. He read Romans 13:4 as allowing a legitimate authority to restrain evil, because refusing to do so leaves victims undefended. A soldier under lawful authority is not thereby acting outside Christian ethics.
Just cause requires a genuine wrong to be righted or prevented. Legitimate authority means only a properly constituted government may wage war, not private persons. Right intention means the aim is a just peace, not vengeance or conquest.
Last resort means non-military means have been genuinely exhausted. Proportionality means the anticipated harm must not exceed the good aimed at. Discrimination means force is directed only at combatants.
The lecture says just war theory is not approval of any war a Christian's nation undertakes. A war that lacks just cause, or fails proportionality or discrimination, is unjust on the tradition's own terms. A faithful Christian committed to the framework should then oppose it or refuse to take part. A war begun with real just cause can still become unjust in its conduct.
Matthew 5 governs a believer's personal response to insult, while Romans 13 governs the state's distinct, divinely authorized role. The two texts are not addressing the same question.
Jesus's teaching describes the church's whole way of being. Romans 13 describes how the world's kingdoms function, and does not commission individual Christians to do the same.
The lecture says readers should be able to state the view they do not hold in words its defenders would accept as fair.
Which reading of the relation between Matthew 5:38-39 and Romans 13:4 do you find more persuasive, and how would a person equally committed to Scripture explain the other one?
Both traditions claim loyalty to Christ and the whole Bible, and neither treats violence as good in itself. They differ on how Matthew 5:38-39 relates to Romans 13:4. Be able to state the other side's view fairly, and keep pastoral care open to believers on both sides.