Lecture 6-3: Sanctity of Life in the Biotech Age
The same dignity doctrine from 6-1 is applied to gene editing, IVF and surrogacy, each with a real promise and a real peril.
Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
The same dignity doctrine from 6-1 is applied to gene editing, IVF and surrogacy, each with a real promise and a real peril.
Systematic Theology IX: Christian Ethics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
The lecture takes the doctrine from 6-1 into two areas that biotechnology has made urgent. Genetic engineering can now edit a human genome, and reproductive technology can create human life outside the process Scripture assumes. Both have a genuine promise and a genuine peril. The lecture argues these are not a new topic needing a new foundation, but the same question asked at a different point of possibility.
The lecture uses this passage because Job pictures God directly framing, fashioning and knitting together a human body. It then asks what human hands doing some of that fashioning should mean.
'Your hands have framed me and fashioned me altogether, yet you destroy me. Remember, I beg you, that you have fashioned me as clay. Will you bring me into dust again? Haven't you poured me out like milk, and curdled me like cheese? You have clothed me with skin and flesh, and knit me together with bones and sinews. You have granted me life and loving kindness. Your visitation has preserved my spirit.'" Job 10:8-12 · World English Bible
It alters one patient's body cells and is not passed to children. Most Christian ethicists treat it like other medicine, raising ordinary questions of safety, consent, access and cost.
It alters embryos, eggs or sperm, so the change is heritable. The edited embryo cannot consent, and neither can the descendants who will carry it, which is why it is far more contested.
In 2018 He Jiankui announced he had edited embryos that became twin girls, a germline edit without adequate justification or oversight. It drew near-universal condemnation. The deeper peril is a slide from treating disease to selecting traits. The lecture says screening that selects against embryos with conditions such as Down syndrome implies that disabled lives are worth less, which the doctrine of the image of God resists.
A child comes as the fruit of an act of love between spouses, the same kind of being as the parents, received as a gift.
A child as the artifact of a technical process, designed, evaluated against a specification and subject to quality control. Oliver O'Donovan says the more a process resembles manufacture, the more it treats a child as a product.
The lecture starts from real sympathy, since Sarah, Rachel and Hannah all treat childlessness as a genuine sorrow. IVF typically creates more embryos than are transferred, and the surplus are frozen, donated for research or discarded. If the image of God applies from the embryo's formation, this raises the same moral question as abortion by a different route. The lecture does not forbid every form of help, but says the number of embryos and what happens to the rest cannot be set aside.
The lecture names two concerns, not a flat verdict. Commercial surrogacy risks treating the woman's reproductive capacity as a purchased service, especially across economic disparities. It can also fragment motherhood, so a child may have a genetic, gestational and rearing mother who are three different women. Altruistic arrangements within a family may not raise these concerns equally.
The lecture treats surrogacy through two concerns, not a flat rule.
What further facts about a specific surrogacy arrangement would most change your own assessment of it?
The line between somatic and heritable germline editing governs the lecture, because future descendants cannot consent to a permanent change. Meet infertility with real sympathy, and help couples face the questions about embryos and technique before they begin.