Lecture 9-3: Design Arguments and Their Scientific Critics
Irreducible complexity is a contested biological claim, and it is not the same kind of case as fine-tuning.
Christian Apologetics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
Irreducible complexity is a contested biological claim, and it is not the same kind of case as fine-tuning.
Christian Apologetics
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
Michael Behe, a biochemist, introduced the term in his 1996 book Darwin's Black Box. He describes a system of several well-matched, interacting parts in which removing any one part makes the system effectively cease functioning. He argues that natural selection can only preserve small functional steps, so such a system could not be assembled gradually.
Behe's best-known illustration is the bacterial flagellum, a rotary molecular motor some bacteria use for propulsion. It is built from dozens of protein parts, including a rotor, a stator, a universal joint and a propeller-like filament. Behe compares it to a designed outboard motor.
Kenneth Miller, a biologist and a practicing Catholic, accepts that the flagellum is remarkable but denies that no gradual pathway to it is possible. He points to the Type III secretion system, a simpler machine that shares many protein components with the base of the flagellum. The argument is not that it is a missing link. It is that a related, independently functional system exists built from a smaller subset of the parts.
Co-option means that a structure performing one function is repurposed, sometimes together with other formerly independent structures, to perform a new one. Critics propose that some of the flagellum's parts had a different function first, secretion, before later modification and gene duplication produced the full motor. They extend the same strategy to other systems Behe cites, including the biochemical cascade in blood clotting.
Proposing a co-option pathway in outline is not the same as showing that each step was viable and reachable by small mutations. In their assessment the detailed pathway has not been shown.
The Type III system and related findings defeat the strong claim that no pathway is conceivable. A complete step-by-step history is not yet reconstructed, which they attribute to the difficulty of reconstructing ancient history.
It rests on physical constants whose measured values are essentially uncontested. The controversy is about which explanation fits: chance, necessity or design.
It rests on a specific biological claim that certain systems have no possible gradual history. The underlying facts themselves are disputed by working scientists on both sides.
Psalm 139:14 grounds appreciation of biological complexity in worship rather than in the outcome of one scientific controversy. The lecture says the verse would remain true however biologists resolve this debate. Tying a doctrine of providence too tightly to one contested argument risks making the doctrine depend on that argument.
The lecture notes that Kenneth Miller is a practicing Catholic.
Why might the lecture name that fact, and what assumption about this debate does it push back against?
Behe argues that systems like the flagellum cannot be built step by step. Miller answers that the Type III system suggests a route through co-option, and the full history is still unfinished. Fine-tuning rests on accepted physics, while this argument rests on a disputed biological claim, so do not treat them as equally strong.